Explorer vs. Freedom

Welcome to Cruise Critic! If you'd like to participate on our forums by joining in the conversation, please Register Now! Be sure to visit our FAMOUS Roll Call forums, where you can meet other cruisers sailing with you and share a tour or shore excursion and SAVE MONEY!

#1
Palmyra, PA
80 Posts
Joined Oct 2011
Can anyone that has cruised on both the Explorer of the Seas and Freedom of the Seas give me a comparison? My family has sailed twice on the FOS and have absolutely loved it. The ship was perfect, and would love to do it again.

Being that we are from Pennsylvania, and have 5 people traveling, it can be quite expensive to fly to Florida. Also, we usually tend to travel in January in order to get out of the cold, so therefore fly down 2 days ahead of time in case bad weather would cancel or delay our flight, which adds 2 nights of hotel stays. Add in transportation to and from the airport, plus meals while in Florida and we are already out $2000 or so before we even board.

Another alternative would be to simply drive the 3 hours and take the Explorer of the Seas out of NJ. Of course we would have parking and tolls, but those would pale in comparison to the other charges listed above.

Can anyone that has traveled on both give me a comparison. My wife and I are both in our 30's, traveling with an 18, 13 and 10 year old. Is there as much to do on the ship? Will we notice a big difference in the size of the ship? Any help is appreciated!
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Carnival Victory - Jan 2006 Western Caribbean
RC Freedom of the Seas - Jan 2009 Western Caribbean
RC Freedom of the Seas - Jan 2012 Eastern Caribbean
RC Explorer of the Seas - June 2014 Eastern Caribbean
RC Navigator of the Seas - Jan 2016 Eastern Caribbean


#2
Dayton, Ohio
1,500 Posts
Joined Apr 2003
Have sailed on both and they are more similar than not.

Sailing out of NJ in the winter, you will have about 1.5 cold days going south and about the same coming back north. Can't enjoy the outside pool deck much.

Will not have flow rider on Explorer or the kids water park area. The promenade is a bit shorter on Explorer. Sorrentos and Cafe promenade are combined.

Cabin sizes are about the same. Balconies on Explorer are part of the infrastructure, therfore surrounded by steel, and the railing is half steel, half plexiglass.

Most of the public areas are about the same.
Dining rooms, theatre, lounges....

My DH says that Freedom class is just Voyager class on steroids.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Ellen

FUTURE CRUISES

Celebrity Equinox Oct 27,2017
OASIS OF THE SEAS FEB11,2018

#3
Columbus, OH USA
26,672 Posts
Joined Oct 2005
Originally posted by cruizinEllen
Dining rooms, theatre, lounges....
On Freedom, I will add the Solarium is a bit bigger with a slightly larger pool. The Windjammer is also a bit bigger and just from perception is one of the larger ones passenger vs seating in the fleet.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
1st cruise 4/29/06 RCCL Voyager of the Seas. - Eastern Caribbean.
2nd cruise - 5/11/07 Majesty of the Seas - Bahamas. MOTHER'S day cruise!
3rd cruise - 4/27/08 Freedom of the Seas -Western Caribbean. Freedom's 100th cruise!
4th cruise - 4/16/09 Navigator of the Seas - Cozumel/Belize.
5th cruise 11/15/10 Majesty of the Seas - Key West Nassau.
6th cruise -5/1/11 Allure of the Seas Eastern route 30th anniversary cruise
7th cruise 4/14/12 Jewel of the Seas Cozumel Costa Maya
8th cruise 4/28/13 Allure of the Seas Eastern route
9th cruise 10/28/13 Majesty of the Seas Halloween in Key West
10th cruise 5/3/14 Jewel of the Seas Southern Caribbean
11th cruise 4/26/15 Freedom of the Seas Western Caribbean
12th cruise 4/30/16 Oasis of the Seas Eastern Caribbean
13th cruise 10/17/16 Majesty of the Seas 4 day from Port Canaveral Bahamas
14th cruise 4/29/17 Adventure of the Seas Southern Caribbean ABC islands.
81 great night's sleep

21 days on an Oasis class, 19 days on a Voyager class,15 days on a Sovereign class ship, 14 days on a Freedom class, 12 days on a Radiance class, .








