Welcome to Cruise Critic! If you'd like to participate on our forums by joining in the conversation, please Register Now! Be sure to visit our FAMOUS Roll Call forums, where you can meet other cruisers sailing with you and share a tour or shore excursion and SAVE MONEY!
Ask a Cruise QuestionPost your general cruise questions here.
Princess is an easy choice if the price is near the same. My sons like Princess much better and they started cruising at the ages of 10 and 12.
__________________ Celebrity: Millenium -November 2003 Princess: Caribbean -November 2004 Princess: Caribbean -November 2005 Royal Caribbean: Sovereign of the Seas -August 2006 Carnival: Glory -November 2007 Princess: Caribbean -January 2008 Princess: Ruby -November 2009 Princess: Crown -January 2 2010 Princess: Crown - November 27 2010 Royal Caribbean: Navigator of the Seas - December 10 2011
CARNIVAL FREEDOM September 8 2012
Me and my mother are planning a 7 day Christmas cruise this December to the Mexican Riviera
Many people have told me Princess will have better food, better service overall, but Carnival appears to have funner activities, and a more energized vibe onboard. The 'Carnival Miracle' also has better member reviews then the 'Sapphire Princess' and a better room.
The more fun energetic vibe on Carnival appeals to me a lot more then the more formal Princess but I've heard many horror stories from Carnival.
Is it worth choosing the fun over the service?
We went within months on Mexican Riviera cruises on both Carnival and Princess. One big difference was that since they were doing Mazatlan both cruises spent two nights in Cabo. The difference was that Carnival sailed out to sea after the first night and came back the next morning. Princess spent the night in the harbor so if you wanted to go ashore for late night fun you could on Princess but not on Carnival.
Over 50 Cruises
First cruise: Prince George Alaska
Most recent cruise: Grand Princess Hawaii