Carnival VS Silvermoon - Turtle snorkel tour

Can't decide which is the right option. Carnival has the tour for 70$ and silvermoon as it for $115. Is it really worth the extra money on silvermoon? The other big ones mentioned on here are off island when we will be there. Any advise/suggestions?

depends on if you want the group grope / sardine can experience or the more personalized 24 person max, there's room to move and I'm not getting kick in the head while snorkeling experience. Silvermoon books up quickly !

we have done Calabaza and Silvermoom. Both are really nice but I prefer Calabaza a little more. Only 12 max on the catamaran

Yes. It is most definitely worth the extra money.

we have done Calabaza and Silvermoom. Both are really nice but I prefer Calabaza a little more. Only 12 max on the catamaran

how much are the Calabaza tours & where do they take you? Do they pick you up at the dock? Thank you for the advice.