NY Senator calls for cruise ship Bill of Rights

Welcome to Cruise Critic! If you'd like to participate on our forums by joining in the conversation, please Register Now! Be sure to visit our FAMOUS Roll Call forums, where you can meet other cruisers sailing with you and share a tour or shore excursion and SAVE MONEY!

Cruise News
Discuss up-to-the minute happenings in the cruise line industry.
Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts
BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
All times are GMT -4.
The time now is 02:18 AM.
#2
Ft. Worth, Tx, USA
9,771 Posts
Joined Nov 2000
A word of caution! If you see a TV camera, anywhere within 100 yards of yourself...Be on alert.....There is a very good chance Chuckie will knock you over to get in front of it.

The only word that applies to this guy these days is....boring.

I think the legal system will work out any difficulties that have arisen with the last few months with various ship incidents.

Chuckie...to gat another junket.....
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Previous Cruises: Way too many to list, started in 1974

RCI Diamond Plus

CELEBRITY ELITE

In a bunch of other cruiseline frequent cruiser programs

CARNIVAL BREEZE JUN 4, 2017
#3
Western New York
575 Posts
Joined Mar 2006
Oh lucky us!! Factually speaking, Shumer's nothing but a camera hogging vote whore. Unfortunately for us and to his benefit, our political system is based on name recognition and not acomplishment.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Carnival Valor 3/23/14
Oasis of the Seas 10/5/13
Carnival Dream 9/28/13
Carnival Victory 10/14/12
Serenade of the Seas 6/5/11
Serenade of the Seas 6/13/10
Carnival Victory 6/6/10
Carnival Freedom 3/28/09
Carnival Glory 9/22/07
HAL Noordam 3/21/07
Sea Princess 3/11/06
HAL Zuiderdam 9/24/05
HAL Volendam 3/10/05
Sun Princess 3/10/04
#5
ft lauderdale
2,372 Posts
Joined Dec 2005
Congress needs to get their house in order before going after anyone else, they cannot not even agree to disagree.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Dale
Seaward,Norway, Rotterdam,
Sensation, Zuiderdam 3/04
Radiance of the Seas 1/06, Jewel of the Seas, 11/06, Century 1/07, Majesty OTS 5/07,
Navigator OTS 12/07, Caribbean Princess 5/08
Freedom of the Seas 12/08, Century 1/09,
Navagator OTS 3/09, Imagination 7/09,
NCL Pearl 12/09, Century 1/10, Oasis, 11/10,
NOS 12/2010, Azamara Journey 11/11
Celebrity Solstice 3/12, Azamara Quest 4/13
Liberty of the Seas 12/13, Allure 12/14
Navigator of the Seas 12/2015
#6
1,967 Posts
Joined Apr 2006
I will not comment on the personality or agenda of the senator involved.

However, it is always good to have a legal system of checks and balances in place to protect consumers and keep corporations at bay.

Most of you are probably too young to remember the old days when the major banks clearly abused credit card customers and acted in whatever way they wanted until the Fair Credit Act was enacted.

The ability of being able to dispute a charge and receive a credit on your account comes from that law -- not from the goodness of the banks wanting to help people.

Kind regards,

Gunther and Uta
#7
Michigan
6,480 Posts
Joined Jul 2005
Our country is going bankrupt and has serious problems to address and once again a politician is wasting time on minor things instead of doing what really needs to be done........
#8
Ohio
528 Posts
Joined Oct 2007
Originally posted by snownyet
Oh lucky us!! Factually speaking, Shumer's nothing but a camera hogging vote whore.


..........
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Sheila









#9
south burlington,vt.
3,928 Posts
Joined Dec 2008
Originally posted by bouhunter
Our country is going bankrupt and has serious problems to address and once again a politician is wasting time on minor things instead of doing what really needs to be done........
Agreed The old case of "hey look over here". Chuckle....what a "boob"...
#10
4,273 Posts
Joined Aug 2005
Originally posted by cruisingerman
i will not comment on the personality or agenda of the senator involved.

However, it is always good to have a legal system of checks and balances in place to protect consumers and keep corporations at bay.

Most of you are probably too young to remember the old days when the major banks clearly abused credit card customers and acted in whatever way they wanted until the fair credit act was enacted.

The ability of being able to dispute a charge and receive a credit on your account comes from that law -- not from the goodness of the banks wanting to help people.

Kind regards,

gunther and uta
ita
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Ginnie


134 Nights at Sea
#11
534 Posts
Joined Apr 2009
People, don't be blinded by your politics. Schumer may be a blowhard. He may be in a different party than you. But if he can goad the cruise lines into adopting a cruisers bill of rights, that's a good thing for all of us.
#12
CT
2,533 Posts
Joined Jul 2008
Originally posted by zekekelso
People, don't be blinded by your politics. Schumer may be a blowhard. He may be in a different party than you. But if he can goad the cruise lines into adopting a cruisers bill of rights, that's a good thing for all of us.
All it will do is raise the price of a cruise. It is definitely NOT a good thing to get an ambulance chasing politician involved in my vacation. Gee I wonder why there are no major cruise ships registered in the USA???