My long signature will annoy some people. I'm ok with that.
#5
Palmyra, PA
80 Posts
Joined Oct 2011
Thanks for both replies so far, I appreciate it. We are looking at our next cruise possibly in May 2014 (Good Lord that is so long away!) I'm sure the temperatures should be a lot better than January obviously, but maybe not warm enough to be out by the pool for a day down, and back. Maybe we could make it up by doing a 9 or 10 day cruise instead of a 7. With what we save in travel costs we would be able to afford it!

I haven't done the Flow Rider, and don't plan on it, and our kids are old enough that they don't need the Splash Zone, so we would be ok there.

Our main areas of the ship that we enjoy most are the pool, Promenade, Wind Jammer, casino and Main Dining room. It sounds like both ships are comparable in those areas.

Is the overall appearance of the ship seem to be up to date and well kept? That's also another thing that makes the FOS as nice as it is. They seem to do a good job of keeping it clean.

Any more opinions would be appreciated!
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Carnival Victory - Jan 2006 Western Caribbean
RC Freedom of the Seas - Jan 2009 Western Caribbean
RC Freedom of the Seas - Jan 2012 Eastern Caribbean
RC Explorer of the Seas - June 2014 Eastern Caribbean
RC Navigator of the Seas - Jan 2016 Eastern Caribbean


#6
New Jersey
2,655 Posts
Joined Apr 2008
Originally posted by ClemsonTiger96
Our main areas of the ship that we enjoy most are the pool, Promenade, Wind Jammer, casino and Main Dining room. It sounds like both ships are comparable in those areas.

Is the overall appearance of the ship seem to be up to date and well kept? That's also another thing that makes the FOS as nice as it is. They seem to do a good job of keeping it clean.

Any more opinions would be appreciated!
We've never sailed on the Freedom but have sailed several times on the Explorer. The ship is very well maintained. It is kept very clean. The crew is very friendly and accommondating.

If you sail in May you can book an itinerary that includes Bermuda, something that you can't do when sailing out of Florida. We've done the 9 night Bermuda and the Caribbean cruise and really enjoyed it. Bermuda is so different from the Caribbean islands.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Madeline
#7
The Jersey Shore
6,195 Posts
Joined Mar 2003
Originally posted by ClemsonTiger96
Thanks for both replies so far, I appreciate it. We are looking at our next cruise possibly in May 2014 (Good Lord that is so long away!) I'm sure the temperatures should be a lot better than January obviously, but maybe not warm enough to be out by the pool for a day down, and back. Maybe we could make it up by doing a 9 or 10 day cruise instead of a 7. With what we save in travel costs we would be able to afford it!

I haven't done the Flow Rider, and don't plan on it, and our kids are old enough that they don't need the Splash Zone, so we would be ok there.

Our main areas of the ship that we enjoy most are the pool, Promenade, Wind Jammer, casino and Main Dining room. It sounds like both ships are comparable in those areas.

Is the overall appearance of the ship seem to be up to date and well kept? That's also another thing that makes the FOS as nice as it is. They seem to do a good job of keeping it clean.

Any more opinions would be appreciated!
I've been on both as well, and have been on Explorer 6 or 7 times. Your main areas of concern are definitely comparable. There is not a HUGE enough difference in those areas on both of the ships.

