Go Back   Cruise Critic Message Board Forums > Cruise Lines "A - O" > Cunard Line
 
Register here!
Forgot Your Password?


Notices

Cunard Line
Read hundreds of Cunard Cruise Reviews from real cruisers and compare the best Cunard Cruise Deals.

Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
  #21  
Old January 14th, 2012, 08:26 PM
highcbob highcbob is offline
Cool Cruiser
 
Join Date: Jan 2002
Location: sf usa
Posts: 560
Unhappy Sad

Captain now charged with manslaugter, abandoning ship before many passengers. Crew were not properly trained for emergency and also rushed off ship before many passengers. French couple say there was no lifeboat drill when they boarded in France.

Last edited by highcbob; January 14th, 2012 at 08:28 PM.
Reply With Quote

Ad Sponsored By
  #22  
Old January 14th, 2012, 09:06 PM
Jim Avery Jim Avery is offline
Blue Ribbon Cruiser
 
Join Date: Mar 2004
Location: Valley of the Sun, Arizona
Posts: 4,870
Default

Thank you, Host Michell.
Reply With Quote

  #23  
Old January 14th, 2012, 10:51 PM
BettyBoop3850's Avatar
BettyBoop3850 BettyBoop3850 is offline
Cool Cruiser
 
Join Date: Aug 2003
Posts: 316
Default

Cruise ship captain: That rock wasn't on my chart
__________________
HAL Rotterdam 1977 Bermuda

RCCL Song oF Norway 1988 Bermuda

Celebrity Galaxy Oct 24th 03 Caribbean

QM2 Oct. 2004 New England - Canada

Celebrity Constellation Oct 2005 Caribbean

QM2 July-Aug 2006 Mediterranean

QM2 June 10th - July 2nd 2007 Norway

QM2 March 24th - April 6th 2008 Caribbean

Crystal Symphony Oct. 8th-29th 2008 New England/Canada

RCI EOS April26th-May9th 2009

QM2 October 9th - October 29th Around The British Isles

QM2 October 23rd-November 17th 2011 Grand Iberian Adventure

QM2 September 15th-27th 2014 New England and Canada
Reply With Quote

  #24  
Old January 14th, 2012, 10:58 PM
Highlander0108's Avatar
Highlander0108 Highlander0108 is offline
Cool Cruiser
 
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: Connecticut
Posts: 468
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Jim Avery View Post
Interesting difference of tracks. The first site shows much more detail and yes, the ship is obviously not heading back to sea but is virtually ashore on the island. Very curious. I am amazed that, with all the extensive compartmentalization of modern ships, that the list developed so rapidly. Very scary stuff. Heading off to Queen Victoria on Thursday.
I frequent that site often and the underlay map often is quite off , sometimes showing the ship in port, "in" the land. If you study it, the course is actually the same in both sites and both do not show the final turn which had to have happened.
__________________
Costa Victoria Jan 1998 Western Carribean
Cunard QE2 Oct 2000 Carribean Sampler
Costa Magica Apr 2006 Western Caribbean
Costa Magica Apr 2007 Bermuda
Cunard QE2 Jan 2008 Winter Crossing
Cunard QE2 Oct 2008 Final Farewell to the UK
Cunard QM2 Jan 2011 Caribbean Calypso
Carnival Miracle Apr 2012 Eastern Caribbean
Carnival Splendor Apr 2013 Bermuda
Reply With Quote

  #25  
Old January 15th, 2012, 12:32 AM
bazzaw's Avatar
bazzaw bazzaw is offline
5,000+ Club
 
Join Date: Oct 2007
Location: SE Queensland, Australia
Posts: 5,024
Default

The AIS track is obviously missing a number or reporting points - the first 4-5 points are 2-3 minutes apart , but then at the end there is a 15 minute gap in reports. Thus AIS does not show us where the ship was during that missing 15 minutes. The Turkish newspaper report claims that the ship went between those rocks just to the south of the town. I don't know what info they have to support that - but if it is true, that would be mind blowingly incredible!!! The gap between those rocks is only about 60 metres -- http://maps.google.com.au/maps?hl=en...h&z=17&vpsrc=6 I simply can't believe that any cruiseship would try to go through there!!

