Go Back   Cruise Critic Message Board Forums > Cruise Discussion Topics > Ask a Cruise Question
 
Register here!
Forgot Your Password?


Notices

Ask a Cruise Question Post your general cruise questions here.

Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
  #1  
Old August 25th, 2012, 11:35 AM
Mrs Harley Mrs Harley is offline
Cool Cruiser
 
Join Date: Aug 2012
Location: United States
Posts: 56
Default Transatlantic ...Cunard v NCL

I hope I am posting this is the right place.

Jut wondered if anyone can give me any feedback on the better of the 2 lines for a transatlantic crossing.

Our first cruise was on the QM2 last year from NY to Southampton. Next year we are booked for a 7 night Western Caribbean cruise with NCL on the Star. We received our brochure from NCL today and I noticed that the Star sails from NOLA to Dover ... which would be great for us as we live 6 hours drive from NOLA and Dover is right between where our families live in Kent. This would save us so much time..my question is has anyone done this route with both cruise lines and can you tell me how they compared with regard to handling the weather conditions and sea swells...

Thanks
__________________
Mrs H

First Cruise: Oct 2011 - Cunard Transatlantic NY to Southampton













Reply With Quote

  #2  
Old August 25th, 2012, 12:23 PM
Keith1010 Keith1010 is online now
50,000+ Club
 
Join Date: Jul 2000
Posts: 65,188
Default

The QM2 handles a crossing better than most any ship afloat so it will be much better than NCL in that regard and it is a much different experience in terms of the on board feel.

Keith
Reply With Quote

  #3  
Old August 25th, 2012, 12:34 PM
Starbright's Avatar
Starbright Starbright is offline
Cool Cruiser
 
Join Date: Aug 2004
Location: UK
Posts: 673
Default

The QM2 is an ocean liner rather than a cruise ship, so will always handle bad weather better.
__________________
Reply With Quote

  #4  
Old August 25th, 2012, 06:52 PM
CaveDiving's Avatar
CaveDiving CaveDiving is offline
Cool Cruiser
 
Join Date: May 2008
Posts: 1,316
Default

IMHO, comparing Cunard to NCL is kind of like comparing Ruth's Chris to McDonald's.

Scott & Karen
__________________

78 Britanis/Caribbean...................06 Saphire Princess/Mexico..........06 Crown Princess/Caribbean….. 06 Crown Princess/Caribbean...06 Norwegian Dream/Mexico
06 Oceania Regata/Amazon…....07 Prinsendam/Grand S. America..07 Regal Princess/Hawaii…........…07 Regal Princess/Hawaii…......07 Maasdam/E. Canada
07 Maasdam/Voyage of Vikings...07 Carnival Conquest/Caribbean...08 Amsterdam/Grand World…..…..08 Amsterdam/Panama Canal..08 Amsterdam/Alaska
08 Amsterdam/Alaska……….…...08 Amsterdam/Grand Asia…..…....09 Prinsendam/Grand S. America..09 Prinsendam/Grand Med.......09 Maasdam/E. Canada
09 Maasdam/E. Canada….…......09 Maasdam/Voyage of Vikings......09 Zaandam/Hawaii........................09 Amsterdam/Panama Canal..10 Amsterdam/Grand World
10 Amsterdam/Grand Asia...........10 Amsterdam/Panama Canal.......11 Amsterdam/Grand World…….....11 Amsterdam/Panama Cana…11 Amsterdam/Alaska
11 Amsterdam/Grand Asia...........11 Amsterdam/Panama Canal…....11 Amsterdam/Caribbean…..….…..11 Amsterdam/Caribbean.........12 Amsterdam/Grand World
12 Amsterdam/Panama Canal.....12 Maasdam/E. Canada.……........12 Maasdam/East USA …..…......…12 Maasdam/Mediterranean.....12 Maasdam/S. Caribbean
12 Maasdam/E. Caribbean….…...12 Maasdam/S. Caribbean……....13 Amsterdam/Grand World............13 Amsterdam/Panama Canal..13 Amsterdam/Alaska
13 Amsterdam/Alaska..................13 Amsterdam/Pacific coast...........14 Amsterdam/Grand World ….......14 Amsterdam/Panama Canal..14 Amsterdam/Alaska
14 Prinsendam/Amazon...............14 Prinsendam/Caribbean…..........15 Prinsendam/Grand S. America..15 Prinsendam/Grand Med.......15 Prinsendam/West. Europe
15 Prinsendam/Baltic...................15 Amsterdam/Inca Empire............15 Amsterdam/Panama Canal........16 Amsterdam/Grand World.....16 Amsterdam/Panama Canal
Reply With Quote

  #5  
Old August 25th, 2012, 08:40 PM
rdsqrl rdsqrl is offline
5,000+ Club
 
Join Date: Mar 2007
Posts: 8,398
Default

Well, you've already done the TA on the Queen Mary, so you have a good idea of what that's like. Even ocean liners can run into rough weather and rough seas -- we had 1.5 days of extremely rough (as in, nobody allowed out on the open decks) seas even on the QE2. That said, certainly a liner like the QM is going to handle seas better than a cruise ship.

The onboard experience, however, will be polar opposite in tone. Really. You can just literally imagine the exact opposite of everything you experienced onboard the QM and that's pretty much how your NCL experience will be. If the timing works, wait until after your Caribbean NCL cruise and you'll have a better feel for whether that atmosphere is something you care to experience for an entire TA.
Reply With Quote

Ad Sponsored By
  #6  
Old August 25th, 2012, 08:43 PM
CruiserBruce's Avatar
CruiserBruce CruiserBruce is offline
10,000+ Club
 
Join Date: Jul 2000
Location: Petaluma, Ca. 94954
Posts: 19,068
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by CaveDiving View Post
IMHO, comparing Cunard to NCL is kind of like comparing Ruth's Chris to McDonald's.

