NCL Jade or MSC Divina

Welcome to Cruise Critic! If you'd like to participate on our forums by joining in the conversation, please Register Now! Be sure to visit our FAMOUS Roll Call forums, where you can meet other cruisers sailing with you and share a tour or shore excursion and SAVE MONEY!

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts
BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
All times are GMT -4.
The time now is 05:25 AM.
#1
462 Posts
Joined Mar 2006
Trying to compare Norweigan Jade and MSC Divina for a possible cruise June 22nd.

So far here are my thoughts, any input that can help me make a decision?

MSC Divina has only set time dining and buffet, gorgeous, a little more formal I think with regards to clothing, new ship and very international passenger set. Any chance lots of British kids on board or they not out of school yet? Limited hours in ports and not sure why? Food gets mixed reviews and no free water so fator that into the cost. I think also no free room service.


NCL Jade- older ship, more geared toward North Americans so more English spoken, but not sure if that is the case considering the location, food doesn't get great reviews, but compared to MSC not sure which is better, anytime dining and very casual clothing like jeans are allowed. longer times in port. I went on this ship before the remodel on a cruise to Hawaii and it was nice then, but very tropical looking, not sure what it would look like in the Med.

Can anyone compare the kids club facilities? Compare the food or the feel? For our family of 4 the base price is almost the same, so just trying to figure out more info to decide!


Jenn
#2
Nottingham, England
2,141 Posts
Joined Sep 2009
There won't be British school kids on board unless they are under 5 as schools don't break up in the UK till mid July at the earliest.

Not sailed on MSC but will be on the Jade very soon!
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
COMING UP!!!

MSC MERAVIGLIA - JULY 2017

SAILED!

Britannia - P&O Cruises - Mini Cruise to Bruges - May 2017 - 2 nights - (Superior Deluxe Balcony)
REVIEW - http://boards.cruisecritic.co.uk/showthread.php?t=2502268
Celebrity Reflection - Miami to Puerto Rico, St Thomas & St Maarten - April 2016 - 7 nights - (Aqua Class Hump Balcony)
REVIEW - http://boards.cruisecritic.co.uk/sho....php?t=2334071

NCL Escape - NCL - Inaugural Cruise from Hamburg to Southampton - Oct 2015 - 3 nights - (Spa Mini Suite Balcony)
REVIEW - Still not finished - sorry!

Britannia - P&O Cruises - Norwegian Fjords - June 2015 - 7nights - (Superior Deluxe Balcony)
REVIEW! http://boards.cruisecritic.co.uk/sho....php?t=2230373

Azamara Quest - Azamara Club Cruises - Cruise to the Greek Islands and Turkey - June 2014
7 nights (Balcony)

REVIEW!
http://boards.cruisecritic.com/showthread.php?t=2063572

Norwegian Jade - NCL - Eastern Med from Rome - March 2013 - 10 nights (Mini Suite Balcony)
REVIEW!
http://boards.cruisecritic.com/showt...hlight=kikki21

Norwegian Epic - NCL - Hurricane Earl West/East
Caribbean special from Miami - August 2010 - 7 nights (Balcony)
Splendour of the Seas - RCCL - Eastern Med from Venice - October 2009 - 7 nights (Outside)
Celebrity Galaxy - Celebrity - Eastern Med from Rome - October 2008 - 10 nights (Concierge Class Balcony)
Majesty of the Seas - RCCL - Bahamas from Miami - Nov 2007 - 4 nights (Outside)
#4
Flekkefjord, Norway
148 Posts
Joined Mar 2011
Originally posted by AquamarineBreeze
I haven't been on Msc ...

But as far as kids are concerned you may find more Italian children since elementary schools finish mid- June in Italy.

The Jade and its crew are lovely.
And Italian kids are IRRITATING

I would pick Jade.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Best regards,
Oskar!
89days at sea and counting
Gold latitude with Norwegian Cruise Line and platiunum C&A with RCCL
Completed:
  • Hurtigruten MS Trollfjord July 2009
  • Norwegian Epic August 2011
  • Norwegian Gem December 2012
  • Norwegian Jade August 2013
  • Independence of the Seas October 2014
  • Norwegian Getaway December 2014
  • Anthem of the Seas May 2015
  • Pride of Hawaii 9th May 2015
  • Queen Elizabeth 6th January 2016
  • Hurtigruten MS Nordlys 7th of April 2016
  • Queen Mary 2 25th of May 2016 pre-refit cruise
  • Harmony of the Seas 23rd October 2016 transatlantic Barcelona - Fort Lauderdale
  • Costa Deliziosa 21st of December 2016 Christmas cruise
Upcoming:
  • Norwegian Bliss 21st of April 2018 transatlantic Southampton - New York
  • Symphony of the Seas October 28th 2018 transatlantic Barcelona - Miami
  • Norwegian Bliss March 30th 2019 Panama Canal Miami - Los Angeles
#5
San Francisco Bay Area, CA
1,726 Posts
Joined Apr 2010
Originally posted by Califonria cruiser
NCL Jade - I went on this ship before the remodel on a cruise to Hawaii and it was nice then, but very tropical looking, not sure what it would look like in the Med.
We liked the Jade and loved the spa on sea days and in the evenings. We also prefer freestyle dining and the speciality restaurants.