Barry
__________________
A Blog of our unusual "World Cruise" - Brisbane to Brisbane, Australia - 12 weeks on two different P&O ships, Oriana and Arcadia - with a White Christmas in-between....UK 2010

A review of our 28 day cruise to Tahiti on Pacific Pearl.... Pacific Pearl to Tahiti

Pics of our "3 Queens" cruise with Cunard--May/Jun 2012...Plane, Cunard and train to Germany

Pics of our 14 nights on Voyager of the Seas -- to NZ...On a BIG ship to NZ

A report of the inaugural cruise by Pacific Dawn to Papua New Guinea ports...Pacific Dawn to PNG

Ships sailed on since 2007

P&O Pacific Star
P&O Pacific Sun x 2
P&O Pacific Dawn x 3
P&O Pacific Pearl
P&O Oriana
P&O Arcadia
Queen Victoria
Queen Elizabeth
Queen Mary 2 x 2
Voyager of the Seas
Radiance of the Seas
Reply With Quote

  #26  
Old January 15th, 2012, 12:34 AM
highcbob highcbob is offline
Cool Cruiser
 
Join Date: Jan 2002
Location: sf usa
Posts: 560
Default From a passenger who was onboard

http://boards.cruisecritic.com/showthread.php?t=1548951
Reply With Quote

  #27  
Old January 15th, 2012, 12:43 AM
Salacia Salacia is offline
5,000+ Club
 
Join Date: Apr 2010
Location: USA
Posts: 7,315
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by safarigal View Post
We are on QV at the moment, and the captain just made an announcement about the Costa ship. He also reassured us that the officers and crew on QV were well trained in emergencies. He then went on to say that the weather is deteriorating and we can expect a stormy night tonight.................

Hi safarigal. Thanks for your post; best wishes to you and all the ships at sea. Regards, -S
Reply With Quote

  #28  
Old January 15th, 2012, 01:23 AM
Salacia Salacia is offline
5,000+ Club
 
Join Date: Apr 2010
Location: USA
Posts: 7,315
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Jimsgirl View Post
I always attend the muster no matter which ship I am on, BUT I will admit that in the past I have sighed , wished I had the nerve not to go, and listened with only half my mind on that being said.

In future I will be far more attentive, and never think of not attending in.

That is the lesson we should all learn from this terrible event and the discussion here.

Mrs Jimsgirl, I also plead guilty to not paying attention to muster drills after the first 7 or 8 voyges on QM2.

But considering the events on the Costa Concordia, with the ship listing to such a degree by the time the abandon ship was called, muster drill was rendered meaningless. (If your muster station is underwater, where do you go?) Passengers rely on the captain and crew, but we also (hopefully) know not to panic.

Unfortunately, we know that all too often the facts of the situation are not communicated to passengers; to me, this is a breach of trust.
Reply With Quote

  #29  
Old January 15th, 2012, 04:45 AM
ToadOfToadHall's Avatar
ToadOfToadHall ToadOfToadHall is offline
Cool Cruiser
 
Join Date: Apr 2011
Location: Chester, UK
Posts: 656
Default

The thing about the muster/safety drill is that is utterly pointless.

Before I'm abused for saying that, I'll tell you why I think it.

1) I've briefly worked on an off-shore North See oil rig. To be allowed to go I had to undertake a 5-day off-shore survival course. So when I first went to the ship's safety briefly and realised the whole thing was a total waste of time.

2) I work on an industrial site from time to time. Everyone who is on the site must watch a safety video once a month. One of the things on it is what the two alarms sound like and what to do if they go off ( one is the fire alarm, the other is if there is a toxic chemical incident ). A few months ago, one of the alarms did go off and nearly every one walked outside and headed to the fire assembly point. The problem was that is was the gas alarm, so they did totally the wrong thing. But, they have all seen to video, so they should have all know what to do - but they didn't.