Scott & Karen
No kidding Not sure there could be a much different set of things to compare!
Reply With Quote

  #7  
Old August 26th, 2012, 11:04 AM
Mrs Harley Mrs Harley is offline
Cool Cruiser
 
Join Date: Aug 2012
Location: United States
Posts: 56
Default

Thanks for your replies... we obviously know the on board experience will be very different and the difference in the type of ship.

On the QM2 we were in a force 9 gale and the only discomfort we had was the heat as the outside doors were closed off... luckily we had a balcony and were able to get some air. My question was really ( and maybe I didnt word it too well) about how the different ships handle the weather...is the roll and swell very noticeable....
__________________
Mrs H

First Cruise: Oct 2011 - Cunard Transatlantic NY to Southampton













Reply With Quote

  #8  
Old August 26th, 2012, 11:08 AM
Mrs Harley Mrs Harley is offline
Cool Cruiser
 
Join Date: Aug 2012
Location: United States
Posts: 56
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by CaveDiving View Post
IMHO, comparing Cunard to NCL is kind of like comparing Ruth's Chris to McDonald's.

Scott & Karen
I actually think your response was kind of rude...we are not idiots and were not asking for comparison of the cruise experience which even to novice cruisers like ourselves would be noticeably different.... but on the difference in the way the ships handle.
__________________
Mrs H

First Cruise: Oct 2011 - Cunard Transatlantic NY to Southampton













Reply With Quote

  #9  
Old August 26th, 2012, 08:26 PM
kitty9 kitty9 is offline
20,000+ Club
 
Join Date: Oct 2000
Location: Moon Township, Pa
Posts: 22,117
Default

The handling of the seas will be much better on a Cunard ship that's built specifically for trans Atlantic crossings. If you're in a storm on NCL, you will definitely feel it much more. I know I did when we were on NCL Dream. She did not take the swells very well at all. And it was only 15 ft waves. On the QM2, we had 25ft seas and hardly felt a thing on her.
__________________
Darcie
Reply With Quote

  #10  
Old August 27th, 2012, 11:18 AM
Mrs Harley Mrs Harley is offline
Cool Cruiser
 
Join Date: Aug 2012
Location: United States
Posts: 56
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by kitty9 View Post
The handling of the seas will be much better on a Cunard ship that's built specifically for trans Atlantic crossings. If you're in a storm on NCL, you will definitely feel it much more. I know I did when we were on NCL Dream. She did not take the swells very well at all. And it was only 15 ft waves. On the QM2, we had 25ft seas and hardly felt a thing on her.

Thank you
__________________
Mrs H

First Cruise: Oct 2011 - Cunard Transatlantic NY to Southampton













Reply With Quote

  #11  
Old August 27th, 2012, 03:23 PM
loubetti's Avatar
loubetti loubetti is offline
Cool Cruiser
 
Join Date: Jul 2008
Posts: 1,568
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by CaveDiving View Post
IMHO, comparing Cunard to NCL is kind of like comparing Ruth's Chris to McDonald's.

Scott & Karen
Bingo!

Rude or not, QM2 is an ocean liner, as stated above, and you know this already. Now, granted, the cruise ships take a southerly route, which can be smoother, maybe. But for me, if I want to cross the Atlantic on a ship, it will be QM2 and nothing else. I've been on force 12 seas on QE2 and QM2, and I would NOT want to be on any ordinary cruise ship in those conditions, regardless of it's size.

I recall when QE2 got hit by a rogue wave, almost 100' high, and she just went about her business, and they did not repair the dented forecastle plating for almost a year! If that wave had hit a cruise ship, you would be talking major structural damage, injuries, and potential loss of life.
__________________
Best regards,

Lou Betti
Boca Raton, FL

The late, great Regal Empress. One of the
longest serving passenger ships of all time.
...............1953 to 2009.....................

On board QE2 for the last trans-Atlantic
of the 20th Century, December 1999 & 2000

On board QM2 for her maiden trans-Atlantic
to New York, April 2004

I love to cruise, but my flying comes first!
Cessna 210N Turbo Centurion.

44 cruises since 1985 and I am too lazy to mention them all! However, I do own the Builder's Certificate to the the RMS Queen Elizabeth. A lot of good that does me! Ships sailed on: Costa Riviera. Home Lines Atlantic. Cunard QE2 & QM2. Premier Cruise's Sea Breeze & Rembrandt. Celebrity Zenith, Century, Galaxy & Millennium. Bahamas Celebration, and my favorite ship of all, Regal Empress! Cunard Diamond, Celebrity Elite, RCI Diamond (and I've yet to sail on RCI!!)

Last edited by loubetti; August 27th, 2012 at 03:32 PM.
Reply With Quote

  #12  
Old August 27th, 2012, 05:56 PM
LadyShiva LadyShiva is offline
Cool Cruiser
 
Join Date: Feb 2007
Posts: 1,600
Default

Mrs. Harley, you might get a wider range of people who've actually crossed the Atlantic on NCL ships here: http://boards.cruisecritic.com/forumdisplay.php?f=107

I don't have an opinion of how well NCL ships fare on the Atlantic because I haven't yet crossed the Atlantic on Cunard or NCL.

I've heard the crossing can have dramatically different weather, between "sea of glass" and "oh my GOSH, that's a big wave!" I'm looking forward to your review, if you post one!
__________________
Reply With Quote

Reply

Bookmarks


Ad Sponsored By
Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Forum Jump


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 08:06 AM.


© 1995 - 2014, The Independent Traveler, Inc. All rights reserved.
"A Community of People Who Love To Cruise"
All of the information contained within Cruise Critic is protected by copyright. You may, however, download a single copy only for your personal use.