Celebrity VS Princess for Alaska

Welcome to Cruise Critic! If you'd like to participate on our forums by joining in the conversation, please Register Now! Be sure to visit our FAMOUS Roll Call forums, where you can meet other cruisers sailing with you and share a tour or shore excursion and SAVE MONEY!

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts
BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
All times are GMT -4.
The time now is 10:23 AM.
#1
Pennsylvania
410 Posts
Joined Feb 2008
We are thinking about a cruise to Alaska this upcoming summer. I was wondering what anyones thoughts are about doing a Celebrity cruise/cruisetour versus a Princess cruise/cruisetour? Princess comes highly recommended for Alaska, but we loved our Celebrity cruise. We have not sailed Princess.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature


cruisejanet@gmail.com
Ms Koningsdam 10-24-2016 Rome to Ft. Lauderdale
Nieuw Amsterdam 12-27-2015 Ft Lauderdale, Half Moon Cay, Grand Cayman, Costa Maya, Key West
Emerald Princess 12-19-2015 Ft Lauderdale, Curacao, Aruba, Bonaire
Royal Princess 9-21-2015 Ft. Lauderdale, Antigua, Barbados, St. Lucia, St. Kitts, missed Princess Cay(thanks Joquin)
Carnival Conquest 8-2-2015 Ft. Lauderdale, Antigua, St. Maarten, St. Thomas, Nassau
Celebrity Silhouette 11-1-2014 TA from Rome to Ft. Lauderdale
Royal Princess, AGAIN! 1-19-2014 Ft. Lauderdale, Princess Cay, St Thomas, St Maarten
Royal Princess 11-10-2013 Ft Lauderdale, Princess Cay, St Thomas, St Maarten
Golden Princess 10-24-2012 Hilo, Oahu, Kauai, Maui
Coral Princess 3-13-2012 Los Angeles Cabo San Lucas, Nicaragua, Costa Rica, full transit canal, Columbia, Aruba, Ft. Lauderdale
Island Princess 8-31-2011 Hubbard Glacier, Glacier Bay Natl Park, Skagway, Juneau, Ketchikan
Mariner of the Seas 10-3-2010 Cabo San Lucas, Mazatlan, Puerto Vallarta
Celebrity Solstice 4-4-2010 San Juan, PR, St. Kitts, St. Martin/Maarten
Jewel of the Seas 10-27-2009 Repo cruise! Boston to San Juan, PR, St. Thomas, St. John, St. Croix, Oranjestad, Aruba, Miami
Carnival Fascination 1-24-2009 Nassau and Half Moon Cay
Carnival Liberty 6-21-08 Grand Cayman,Ocho Rios, Cozumel
#2
Ft. Lauderdale, FL
2,962 Posts
Joined Oct 2008
We have sailed both Princess and Celebrity to Alaska in recent years. First, I would go with whoever offers the better itinerary: namely, a visit to Glacier Bay or Hubbard Glacier. You may see Tracy Arm fjord on some itineraries as the requisite glacier stop. Though it is a glacier (actually the twin Sawyer glaciers) it pales in comparison to the others and is really not worth it, IMHO. At Hubbard and Glacier Bay you will get much closer to the glaciers, appreciate the color of the ice and the sounds of calving. The visit to Tracy Arm was the one thing that made me regret choosing Princess over Celebrity for our 3rd Alaskan cruise, so I would say they are relatively comparable. Princess food is a slight cut below X's, but their entertainment is much better and has more options in the evenings. Service is a cut above on X - just a touch more polished.

Another itinerary tip: if you can manage it, try a RT Vancouver or Northbound/Southbound. On these itineraries you can enjoy sailing the Inside Passage in all its glory. Our last cruise was RT Seattle and we missed that experience.