3) I reckon if you ask a passenger on a ship what they were told in the safety briefing an hour after it ended, I'd bet most people will not be able to tell you, and if they do, it will most likely be wrong.

My point is, my occupation sometimes takes me to hazardous work places, and I see "tick box" safety all the time. I could give you loads more examples of the rubbish I see, all in the name of "health and safety" and the muster briefing on a cruise ship is a prime example.
Reply With Quote

  #30  
Old January 15th, 2012, 05:03 AM
bazzaw's Avatar
bazzaw bazzaw is offline
5,000+ Club
 
Join Date: Oct 2007
Location: SE Queensland, Australia
Posts: 5,024
Default

I can see your point - and as an ex-Navy man, I have always known that if some major emergency was to happen on a cruiseship (I have been mainly thinking of fire up until now), chaos would reign.

The average age of many cruiseship passengers is quite high - and the average fitness level is low (many are morbidly obese) . Can you imagine what would happen if a large cruiseship was to have a major fire and undisciplined civilian elderly/unfit passengers had to get up perhaps 5-6 decks by stairs in the dark (can't use lifts), etc.

My understanding is that the "safety lectures" on Costa ships are done in 5 languages -- is this so??

Barry
__________________
A Blog of our unusual "World Cruise" - Brisbane to Brisbane, Australia - 12 weeks on two different P&O ships, Oriana and Arcadia - with a White Christmas in-between....UK 2010

A review of our 28 day cruise to Tahiti on Pacific Pearl.... Pacific Pearl to Tahiti

Pics of our "3 Queens" cruise with Cunard--May/Jun 2012...Plane, Cunard and train to Germany

Pics of our 14 nights on Voyager of the Seas -- to NZ...On a BIG ship to NZ

A report of the inaugural cruise by Pacific Dawn to Papua New Guinea ports...Pacific Dawn to PNG

Ships sailed on since 2007

P&O Pacific Star
P&O Pacific Sun x 2
P&O Pacific Dawn x 3
P&O Pacific Pearl
P&O Oriana
P&O Arcadia
Queen Victoria
Queen Elizabeth
Queen Mary 2 x 2
Voyager of the Seas
Radiance of the Seas
Reply With Quote

  #31  
Old January 15th, 2012, 05:38 AM
balf balf is offline
Cool Cruiser
 
Join Date: Sep 2008
Posts: 1,997
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by guernseyguy View Post
The ship is operating a circular itinerary, with most passengers embarking and disembarking in Savona - and they had their drill 6 days ago. Some passengers boarded yesterday in Civitavecchia and they would have had their muster drill tomorrow with the newly boarded Savona passengers, within 24 hours of sailing, as required by law.
I have always thought this to be very unsafe practice.

David.
Reply With Quote

  #32  
Old January 15th, 2012, 05:38 AM
Cruachan's Avatar
Cruachan Cruachan is offline
5,000+ Club
 
Join Date: May 2007
Location: Old York
Posts: 5,532
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by bazzaw View Post
I can see your point - and as an ex-Navy man, I have always known that if some major emergency was to happen on a cruiseship (I have been mainly thinking of fire up until now), chaos would reign.

The average age of many cruiseship passengers is quite high - and the average fitness level is low (many are morbidly obese) . Can you imagine what would happen if a large cruiseship was to have a major fire and undisciplined civilian elderly/unfit passengers had to get up perhaps 5-6 decks by stairs in the dark (can't use lifts), etc.

My understanding is that the "safety lectures" on Costa ships are done in 5 languages -- is this so??

Barry
Another thing that has always worried me about the muster drill is that it is predicated on the idea that you will go from your cabin to "your" muster station, and the muster stations are basically arranged so that there is a more or less even distribution of cabins to muster stations.

All this is fine if the accident happens, for example, during the early hours of the morning when just about everyone is in their cabin. But if it happens during the day when passengers are spread around ever public space from one end of the ship to the other then the probability of mayhem becomes a self fulfilling prophecy.

