Welcome to Cruise Critic! If you'd like to participate on our forums by joining in the conversation, please Register Now! Be sure to visit our FAMOUS Roll Call forums, where you can meet other cruisers sailing with you and share a tour or shore excursion and SAVE MONEY!
I have a 7 year old, 5 year old and a 3 year old. We cruised RCCL last year and had a great time! However, after doing some research NCL seems to offer a lot and has more availability. Can anyone tell me the differences and what line you would recommend and why.
I'd go RCCL. Tons of activities for the kids, better food & service than NCL. We are not NCL fans - dd didn't like kids program at all but, loved other lines. They are closed more than open, same things daily and everything requires parental supervision (making pizza, water balloon toss, etc). Never had that on other lines.
__________________ Carnival - Celebration- 1990 RCCL - Majesty of the Seas - 1993 Celebrity - Century - 1999 Princess - Grand - 2002 Princess - Golden - 2003 NCL - Dawn - 2004 Princess - Golden - 2005 Celebrity Constellation - 3/06 Celebrity Zenith - 8/06 HAL - Noordam - 3/07 Carnival - Valor - 4/08 Carnival Triumph - 7/09 Celebrity Constellation - 10/09
I just posted a very glowing review of our experience on the NCL Spirit with our two children!!!! If you are looking to sail from NY, than NCL is the way to go. The Spirit was GREAT and I've heard the Dawn and the Gem are also wonderful choices for families with children. We looked into RCCL for next year, but the price for their 5 day to Bermuda is about the same as the Dawn's 7 day to Bermuda!
Good luck choosing! I'm sure whatever you decide you'll have a great trip
We have done RCCL and NCL once each and have a cruise booked on each one. So...we like both! Our DD was 7 on RCCL's Explorer and 8 on NCL's Dream and she actually preferred the Dream's kids' program because she said the counselors played more with them (even though on such an elderly ship the facility for kids was small and not fancy). She also liked that since it was a smaller ship she saw kids she knew from the kids' program around the ship.
My vet just got back from the NCL Pearl and said it was fabulous. I want to try one of the newer ships NCL has next time. The Freestyle dining is a big plus with kids, I think, because asking young kids to sit through a long dinner service every night is asking a lot. That would be a personal preference but DH and I prefer Freestyle and want to experience it on a ship designed for it.
I would read lots of member reviews from people with kids.