The Jade still has the Hawaii decor - flowers everywhere (carpet, walls, ceiling), tiki statues in the buffet area and the main dining room is beautiful but completely Hawaiian in decor.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature



Norwegian Sky - Havana Cuba August 2017
Norwegian Star - Adrift off the Southern Australia coast Feb. 2017
Norwegian Gem - Southern Caribbean Nov. 2016
Norwegian Sun - South America westbound Jan. 2016
Norwegian Pearl -Vancouver Sept. 2015 & Miami Nov. 2015
Norwegian Star - Baltic Capitals May 2015 & Iceland Sept. 2013 & NOLA Jan. 2013
Norwegian Jade - Rome, Istanbul March 2014 & Barcelona Feb. 2011
Norwegian Dawn - Boston to Quebec City - October 2012
Norwegian Pride of America - Hawaii - Dec. 2011
RCCL - Splendour of the Seas - Venice, Greece, Turkey - May 2010
M/N Santa Cruz - Galapagos - August 2004
NCL Windward - Alaska - August 1996
NCL M/S Starward - Eastern Caribbean - Nov. 1991
MTS Pegasus - Greek Isles - July 1990
NCL M/S Southward - Baja Mexico - Sept. 1988
#6
California
1,749 Posts
Joined Feb 2005
It's more of a cultural difference between the two.
MSC (we were on the Splendida, not Divina)--food was great, many varieties in the MDR. More Italian passengers who might act differently than what you are used to. US passengers will get water vouchers for dinner. 1 coupon book per cabin, not enough but we made it work for us. Just have to prepare for the cultural difference and you will be fine. Excellent itineraries and good price for cruising. Service was good but it was difficult to find someone responsible at a higher level when there's a problem.

NCL Jade--food in MDR had declined. No more escargot or creme brulee, or come to think of it, shrimp cocktail. Maybe because we were in the suite this time so it didn't bother us that much. We had breakfast and lunch at Cagney's. More casual and relax on NCL. I felt more "at home" on the Jade.

My brother asked me if I would ever sail MSC again, my answer was "If the itinerary is interesting and the price is right."

I have pictures of both cruises if you want to look for them in my signature.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Welcome to My Blog

8 Other Cruises between 1993~2007 on NCL, Princess, Celebrity, Victoria and Carnival
2008-Carnival Splendor 8-day Inaugural Genoa to Dover
2008-Carnival Splendor 12-day Baltic
2008-NCL Star Mexican Riviera
2009-Victoria Queen-Yangtze River, China (Shanghai to Chongqing)
2009-HAL Zaandam-Alaska
2010-NCL Gem-14-day B/B Venice (Adriatic, Turkey, Greek Isles)
2011-Diamond Princess-Alaska 12-day Cruisetour
2012-MSC Splendida-Western Mediterranean
2012-NCL Jade-Eastern Mediterranean and Holy Land
2014-Carnival Inspiration-Baja California
2014-Royal Caribbean Radiance OTS- 13-day R/T Sydney/New Zealand
2015 Carnival (Inspiration)-Baja California
2015 NCL Jade-11-Day Western Mediterranean
2015 NCL Jade 10-Day Eastern Mediterranean
2015 Crown Princess Wine Country Coastal
2015 Diamond Princess B2B Grand Japan
2015 Sinorama Gold 8 Yangtze River
2016 HAL Volendam Asian Adventure
2016 HAL Volendam Far East Discovery
2017 NCL Getaway Transatlantic
2017 HAL Zuiderdam Fjords & Highlands
#7
Helena, Alabama, near Birmingham
2,118 Posts
Joined Sep 2002
A friend of ours did the MSC line in the Mediterranean a few years ago and said it was a big mistake. 90% of the passengers were Italian, French and German so the cultural differences were a problem as was finding crew members who spoke English. They choose MSC as they thought the food would be more European and better than on the RCI cruise there were considering. They thought the food was bland and mediocre. The other problem was smoking was allowed almost everywhere on the ship and our friends are non smokers.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature


Gold Star Cruises 1994 on Star of Texas the former Mardi Gras, Carnival's first cruise ship. She was a true rust bucket

CCL Fascination 1998
Cruise West Spirit of Endeavour 1999
RCCL Rhapsody of the Seas 2000
Celebrity Century 2008
HAL Volendam 2002 & 2003, Oosterdam 2005 & 2007 Westerdam 2006 & 2010. Nieuw Amsterdam 2011
#8
Bristol, TN
211 Posts
Joined Feb 2008
We sailed NCL twice early on, then decided to try MSC. WOW what a dissapointment. We had vacationed in Italy years earlier and the thought of a international mix of passengers, Italian dining, exotic places, not to mention a really good rate for a 17 night transatlantic cruise caused us to book MSC. We were wrong! In our opinion the food sucked, the buffet looked like the cold cut section at a local deli with a few cold pastas thrown in, main dining meals were uninspired, slowly served and never at the proper temperature. Due to the languages involved shows were mostly exhibitions or musicals, except that you had to endure approx 10 minutes before each one for the CD to make his introductions and announcements in 5 languages (which, by the way was the same for all shipwide announcements). The REAL burner for us however was the total disregard for the passengers concerns about anything. We are not high maintenance or complainers, but when you approached the service desk with a problem you were for the most part greeted with a blank stare, and not because they didn't understand but because they didn't care. I have followed the reviews occasionally since then and I still see these same opinions being voiced.

The only thing we got from the MSC cruise that we cherish is the fact that we were able to see some wonderful places. MSC is a shipping company, and that what we felt like we were, just cargo being moved from one lovely port to another. If you have a choice of seeing the same ports with NCL or another cruise line my suggestion would be to choose someone else. We are returning to cruise Europe this summer and NEVER ONCE even looked at what MSC was offering. We have sailed multiple times on NCL, Princess and Carnival and have had a great time on all of them, but once was more than enough with MSC!!!