Pirate night will have a special menu and a couple of free souvenirs for you in ALL 3 restaurants. So you will experience it no matter what restaurant you are in.
If you want to experience each restaurant you wont be able to do Palos.
But if I were to miss one dinner I would miss Lumiere's (Tritons).
Animators Palate will have the light show which is a must, Parrot Cay is so neat and really sets the tropical theme of the cruise. Lumiere's is more formal and beautiful but that is the one I would choose to miss.
I don't know if Palos does the brunch on the 3 day or not, but if they do that may be another option for you so you wouldnt have to miss a dinner your first time on the ship. I havnt done the Brunch myself but I have heard many like it much better than the dinner.
One other option may be to book Palos for a late dinner on any night accept for Pirate night, then go ahead and go to dinner with your child, but dont eat, just have a drink and visit with your child while he eats, and enjoy the restaurants decor. Then go to Palos and enjoy your dinner after wards.
I have heard of others doing this, it may work for you??
mom x4,grandma x4
12/5/02 Wonder 4 day room 6626
5/1/03 Magic Eastern 7 day room 5624
12/13/03 Wonder 3 day room 7124
3/20/04 Magic Eastern Spring Break
5/04 Wonder 3 day room ?
10/04 Wonder 3 day room ?
1/2/05 Wonder 4 day room 5648
5/12/05 Wonder 3 day room 2560
10/6/05 Wonder 3 day room 8092
10/17/07 Magic Western room 5132
5/06 Wonder 3 day room 6634
8/5/06 Magic Eastern room ?
11/25/06 Magic Eastern Banana Head Group
4/5/07 Wonder 3 day cruise room 6152
6/30/07 Western Carnival Cruise
11/24/07 Magic Eastern Banana head reunion cruise room 7624
1/24/08 3 day Wonder room 6137
11/29/08 Western Magic room 6132
11/7/09 Eastern cruise room 5640
11/5/2011 Eastern cruise room #5629
11/24/2012 Western Fantasy cruise, room 10654
1/31/2013 Dream Room 10108
2/28/13 Dream Cruise, Room 7032
5/27/2013 Enchantment of the Seas room 3018
2/7/14 Magic 3 day cruise, room 2056
12/8/14 Enchantment 4 day cruise Room 7556