J
__________________
Reply With Quote

  #33  
Old January 15th, 2012, 06:02 AM
Nippy Sweetie's Avatar
Nippy Sweetie Nippy Sweetie is offline
Cool Cruiser
 
Join Date: May 2007
Location: Scotland
Posts: 530
Default

A scary prospect indeed. Just thinking about it all happening in the dark too while all dressed up..............
Good point about the predominance of elderly and pretty infirm people who enjoy cruising too. Oh dear oh dear
__________________
Previous cruises: QE2 X3, Viking Pride X1, Arcadia X1, Avalon Scenery X1, Avalon Creativity X1, QVX1. Viking Douro X1
Reply With Quote

  #34  
Old January 15th, 2012, 06:30 AM
cinta's Avatar
cinta cinta is offline
Cool Cruiser
 
Join Date: Oct 2007
Location: Thornbury (like anyone would know it!), uk
Posts: 952
Default

It's even scarier if you add alcohol into the equation at that time of night, in evening wear & spread all over the ship= Bedlam!

A lady has posted on the Costa forum telling her story. She & her family are waiting to fly back to Oz. It sounds terrifying.
__________________
Steve & Sharon travelled on:
QM2 WB TA 23rd april 2006
QV tandem WB TA crossing 6 january 2008
QM2 WB TA 2nd June 2008
QM2 EB TA 8th June 2008
QV WB TA on 2nd january 2009
QV 30th August 2009, Gallic Getaway I
QM2 11th January 2010, Soton to Dubai
QV Mediterranean Medley 14th May 2010
QE tandem WB TA 5th January 2011
QV Mediterranean Gems 10th May 2011
QM2 Iberian Adventure 30th October 2011
QV EB TA 16th March 2012
QV Canaries November 201N3
QM2 Northern Highlights May 3013
QE WB TA January 2014
To come:
QV voyage to Liverpool to celebrate 175 years of Cunard, May 2015
Reply With Quote

  #35  
Old January 15th, 2012, 06:39 AM
Ubarrow Ubarrow is offline
Cool Cruiser
 
Join Date: Sep 2010
Posts: 33
Default

I do think that many commentators are completely missing the point here.

If you knew nothing about this incident but were simply shown the pictures and told that the ship was nearly full and asked how many casualties there were then most people would come up with far larger numbers than seem to be the case.

I live near Grayrigg and was there the morning after the train crash. I looked at the scene of devastation along with the intact carriages and vowed to travel in this type of train wherever possible.

Clearly this accident should never have happened (whatever the cause) but the ship having got into this position the fact that the vast majority of passengers are safe and well is a tribute to the crew, the passengers and the safety systems.

Last edited by Ubarrow; January 15th, 2012 at 06:39 AM.
Reply With Quote

  #36  
Old January 15th, 2012, 08:02 AM
Ray66's Avatar
Ray66 Ray66 is offline
Blue Ribbon Cruiser
 
Join Date: Jan 2009
Location: UK
Posts: 3,043
Default

The number not accounted for has now been set at just 17 (previously around 40) - 11 passengers and 6 crew.

Still just 3 people confirmed dead.
__________________

QM2 - Transatlantic roundtrip via Halifax - June 2014
QM2 - Fjords - July 2013
QV - Fjords - July 2012 (3 Queens Southampton)
QE - Spring Getaway - May 2012
QE - Maiden Baltic & St Petersburg - June 2011
QV - Norwegian Wonders - July 2010
QV - Weekend Getaway - April 2010
QV - Gallic Getaway - October 2009
QM2 - Iberian Odyssey - July 2009
QM2 - Hamburg - August 2008
Reply With Quote

  #37  
Old January 15th, 2012, 08:44 AM
Freecall Freecall is offline
Cool Cruiser
 
Join Date: Feb 2009
Posts: 1,062
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by Ubarrow View Post
I do think that many commentators are completely missing the point here.

If you knew nothing about this incident but were simply shown the pictures and told that the ship was nearly full and asked how many casualties there were then most people would come up with far larger numbers than seem to be the case.

I live near Grayrigg and was there the morning after the train crash. I looked at the scene of devastation along with the intact carriages and vowed to travel in this type of train wherever possible.