As for cruisetours, both Princess and HAL both have serious roots in Alaska and have been doing the cruisetours for years - since the 1970s or 80s. I know Princess has some nice lodges in the interior and their cruisetours are highly respected. With itineraries being equal, I would probably pick a Princess cruisetour over an X one because of their reputation.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Infi
67 cruises: Carnival, Celebrity (Elite +), Costa, Cunard, Holland America (), Princess (Elite), Sitmar, Home lines, Chandris, Dolphin, and others long gone but not forgotten

Photos: Our cruises
Most recent cruises:

Amsterdam - Panama Canal, SD-FLL, Christmas/NYE - 12/18/15
Prinsendam - Christmas/NYE - 12/18/14
Amsterdam - Panama Canal, SD-FLL, Christmas/NYE - 12/20/13
Veendam - Canada/New England B2B, RT Boston - 6/1/13
Maasdam - 3/8/13

Email: Email me


xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx5th cruise to Alaska!
#3
Wheaton, IL
4,840 Posts
Joined Dec 2005
Here is a suggestion based on what we did. Take a Celebrity cruise, but book your package through a local (ie,Alaska) travel agent. We did that and for a three day package we saved over $900 and that was several years ago. We took the same train and had no problem getting seats in the observation car, and we actually stayed at one of the Princess resorts. It was a no brainer for us.

ps
I would agree, though, that in Alaska itinerary rules IMHO. I would pick the best itinerary if there were a considerable difference, although if that were equal Celebrity would always be my cruiseline of choice
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature



#4
Canada
2,041 Posts
Joined Sep 2005
We decided on a north bound on the Millie from Vancouver. We also looked at Princess, but there was a big difference in price when we booked last summer for July 2011 and Celebrity own on that point. We're doing our own tour of Alaska when we get off. We're taking the train to Anchorage where we will stay over night, rent a car and set off for a week of exploring.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Future cruises


Past cruises:
Westerdam - Alaska July 2001
Star Princess - Southern Caribbean December 2005
Tahitian Princess - French Polynesia and Cook Islands April 2008
Celebrity Constellation - Panama Canal Dec 22/08
Celebrity Eclipse - Baltic cruise - July 10, 2010
Ruby Princess - Eastern Caribbean - March 13, 2011
Celebrity Millennium - northbound Alaska - July 15, 2011
Celebrity Constellation - 14 day Caribbean - January 28, 2012
Celebrity Silhouette transatlantic - April 22, 2012
Celebrity Silhouette b2b Mediterranean/Greece May 5, 2012
Grand Princess 49 days around South America January 26, 2013
Celebrity Reflection- Eastern Mediterranean October 21, 2013
Celebrity Reflection - Transatlantic November 1, 2013
Ocean Princess - Hawaii to Papeete January 29, 2014
Ocean Princess - French Polynesia February 9, 2014
Caribbean Princess - Jr. World Hockey cruise January 3, 2015
Celebrity Infinity - Antarctica February 15, 2015
Celebrity Infinity - South America - March 1, 2015
Celebrity Infinity - Panama Canal - March 15, 2015
Celebrity Infinity - Panama Canal - March 29, 2015
Coral Princess - Panama Canal - September 16, 2015
Royal Princess - Caribbean Cruise - March 3, 2016
Caribbean Princess - Transatlantic/British Isles - April 17, 2016
Celebrity Silhouette - Christmas cruise - December 18, 2016
#5
Philadelphia. PA
662 Posts
Joined Jul 2001
While Celebrity is our favorite cruiseline, we enjoyed every moment of our Coral Princess Alaska tour. The cruise tour that preceded it was wonderful (and possibly my favorite part of the trip!). The port itinerary was the selling point for us. To help you make your decision, look carefully at your scenic cruising opportunity and the actual time in each port; to us, the ship experience was secondary. That being said, we were very happy with Princess!
#6
Pennsylvania
410 Posts
Joined Feb 2008
wow, the more I read about different Alaska cruises/cruisetours, the more confused I get!! Now, I am looking at Holland America cruises/tours, also! You really do need to do alot of homework before going to this area of the US! The caribbean was easy to figure out! Thanks everyone, the more responses and opinions, the better!! I just love these boards!
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature


cruisejanet@gmail.com
Ms Koningsdam 10-24-2016 Rome to Ft. Lauderdale
Nieuw Amsterdam 12-27-2015 Ft Lauderdale, Half Moon Cay, Grand Cayman, Costa Maya, Key West
Emerald Princess 12-19-2015 Ft Lauderdale, Curacao, Aruba, Bonaire
Royal Princess 9-21-2015 Ft. Lauderdale, Antigua, Barbados, St. Lucia, St. Kitts, missed Princess Cay(thanks Joquin)
Carnival Conquest 8-2-2015 Ft. Lauderdale, Antigua, St. Maarten, St. Thomas, Nassau
Celebrity Silhouette 11-1-2014 TA from Rome to Ft. Lauderdale
Royal Princess, AGAIN! 1-19-2014 Ft. Lauderdale, Princess Cay, St Thomas, St Maarten
Royal Princess 11-10-2013 Ft Lauderdale, Princess Cay, St Thomas, St Maarten
Golden Princess 10-24-2012 Hilo, Oahu, Kauai, Maui
Coral Princess 3-13-2012 Los Angeles Cabo San Lucas, Nicaragua, Costa Rica, full transit canal, Columbia, Aruba, Ft. Lauderdale
Island Princess 8-31-2011 Hubbard Glacier, Glacier Bay Natl Park, Skagway, Juneau, Ketchikan
Mariner of the Seas 10-3-2010 Cabo San Lucas, Mazatlan, Puerto Vallarta
Celebrity Solstice 4-4-2010 San Juan, PR, St. Kitts, St. Martin/Maarten
Jewel of the Seas 10-27-2009 Repo cruise! Boston to San Juan, PR, St. Thomas, St. John, St. Croix, Oranjestad, Aruba, Miami
Carnival Fascination 1-24-2009 Nassau and Half Moon Cay
Carnival Liberty 6-21-08 Grand Cayman,Ocho Rios, Cozumel
#7
4,280 Posts
Joined Dec 2003
We did land/cruise tour with Princess Coral. We flew to Fairbanks and started our land tour traveling via Princess Train. Had a great time, Princess has great lodging and the train was great. Enjoyed the Coral.

Celebrity is my cruise line of choice but I would do Alaska again with Princess.

I suggest that you look over on the Alaska Board. Lots of GREAT info there. As others have stated you need to decide what you want to see and go from there.

Have a great time in Beautiful Alaska!
#8
Wheaton, IL
4,840 Posts
Joined Dec 2005
Another thing newbie Alaska cruisers need to keep in mind is the cost of shore excursions. There are some truly awesome excursions to be had, but many of them are very expensive (up to several hundreds of dollars pp for flight excursions). It is not at all unusual to spend in the neighborhood of $100 pp for an excursion. You also have fewer options for doing excursions on your own, and those that you can do are often of similar price. (this is simply a capacity situation - Alaska has such a short tourist season and it is now so popular that there are only so many vendors to go around). You can do it cheaper in many ports if you choose to just walk around town, but it is very tempting to see all the wonderful sights you can see on the tours. When looking at the cost of your trip, you need to factor this in. Anyone used to Caribbean cruises can experience 'sticker shock' in Alaska (although I know there are some pricey tours available for the former as well)
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature



#9
Shady Cove, Oregon
976 Posts
Joined Apr 2004
Originally posted by texkan
We did land/cruise tour with Princess Coral. We flew to Fairbanks and started our land tour traveling via Princess Train. Had a great time, Princess has great lodging and the train was great. Enjoyed the Coral.

Celebrity is my cruise line of choice but I would do Alaska again with Princess.

I suggest that you look over on the Alaska Board. Lots of GREAT info there. As others have stated you need to decide what you want to see and go from there.

Have a great time in Beautiful Alaska!
We agree with you. Celebrity is our line, but Princess does Alaska perfectly. They own the lodges. They are fabulous!!! Their train cars are wonderful!! Everything is handled in a timely and very organized fashion. Princess is not our cruiseline, but they do a great job in the Alaskan market!
#10
Central, Tx
4,744 Posts
Joined Oct 2003
Pretty much a toss up. Both are fine lines. I like Celebrity food and ships much better than Princess. Food is subjective, however the chopped up ship design on Princess not so much.

FWIW.... I would go with Celebrity as the tree huggers may be about to get Hubbard Glacier shut down to cruise ships. What a shame. It really is the ultimate glacier to visit in Alaska. I would go before they shut it down, and hope like heck it does not start this summer.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
I wrestled with reality for years, Doctor, and I'm happy to state, I finally won out over it. (Jimmy Stewart in "Harvey" 1950)
#11
Vancouver, BC
16,919 Posts
Joined Feb 2002
Glacier bay hands down so that equals either HAL or Princess. Celebrity cruises Hubbard because they can't get into Glacier Bay
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Coming next
May 2017..Crete land trip
September 2017..Solstice Vancouver to Hawaii
November 2017...Constellation Rome to Dubai
September 2018...Koningsdam Iberia & Greece