But if you feel all corporations are out to kill their customers there will be no convincing you. After all, no company ever went out of business because of poor service.

If you don't like the cruise line don't sail, it's not like it's a necessity.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature





If you are expecting perfection, don't travel, you will surely be disappointed.



Steve & Diane -- 180 nights and counting on more...

11-Dec-2016 - Jewel - 7 Night Southern Caribbean (B2B)
04-Dec-2016 - Jewel - 7 Night Southern Caribbean

10-June-2016 - Radiance - 7 Night Southbound Alaska & Hubbard Glacier
04-Dec-2015 - Serenade -10 Night Southern Caribbean
05-Sep-2015 - Liberty - 5 Night Bermuda

24-April-2015 - Serenade - 15 Night Boston TA
12-Dec-2014 - Quantum - 8 Night Bahamas
23-May-2014 - Radiance - 7 Night Southbound Alaska & Hubbard Glacier
21-Mar-2014 - Explorer - 8 Night Bahamas
07-Dec-2013 - Jewel - 7 Night Caribbean
10-Oct-2013 - Serenade - 12 Night Mediterranean Greek Isles
01-Feb-2013 - Explorer - 9 Night Eastern Caribbean
02-Dec-2012 - Allure - 7 Night Western Caribbean
19-May-2012 - Explorer - 5 Night Bermuda
30-Oct-2011 - Serenade - 7 Night Southern Caribbean
31-Oct-2010 - Serenade - 7 Night Southern Caribbean
12-Feb-2010 - Radiance - 10 Night Mexican Riviera
13-Jun-2009 - Legend - 12 Night Italy And Croatia
25-May-2008 - Adventure - 7 Night Southern Caribbean
29-Sep-2007 - Voyager - 7 Night Mediterranean
25-Sep-2006 - Enchantment - 5 Night Western Caribbean
20-Jan-2006 - Sovereign - 3 Night Bahamas
22-Oct-2004 - Voyager - 8 Night New York To Miami
#13
Ft. Worth, Tx, USA
9,771 Posts
Joined Nov 2000
Compare cruise prices in the USA and those in England. England "protects" their citizens against just about every concievable nightmare.

Me, I will pay USA prices, thank you government, but no thank you.

Side note, this is not one party or another. It applies to every elected official in the US. They have one job. No matter what you might here or see, they have one job: Get re-elected. how do they do that?
Have you ever seen the number of pieces of legislation, rules, regulations, guidlelines, restrictions, etc every politician (NO POLITICS HERE....everyone of them)...they introduce every sesson?

Leave us alone to determine what cruise line we will sail, when we will sail, how much money we will spend, and what recourse we choose should something occur.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Previous Cruises: Way too many to list, started in 1974

RCI Diamond Plus

CELEBRITY ELITE

In a bunch of other cruiseline frequent cruiser programs

CARNIVAL BREEZE JUN 4, 2017
#14
5,617 Posts
Joined Jan 2010
Originally posted by zekekelso
People, don't be blinded by your politics. Schumer may be a blowhard. He may be in a different party than you. But if he can goad the cruise lines into adopting a cruisers bill of rights, that's a good thing for all of us.

Probably about as good as the Airline bill of rights worked out for their passengers

The only teeth the airline bill has is $$ penalties for violations, and evan at that, only applies to U.S. Airlines. No cruiselines are U.S. companies, so even if such a bill was adopted it would be toothless. This is purely political posturing - apparently the only skill Washington (both parties) have mastered.
#15
Maryland
9,609 Posts
Joined Mar 2003
Originally posted by steveru621
All it will do is raise the price of a cruise. It is definitely NOT a good thing to get an ambulance chasing politician involved in my vacation. Gee I wonder why there are no major cruise ships registered in the USA???

But if you feel all corporations are out to kill their customers there will be no convincing you. After all, no company ever went out of business because of poor service.

If you don't like the cruise line don't sail, it's not like it's a necessity.
There are no cruise ships registered in the US so cruise lines can avoid US regulations and taxes. I don't think that is a good thing.

Consumer protections for US cruise passengers would be a good thing!
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Charles
#16
Myrtle Beach
5,726 Posts
Joined Nov 2007
Oh please, a Texan calling a NY politician names? Pot, Kettle.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Lessons learned from last cruise for next:
1. Passport - I promise I will never leave home without it again!
2. Peanut M&M's - Do you know how much they cost in the ship's store???
3. Money, lots and lots of money - Need more money!
4. Heck with the rest of the list, just bring lots of money!
[email protected]

Goodie - A Cruise!