Explorer is still a beautiful, shiny ship! You'll find that maybe some of the furniture looks a bit worn, but that's if you look for it. She is still a beauty. And we LOVE the extra few days onboard Explorer versus having to fly to go on Freedom (although I do love that ship as well!). If you really don't want to fly, I wouldn't hesitate one second to go on Explorer!
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
***Christie***
ROYAL CARIBBEAN ROCKS!!!!
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
* Carnival Mardi Gras - July '89 * RC Nordic Empress - April '91 * Celebrity Galaxy - Jan '98
* Carnival Destiny - Oct '98 * RC Explorer of the Seas - Oct '03 My Review * RC FREEDOM OF THE SEAS - Sept '06
*** RC Liberty of the Seas Pre-Inaugural - May '07*** THANK YOU, RCI!!!
*RC Enchantment of the Seas - May '07 *RC Explorer of the Seas - October '07 My Review* NCL Spirit 1-nite CTN - Sept '08 * RC Liberty of the Seas - Nov '08 My Review * RC Explorer of the Seas - April '09 * RC Explorer of the Seas - April/May 2010 * RC Oasis of the Seas - Oct '10 * RC Explorer of the Seas - Nov '11 My Review *RC Explorer of the Seas - Nov '12*RC Quantum of the Seas - Dec '14 - My Review!*RC Freedom of the Seas - Nov '16

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

#8
Virginia
2,099 Posts
Joined Dec 2001
Random question... on Explorer, in the Solarium pool, what is the access into the water? Is it a ladder or stairs?
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature

Grandeur of the Seas 12/21/17
Majesty of the Seas 03/24/17
Grandeur of the Seas 12/22/16
Grandeur of the Seas 05/12/16
Independence of the Seas 12/28/15
Grandeur of the Seas 11/21/14
Explorer of the Seas 04/10/14
Explorer of the Seas 11/23/13
Enchantment of the Seas 03/25/13
Enchantment of the Seas 11/17/12
Enchantment of the Seas 03/31/12
Freedom of the Seas 04/24/11
Freedom of the Seas 04/04/10
2009 - bust... Destination trip to Montego Bay instead
Mariner of the Seas 06/15/08
Mariner of the Seas 04/08/07
Navigator of the Seas 4/15/06
Mariner of the Seas 3/27/05
Mariner of the Seas 4/11/04
Disney Magic 12/01/01
#9
NJ
347 Posts
Joined May 2012
I was advised against sailing out of explorer in January for the reasons mentioned -- it would be cold the first day and a half and last day and a half, meaning 3/7 days would be cold! Kind of a bummer when a perk of january cruising is to get AWAY from the cold :P
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature


Previous: Independence of the Seas Jan 2013 (Honeymoon Cruise!)
#10
Pennsylvania
1,974 Posts
Joined Jul 2008
Been on Explorer many times and on Liberty(same as Freedom) twice. Other then the flowrider and the Freedom being longer the main difference is the elevators. Both ships have the same number of elevators but the number of people using them is greater on the Freedom class. We rarely use the elevators but the waiting crowds made it difficult to walk past the elevators. We prefer the Explorer.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Future
Celebrity Solstice - 7/14/2017 - Alaska
Celebrity Silhouette - 8/11/17 - British Isles
Jewel of the Seas - 10/25/17 - Mediterranean
Jewel of the Seas - 11/6/17 - Trans-Atlantic
Serenade of the Seas - 5/27/18 - Scan. and Russia
Serenade of the Seas - 6/3/18 - Arctic Circle
Adventure of the Seas - 7/27/18 - Canada/New England
Serenade of the Seas - 8/26/18 - Trans-Atlantic
Completed
MSC Divina - 2/4/17 - Caribbean and Antillies, Harmony of the Seas - 10/23/16 - Trans-Atlantic, Harmony of the Seas - 10/20/16 - Western Med. Anthem of the Seas - 5/5/16 - Bermuda and Caribbean, Serenade of the Seas - 2/5/16 - Southern Caribbean, Celebrity Solstice - 10/2/15 - Tahitian Treasures, Celebrity Solstice - 9/22/15 - Hawaii, Celebrity Summit - 7/26/15 - Bermuda, Liberty of the Seas - 5/21/15 - Bermuda and Caribbean, Legend of the Seas - 2/6/15 - So. Caribbean, Explorer of the Seas - 11/01/14 - So. Caribbean Adventure(repositioning), Explorer of the Seas - 7/31/14 - Bermuda/Caribbean, Legend of the Seas - 5/10/14 - Scandinavia/Russia, Legend of the Seas - 5/2/14 - Norwegian Fjords, Legend of the Seas - 2/3/14 - Southern Caribbean, Jewel of the Seas - 10/5/13 - Southern Caribbean, Jewel of the Seas - 10/12/13 - Southern Caribbean, Explorer of the Seas - Bermuda/Caribbean - 5/16/2013, Vision of the Seas - Eastern Caribbean - 1/25/2013, Liberty of the Seas - Trans. Atlantic - 10/27/2012, Liberty of the Seas - Western Med. - 10/20/2012, Explorer of the Seas - Bermuda/Caribbean - 04/26/2012, Jewel of the Seas - Western Caribbean - 01/21/2012, Jewel of the Seas - Repositioning - 10/29/2011, Explorer of the Seas - Bermuda/Caribbean - 4/28/2011, Explorer of the Seas - So. Caribbean - 11/07/2010, Explorer of the Seas - Bermuda/Caribbean - 4/29/2010, Jewel of the Seas - New England/Canada - 09/2009, Jewel of the Seas - Panama Canal - 04/2009, Radiance of the Seas - Alaska Cruise Tour - 08/2008
#11
Kentucky
299 Posts
Joined Oct 2007
Those days going to and from the Caribbean via the Atlantic on the Explorer can entail substantial ship movement. I loved Explorer, but if any of you guys are bad about motion sickness, and hard to treat for it, might be a factor.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
RCI's Adventure of the Seas 7-day Southern Caribbean Cruise - April '06.
Celebrity's Constellation 11-day Ultimate Caribbean Cruise - February '08.
RCI's Liberty of the Seas 7-day Western Caribbean Cruise - January '11.
RCI's Explorer of the Seas 9-day Eastern Caribbean Cruise - November '12.
RCI's Adventure of the Seas 7-day Southern Caribbean Cruise - January '14.
RCI's Oasis of the Seas 7-day Eastern Caribbean Cruise - December '14.
RCI's Allure of the Seas 7-day Western Caribbean Cruise - February '16.
RCI's Allure of the Seas 7-day Eastern Caribbean Cruise - Feb./March '17.
#12
Pittsburgh, PA
232 Posts
Joined Jan 2006
Having been on both of the ships, I would add that the casino is bigger on the FOS. Also, the FOS has fresh water pools and whirlpools. This makes a big difference to my 12 year old daughter. Also, she really enjoys the H2oZone that the FOS has. Enjoy!
Bill
#13
Rockaway, NJ
2,346 Posts
Joined Feb 2004
Originally posted by Candleonwater
Random question... on Explorer, in the Solarium pool, what is the access into the water? Is it a ladder or stairs?
The Solarium pool has stairs
#14
17,899 Posts
Joined Jun 2002
I've been on them both..EX about 11 times.. and Freedom once, in November.

I loved both ships...however, i will say that i prefer the crew on EX overall....hard to explain, but I personally didn't really feel the love...also, our dinner arrangements were a little odd...we usually have MTD, but same time, same table on EX....

On FR, we had trouble with this, and overall I wasn't happy with the MDR.

That said, I had a splendid time on Freedom...beautiful ship and I don't think you could go wrong with either...
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Cape Liberty Info blog

Cruise Photo Albums

My Cruise History:
Royal-too many to count, X-3, NCL-2, CCL-too many to count, MSC-1, HAL-1
So many cruises, so little time and money!

illegitmi non carborundum kmt
#15
virginia
7,503 Posts
Joined Oct 2010
We sailed on the Explorer in October. She was a beautiful ship and had lots to do. For the children they have inline skate area, ice skating, rock wall and mini golf. All of the public areas are nicely done and you will not be disappointed. Also, they added the freestyle Coke machines in October. [a nice feature for the kiddos]

One surprise for us was that the Solarium was not an indoor pool.

This would be an issue for me leaving New Jersey in the winter.

