We are not fans of the Caribbean, particularly the Western Caribbean. At this point we rarely get off the ship in the Caribbean. If itinerary is the key factor then the Eclipse wins. If the decision is based on which ship then for us the Beyond wins.
We love the E class ships; the modern look, the 4MDRs, the new venues and specialty restaurants, the theater and entertainment are all great.
We have the Eclipse booked for October, we have been on her many times but chose her for the itinerary. I’m having a hard time getting excited about the cruise wishing it were on a new ship.