Australia Land Trip - Celebrity Constellation - Greek Isles 2016/Hawaii Land Trip 2015/Christmas and New Years in Hawaii/European Christmas Markets - Land Trip/Hawaii - VCR Celebrity Solstice 2014/Paris Land Trip/Hawaii Land Trip X 2 - 2013/Grand Med. - Ruby Princess/South of France 2012/Hawaii - Land Trip 2012/Hawaii - Land Trip - 2011/Panama Canal and Florida Keys - Coral Princess - 2011/Eastern Caribbean - Ruby Princess - 2010/France 3 Week Land Trip - Burgundy/Loire/Normandy/French Riviera/Provence 2010/Mexican Riviera - Sapphire Princess 2009/Coastal - Sapphire Princess 2009/Alaska - Voyage of the Glaciers - Zuiderdam - 2009/Greek Islands cruise + Monaco and Paris by land - Grand Princess - 2008/Land Trip - Maui - 2008/3 Week Land - Paris to Rome - 2007/Hawaii - Pride of America - 2007/14 Day Caribbean - Sea Princess - 2006/Coastal - Dawn Princess - 2006/Barcelona to Venice - Millennium - 2005/UK & Ireland - Land Trip - 2004/AI Mexican Riviera -2003/Coastal - Island Princess - 2002/Maui - Land Trip x 2/Alaska - Dawn Princess - 2001/UK Land Trip x 3/11 Day Circle the Caribbean - Splendour of the Seas - 2000/Mexican Riviera - Rhapsody of the Seas - 1999/2 Week Land Bermuda - Girls Trip - 1997/Married - Maui - 1997
#12
2,016 Posts
Joined May 2007
You have to decide if you want just a cruise or a cruise tour. Princess wins the cruise-tour fight with the most options. Booking the land tour part separately wins the price fight. Cruise only might have a new player with Oceania. They have some great itineraries.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature


#13
Vancouver, BC
16,919 Posts
Joined Feb 2002
Originally posted by biker1972
Cruise only might have a new player with Oceania. They have some great itineraries.
And a lot of sales right now too.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Coming next
May 2017..Crete land trip
September 2017..Solstice Vancouver to Hawaii
November 2017...Constellation Rome to Dubai
September 2018...Koningsdam Iberia & Greece

Australia Land Trip - Celebrity Constellation - Greek Isles 2016/Hawaii Land Trip 2015/Christmas and New Years in Hawaii/European Christmas Markets - Land Trip/Hawaii - VCR Celebrity Solstice 2014/Paris Land Trip/Hawaii Land Trip X 2 - 2013/Grand Med. - Ruby Princess/South of France 2012/Hawaii - Land Trip 2012/Hawaii - Land Trip - 2011/Panama Canal and Florida Keys - Coral Princess - 2011/Eastern Caribbean - Ruby Princess - 2010/France 3 Week Land Trip - Burgundy/Loire/Normandy/French Riviera/Provence 2010/Mexican Riviera - Sapphire Princess 2009/Coastal - Sapphire Princess 2009/Alaska - Voyage of the Glaciers - Zuiderdam - 2009/Greek Islands cruise + Monaco and Paris by land - Grand Princess - 2008/Land Trip - Maui - 2008/3 Week Land - Paris to Rome - 2007/Hawaii - Pride of America - 2007/14 Day Caribbean - Sea Princess - 2006/Coastal - Dawn Princess - 2006/Barcelona to Venice - Millennium - 2005/UK & Ireland - Land Trip - 2004/AI Mexican Riviera -2003/Coastal - Island Princess - 2002/Maui - Land Trip x 2/Alaska - Dawn Princess - 2001/UK Land Trip x 3/11 Day Circle the Caribbean - Splendour of the Seas - 2000/Mexican Riviera - Rhapsody of the Seas - 1999/2 Week Land Bermuda - Girls Trip - 1997/Married - Maui - 1997
#14
Windsor, Ontario, Canada
2,123 Posts
Joined Nov 2008
While we prefer Celebrity, for us Alaska was all about glaciers so we did a Southbound Island Princess that stopped at both Hubbard and Glacier Bay, sailed inside Vancouver Island. We added a Prince William Sound smaller boat cruise in Whittier. While the Island was a nice ship, that would not have mattered for us. We spent all our time outside enjoying Alaska and did not see a show, a band, or participate in pretty much any ship activities--which is the direct opposite of our pattern in the Caribbean. Absolutely visit the Alaska board and do your research BEFORE you book anything. I have encountered lots of people with buyers regret that booked before knowing what they really wanted to do. Happy planning!
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Epirotiki cruises -- Southern Carribbean--March 1989 and December 1991
Celebrity Century -- Western Carribbean--April 2004
Disney Wonder -- Bahamas--December 2006
Emerald Princess -- Eastern and Southern Caribbean -- January 2009
Island Princess -- Alaska --June 2010
Celebrity Eclipse--Caribbean--January 2011
Ocean Princess -- French Polynesia -- January 2013
NCL Breakawy to Bermuda -- September 2014
NCL Star --Caribbean -January 2016
NCL Breakaway to Bermuda --September 2016