Clearly this accident should never have happened (whatever the cause) but the ship having got into this position the fact that the vast majority of passengers are safe and well is a tribute to the crew, the passengers and the safety systems.
Totally agree.
Reply With Quote

  #38  
Old January 15th, 2012, 10:38 AM
BlueRiband's Avatar
BlueRiband BlueRiband is offline
Cool Cruiser
 
Join Date: Mar 2011
Location: NYC
Posts: 1,767
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by ToadOfToadHall View Post
The thing about the muster/safety drill is that is utterly pointless... I had to undertake a 5-day off-shore survival course. So when I first went to the ship's safety briefly and realised the whole thing was a total waste of time...
I'll take a chance and disagreeing with you since what happens on an oil rig is considerably more volatile than a sailing on a cruise ship.



At the very least, after a muster drill people know that they are supposed to stop whatever else they were doing, grab medication and other essentials, get their life vest and show up at the appointed place. (If the ship was so catastrophically damaged that ALL of the muster stations were submerged then of course this would be pointless.)


On a port call in Barbados in December 2010, the QM2 crew had a drill deploying the port side lifeboats. Some ships crew were inside suited up in their safety gear so presumably that boat would be their charge should the situation ever come to that. (Whether they would still keep up these standards now that the ship is the "Bermuda Queen" is another argument.)



With all do respect, what to you therefore propose? Mandatory attendance at a safety video before the ship sails? What if somebody doesn't attend? Put them off the ship? Perhaps ban evening wear in case there should be an emergency?
__________________
Queen Mary 2: 2004 Caribbean, 2010 Caribbean, 2011 NY-British Isles-NY, 2012 Canada, 2013 NY-Norway-NY, 2014 Canada
Reply With Quote

  #39  
Old January 15th, 2012, 11:08 AM
ToadOfToadHall's Avatar
ToadOfToadHall ToadOfToadHall is offline
Cool Cruiser
 
Join Date: Apr 2011
Location: Chester, UK
Posts: 656
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by mariepr View Post
With all do respect, what to you therefore propose? Mandatory attendance at a safety video before the ship sails?
No, the complete opposite. If you read the example I gave about the fire alarm/gas alarm incident that I witnessed, what I'm saying is the safety briefings/videos or whatever are a waste of time.

People simply don't take the information in, i.e. these briefings serve no real purpose, so don't bother with them.

But, that will never happen, because the main purpose of the safety briefing is to protect the company involved from any legal action.

Quote:
Originally Posted by mariepr View Post
after a muster drill people know that they are supposed to stop whatever else they were doing, grab medication and other essentials,
You see, that's wrong. If the ship is sinking or on fire, people should not be wasting time looking for their pills or anything else. What can be "essential" given the fact that the ship is sinking ?
Reply With Quote

  #40  
Old January 15th, 2012, 11:42 AM
BlueRiband's Avatar
BlueRiband BlueRiband is offline
Cool Cruiser
 
Join Date: Mar 2011
Location: NYC
Posts: 1,767
Default

We're going to have to disaree on this one. At least people know what they are supposed to do when the alarm sounds. (Whether they do it or not is another issue.)

As for the legal issues, I couldn't agree more. There was an earlier thread where the QM2 stated the emergency procedures during the gas turbine fire. One person commented that they were "ninety minutes from loading the life boats". It appears the cruise lines are in a lose-lose situtation. Start emergency procedures and they're accused of inciting unnecessary alarm. Don't start them in time (as one of the Concordia survivers recounted) and the situation is worse.
__________________
Queen Mary 2: 2004 Caribbean, 2010 Caribbean, 2011 NY-British Isles-NY, 2012 Canada, 2013 NY-Norway-NY, 2014 Canada
Reply With Quote

Reply

Bookmarks


Ad Sponsored By
Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Forum Jump


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 01:37 AM.


© 1995 - 2014, The Independent Traveler, Inc. All rights reserved.
"A Community of People Who Love To Cruise"
All of the information contained within Cruise Critic is protected by copyright. You may, however, download a single copy only for your personal use.