Hal Super Verandah Suite Or Celebrity Sky Suite

[SueOverend]

Have cruised 3 times with Celebrity, but am looking to choose between the above two options. As it's my 50th birthday, we thought we'd try a suite for the first time and have the choice of a Sky Suite on the Millennium or a Superior Verandah Suite on the Westerdam. The HAL option is cheaper and a larger stateroom, but have not been with HAL before and am really not sure which to choose.

Any input would be most appreciated.

[dakrewser]

Hmm, a category SS on HAL versus an "SS" (Sky Suite) on Celebrity. The HAL suite is a good 50% bigger, I believe, but has nothing to compare with the butler service on Celebrity (you'd need an S or PS category for that). So it really boils down to space or perks - which do you prefer? Make that choice and the choice of accomodation is much simpler.