Brewers Beach vs Magen's Bay

Welcome to Cruise Critic! If you'd like to participate on our forums by joining in the conversation, please Register Now! Be sure to visit our FAMOUS Roll Call forums, where you can meet other cruisers sailing with you and share a tour or shore excursion and SAVE MONEY!

** Please post your recommendations ONLY in response to request...do not start a new thread. Thanks!
Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts
BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
All times are GMT -4.
The time now is 07:18 AM.
#1
Ottawa, Ontario
164 Posts
Joined Nov 2008
We are Travelling on the Dawn soon and deciding between Cane Garden Bay and Brewer's Beach.
From the cruise Port, are the roads less steep to Cane Garden Bay or Brewer's Beach? I think my wife is now freaked out about the dangerous roads to Brewer's Bay since I told her...silly me!!!

Also, is entry to either beach free, or is there a cost to enter?

Thanks!!!
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Sovereign of the Seas (Nassau/Cocoa Cay)Feb 2007
Carnival Liberty (Nassau/Ochos Rios/Grand Cayman) Feb 2008
Norwegian Dawn (Samana/St. Thomas/Tortola/Great Stirrup Cay) Feb 2009
Carnival Sensation (Freeport/Nassau) Dec 2009
Carnival Triumph (Progreso/Cozumel) Jan 2011
Carnival Victory (St. Thomas/Bridgetown/St. Lucia/St.Kitts/St.Maarten) Jan 2012
Carnival Dream (Nassau/St. Thomas/St. Maarten) Jan 2013
Disney Magic (Nassau/Castaway Cay) Jan 2014
Norwegian Gem (San Juan/St. Thomas/St. Maarten/Tortola) Mar 2015

#2
Pocono Mts, PA
761 Posts
Joined Sep 2005
Originally posted by acruisingcouple
We are Travelling on the Dawn soon and deciding between Cane Garden Bay and Brewer's Beach.
From the cruise Port, are the roads less steep to Cane Garden Bay or Brewer's Beach? I think my wife is now freaked out about the dangerous roads to Brewer's Bay since I told her...silly me!!!

Also, is entry to either beach free, or is there a cost to enter?

Thanks!!!
I can only speak for Brewer's Bay, but I didn't think the roads were THAT terrifying. Heck, some of the roads here in the Poconos are far worse!

No charge for Brewer's itself, but if you want a beach chair, you need to rent one from the proprietor of Nicole's Bar/Restaurant.
#3
Ohio
1,225 Posts
Joined Jan 2007
You have to go over about a thousand feet of elevation to get to either beach. The roads are well-paved.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Lard Greystoke

Carnival Triumph 2015 02 E Carib
RC Jewel OTS 2014 01 S Carib
Jan 13 S Carib
MSC Lirica Jan 08 E/S Carib
Carnival Glory Feb 07 W Carib
RC Voyager of the Seas Feb 06 E Carib
#4
Leonardo, NJ
2,196 Posts
Joined Jan 2005
You basicly use the same roads to get to either beach. Neither road is that bad. I think Brewers Bay is just a little further. You can check out Brewers Bay in my Tortola pictures in my signature.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature

Paul & MaryAnn

NCL Breakaway S. Caribbean 11/27/16
NCL Gem Eastern Caribbean 1/22/16
NCL Breakaway CTN 1/30/15
NCL Breakaway Bermuda 9/21/2014
Carnival Breeze E. Caribbean 2/1/14
NCL Gem CTN 12/19/13
NCL Gem Eastern Caribbean 1/27/13
NCL Star Repo 4/15/12
NCL Star W. Caribbean10/17/11
NCL Gem Bahamas 3/26/11
NCL Sky Family Reunion 10/22/10
NCL Jewel Repo 4/10
NCL Jewel S. Caribbean 2/09
Random Wind 7/08
NCL Pearl S. Caribbean 1/08
Random Wind 7/07
NCL Spirit S.& E. Caribbean 1/07
Random Wind 7/06
NCL Sun W. Caribbean 1/06
Celine 7/05
NCL Spirit W. Caribbean 4/05
Tiko Tiko 7/04
Tiko Tiko 7/96
Tiko Tiko 7/94
Carnival 3/96 Eastern Caribbean (Paul)