Sovereign of the Seas - 3/04; Majesty of the Seas - 4/07 & 11/09; Enchantment of the Seas - 4/08, 4/09 & 11/13; Monarch of the Seas - 12/08, 12/09, 8/10 & 7/11; Independence of the Seas - 1/13, 12/13; Vision of the Seas - 11/13; Freedom of the Seas - 5/14, 11/14 & 10/16; Coral Princess - 4/1 & 12/15; Oasis of the Seas - 1/17
#17
676 Posts
Joined Feb 2011
Originally posted by Charles4515
There are no cruise ships registered in the US so cruise lines can avoid US regulations and taxes. I don't think that is a good thing.

Consumer protections for US cruise passengers would be a good thing!
I think the cruise ships are inspected by the US Coast Guard before they are cleared to sail out of US ports. So it looks like they need to follow US rules and regs to at least some extent.
#18
Coastal Ocean County-Jersey Shore "Jersey Strong !!!"
6,521 Posts
Joined Oct 2001
Originally posted by joe6666
I think the cruise ships are inspected by the US Coast Guard before they are cleared to sail out of US ports. So it looks like they need to follow US rules and regs to at least some extent.
Absolutely correct. And also by the CDC for health inspections

http://www.uscg.mil/hq/cg5/csncoe/


http://www.cdc.gov/nceh/vsp/desc/about_inspections.htm
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
RCCL-Diamond Plus
X-Elite +
NCL-Platinum
Princess-Platinum
Carnival-Platinum
Cunard-Diamond
HAL-***













#19
Maryland
9,609 Posts
Joined Mar 2003
Originally posted by joe6666
I think the cruise ships are inspected by the US Coast Guard before they are cleared to sail out of US ports. So it looks like they need to follow US rules and regs to at least some extent.
Yes, some but not near enough. Not that I have any confidence that Schumer will follow up and actually do anything. Time will tell but I think it likely is a sound byte because of recent issues that have been highlighted in the media.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Charles
#20
CT
2,533 Posts
Joined Jul 2008
Originally posted by Charles4515
There are no cruise ships registered in the US so cruise lines can avoid US regulations and taxes. I don't think that is a good thing.

Consumer protections for US cruise passengers would be a good thing!
There is no way that we will ever agree. I will make my points knowing it will never change your mind that the US federal government is the savoir of everything. The lawyers will force the cruise industry to do far more than any regulation ever could and that's an even worse outcome.

Taxes will force an increase in prices and lower profits. US regulations are usually a joke. You believe regulation="nothing bad will ever happen", which of course is not true. The Staten Island Ferry that crashed into the pier in New York is heavily regulated by everyone. "Jan 9, 2013 – At least 57 injured as ferry crashes into Manhattan's Pier 11". Just Google it and see how great your regulations are.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature





If you are expecting perfection, don't travel, you will surely be disappointed.



Steve & Diane -- 180 nights and counting on more...

11-Dec-2016 - Jewel - 7 Night Southern Caribbean (B2B)
04-Dec-2016 - Jewel - 7 Night Southern Caribbean

10-June-2016 - Radiance - 7 Night Southbound Alaska & Hubbard Glacier
04-Dec-2015 - Serenade -10 Night Southern Caribbean
05-Sep-2015 - Liberty - 5 Night Bermuda

24-April-2015 - Serenade - 15 Night Boston TA
12-Dec-2014 - Quantum - 8 Night Bahamas
23-May-2014 - Radiance - 7 Night Southbound Alaska & Hubbard Glacier
21-Mar-2014 - Explorer - 8 Night Bahamas
07-Dec-2013 - Jewel - 7 Night Caribbean
10-Oct-2013 - Serenade - 12 Night Mediterranean Greek Isles
01-Feb-2013 - Explorer - 9 Night Eastern Caribbean
02-Dec-2012 - Allure - 7 Night Western Caribbean
19-May-2012 - Explorer - 5 Night Bermuda
30-Oct-2011 - Serenade - 7 Night Southern Caribbean
31-Oct-2010 - Serenade - 7 Night Southern Caribbean
12-Feb-2010 - Radiance - 10 Night Mexican Riviera
13-Jun-2009 - Legend - 12 Night Italy And Croatia
25-May-2008 - Adventure - 7 Night Southern Caribbean
29-Sep-2007 - Voyager - 7 Night Mediterranean
25-Sep-2006 - Enchantment - 5 Night Western Caribbean
20-Jan-2006 - Sovereign - 3 Night Bahamas
22-Oct-2004 - Voyager - 8 Night New York To Miami