79 days at sea...waiting to add 11 more!

#15
Orange County, CA
236 Posts
Joined Jun 2003
We have sailed both Princess and Celebrity and chose a Celebrity Millennium Cruisetour two years ago that included Denali, Talkeetna, and Fairbanks. It was amazing! In researching Princess vs Celebrity, here are the key differences we found... Celebrity includes a Tour Guide AND Motor Coach driver on every tour. You have to pay extra for a Tour Guide on Princess (otherwise the motor coach driver doubles as your guide). Big advantage to Celebrity. Princess lodges are very nice, but not necessary in prime locations. Example was in Talkeetna where all the shore excursions left. Celebrity's lodge (sorry can't recall the name but it was BEAUTIFUL with an amazing view of Mt. McKinley from the hot tub on the deck) was within walking distance to Talkeetna (which we enjoyed in the evening), while the Princess lodge was 45 minutes away. Both companies glass dome train cars and motor coaches were nice, although I did notice that the Celebrity train cars were located before Holland America and Princess, so we had the best viewing of wildlife! I'm sure the moose and bear we saw were startled by our Celebrity train car and probably heading for the woods by the time the Princess and Holland America cars passed (Princess was the last car on the train.) You'll have an amazing time on either cruise line. Hope our observations help.
#16
Ohio
1,974 Posts
Joined Jan 2005
I would look at the times in port also. For example, some ships were in Victoria late, late afternoon and evening. We chose one that arrived hours earlier.

I have cruised both inlets of Glacier Bay and Hubbard. Both are impressive. We could really grasp the enormity of Hubbard glacier as we sailed away and a HAL ship took our place. It was dwarfed by the wall of ice. Size in Alaska is difficult to comprehend.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Alison

Future cruises - Southern Caribbean Exotic - Jan 2017Celebrity Eclipse

Future cruises - Southern Caribbean Exotic - Jan 2018 Celebrity Eclipse

1983 World Explorer SS Universe to Alaska - 14 day
1986 Costa Riviera
1988 NCL Skyward
1991 Premier Majestic
1992 Premier Majestic
2001 NCL Seaward
2004 RCI Sovereign of the Sea
2005 RCI Splendour of the Sea
2005 Celebrity Zenith - Christmas at Sea
2006 Caribbean Princess - Christmas at Sea
2007 NCL Pearl - Christmas at Sea
2008 NCL Jewel - Christmas at Sea
2009 RCI Radiance of the Sea - Alaska Cruisetour cruise
2009 Star Princess Sept. 23 - Oct. 24, 2009 -30 day - San Francisco to Sydney, Australia
2010 NCL Pearl - Pacific Coastal
2010 HAL Amsterdam - 1 night to Seattle
2010 Caribbean Princess - New England/Canada
2011 Golden Princess - 14 day LA to Hawaii
2011 Celebrity Infinity - 10 day Alaska RT Seattle
2011 RCI Navigator of the Sea - 6 nite - circle Cuba
2012 Golden Princess - LA to Hawaii
2012 Caribbean Princess - 12 nite - British Isles
2013 - Vantage River Venture - Rhine and Mosel - 14 nite River cruise - with a 500-year flood
2013 - NCL Dawn - Back to Back: Boston to Quebec to Boston
2014 - Crown Princess - Caribbean Islands - 14 nite
2014 - Crown Princess - Pacific Coastal Wine Cruise - 7 nite
2015 - Celebrity Summit - Back to Back Southern Caribbean - 14nite
2016 - Celebrity Summit - Back to Back Southern Caribbean - 14nite
2016 - Vantage Voyager - Danube, Main, Rhine River Cruise - 14 nite