I agree with the person that said you will get motion on the ocean in winter. Every time we have taken a winter cruise from Baltimore we run into a storm or stron winds around North Carolina. We now avoid leaving Baltimore in the winter. [I am sure NJ is very similar]
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature


Previous Cruises:Carnival Ecstasy– July 2000: Mexico; Carnival Fantasy– August 2006: Bahamas; Carnival Pride –October 2009: Bahamas; Celebrity Constellation–March 2010: Panama Canal; Enchantment of the Seas–June 2010: Eastern Caribbean, September 2010: New England and Canada, March 2012: Southern Caribbean; Celebrity Mercury–November 2010 Eastern Caribbean and January 2011 Bahamas and Florida; Carnival Legend –April 2011: Western Caribbean; Radiance of the Seas--Alaska; August 2012, Explorer of the Seas--Bermuda: October 2012; Legend of the Seas –Transatlantic, October 2013; Brilliance of the Seas--North Atlantic TA: August 2014; Vision of the Seas--Southern Caribbean: November 2014; Serenade of the Seas--B2B Bahamas and Western Caribbean: March/April 2015; Southern Caribbean: November 2015; Grandeur of the Seas–June 2005: Bermuda, April 2013: Caribbean reposition cruise; March 2014: Western Caribbean, April 2016: Eastern Caribbean, July 2016: Bermuda/Bahamas, Harmony of The Seas-- October 2016: Transatlantic, Equinox-- .February 2017: Mardi Gras cruise
#16
kingston ontario canada
42 Posts
Joined Jul 2002
We sailed on Explorer Dec 22nd and made it to the pool on our second day. Watch out for the seas around Cape Hatteras. It was a little rough going down (Day 1) and really really rough on the way back January 3rd-70 MPH winds and 30 ft waves. (This I think was unusual as photos were for sale showing the waves crashing on the bow of the ship).
Great ship & I would sail from NJ again.
#17
895 Posts
Joined Jan 2012
Freedom has flowriders, cantilevered hot tub, fresh water pools.

Other than that, it's pretty similar.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
<img src="http://ticker.cruise-ships.com/002/ab17276eeac1c9f9a6ca22c9eaa3a5db.png" alt="Cruise Ship - Ticker" border="0"/>
#19
Boston area
18,423 Posts
Joined Jan 2007
The EX has an indoor hot tub in the fitness center which is very nice if the weather is cool.

Like Meg I have been on the EX many times and on the Freedom once last November. I found that there was more walking on Freedom because it was a longer ship. Despite the fact that the cruise terminal in Port Canaveral is gorgeous, there was a lot of walking to get into the terminal, checked in and onto the ship. Bayonne is an ugly port, but I find the terminal to be much easier because it is small. I prefer taking the shuttle bus to the gangway and entering directly to the elevators on deck 1 over all the walking just to enter the ship on deck 4 in FL.

I'd also rather take a 9 day cruise from Bayonne than spend two days in the airline system going back and forth to FL.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature


Carol
Radiance Alaska 5/17/17 to 6/3/17


#20
New York
2,091 Posts
Joined Sep 2008
We have sailed both and have kids the same age as yours......the main differences for us were the flowrider (which was huge for our kids) and how the kids club was run (which changes frequently from ship to ship).

Our kids missed the Freedom and wouldn't want to do the Explorer again but this was because it lacked the flowrider. If not having the flowrider isn't a big deal to your kids, I think you will be fine.

The other thing that bothered our kids was having too many sea days, this was not helped by, at that time, poorly run kids clubs.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature

Sailed Cruises
Celebrity Zenith.....................4/1993 (E.Caribbean)
Disney Magic.........................10/1999(Bahamas)
Disney Wonder.......................8/2008(Bahamas)
RCCL Freedom of the Seas......8/2009(Western Caribbean)
RCCL Explorer of the Seas......4/2011 (Bermuda&Bahamas) review
RCCL Freedom of the Seas......8/2011(Western Caribbean)
Carnival Liberty......................8/2012(Western Caribbean)
RCCL Freedom of the Seas...7/2013(Western Caribbean)