Welcome to Cruise Critic! If you'd like to participate on our forums by joining in the conversation, please Register Now! Be sure to visit our FAMOUS Roll Call forums, where you can meet other cruisers sailing with you and share a tour or shore excursion and SAVE MONEY!
If you love Celebrity food but had to pick another...
For me, the cruise is 70% itinerary and 30% food. I could not care less about the rest. Okay, maybe the enrichment talks. So, I have been on Celebrity, RCCL, NCL, and Carnival and by far Celebrity blew the rest away-from the Asian breakfast bar to the lychee sorbet to the chocolate croissants to the sushi and everything I ate in the dining room. I absolutely hated 90% of what I ate on Carnival, found the MDR of RCCL okay but most of the food ended up at the buffet so I just ate there on my own time, and NCL was kind of forgettable. Since food is so subjective my question is geared towards anyone who would agree that Celebrity rocks and who has been on Princess and/or HAL. Reviews I have seen seems to compare HAL more with with Celebrity and Princess with RCCL in terms of food-would you agree? Maybe the question should be "which is least like Carnival?"
Carnival Valor, 2006 W. Caribbean
Norwegian Pearl, 2008 Bahamas
Celebrity Millenium, 2010 S. Caribbean
Carnival Spirit, 2011 Mexican Riviera
RCCL Radiance, 2012 South Pacific
I just got back from a cruise on the Celebrity Millennium, after two Princess cruises on the Island Princess. In 2 days I'm leaving on the Star Princess and am looking to confirm my position on exactly this subject. Gut feeling right now----the food in the Main Dining Room on the Princess ships was better, but the buffet on Celebrity had a slight edge in terms of variety and quality. I did all my meals at dinner and most of my breakfasts and lunches on the Millennium in the MDR. Food just didn't seem as exciting as it was on the Princess ships, both in terms of variety and creativity. I'll report back after I get back and see if Princess is still better.
05-November 2010 Island Princess Panama Canal Full Transit
13-April 2009 Island Princess Panama Canal Partial Transit
05-Oct-2008 RCCL Vision of the Seas Mexican Riviera
20-Oct-2003 RCCL Monarch Of The Seas Baja Mexico
08-Nov-1992 RCCL Monarch Of The Seas
We've been on Celebrity, Princess, HAL and RCI, and I'm afraid I don't find huge differences from one cruise line to the other (although I think of the four, RCI is the weakest in this area).
Each seems to have some things that are better; for example, Celebrity has the AquaSpa Cafι with free made-to-order items, HAL and Princess have some great desserts, HAL has some nice stir-fries, Princess has great pizza and the International Cafe...
The food on Celebrity is by far better than the food on NCL, Princess, RCI, Cunard, and Holland America.
To move up, you can try Blu (Aqua Class) on Celebrity; or Azamara; or Oceania.
Higher up and you are into the very Premium Lines like Crystal, Silversea ,
I prefer small amounts of high quality food, so volume is not a concern for me.
Celebrity -- Horizon (93), Galaxy (97), Zenith (98), Constellation (02), Century (02), Millennium (03), Summit (04), Mercury (05), Galaxy (05), Century (06), Millennium (06) , Constellation (08), Constellation (08), Solstice (09), Solstice (10), Eclipse (11), Summit (11), Millennium (11), Silhouette ('12), Silhouette ('12), Silhouette ('13), Infinity ('13), Infinity ('13), Century ('13), Century ('14), and Eclipse ('14).
Holland America -- Veendam (03), Volendam (04), Zuiderdam (05), Westerdam (06), Maasdam (07), Maasdam (07), Westerdam (08), Maasdam (09), and the Nieuw Amsterdam (11)
Royal Caribbean -- Rhapsody of the Seas (01), Voyager of the Seas (02), Splendor of the Seas (02), Grandeur of the Seas (04), Vision of the Seas (04), Radiance of the Seas (09), Allure of the Seas ('12) and the Navigator of the Seas ('14)
NCL -- Starward (78), Norwegian Dream (95), and the Norweigan Sea (01)
Princess -- Star Princess (03), Caribbean Princess (05), and the Golden Princess ('13)
Azamara -- Journey (07) Oceania -- Regatta (09) Cunard -- Queen Mary 2 (10), and Queen Mary 2 ('13)
Sitmar -- Fairsea (82)
(449 days total)
-------------------------------- Future Cruises: NCL Jewel (03/2015), Celebrity Reflection (6/2015), Royal Caribbean Anthem of the Seas (6/2015), Celebrity Equinox (12/2015), and Celebrity Reflection (3/2016).
Without going on Luxury ships I like Oceania best. Was on TA on Ruby Princess.. Only really excellent food was pizza.But did like the Cafe Caribe nitely International buffets. Much better than their MDR. CC also on Caribbean, Crown and Emerald.
We have cruised on both and have eaten in Blu. It really wasn't to my taste but the wife loved it. For me the food on both is very comparable. Celebrity might get a small nod only because they have one more main course offering on their dinner menu then Princess does but that is hardly a deal breaker for me. My wife pretty much feels the same with the exception of desert. She thinks Celebrity has the best deserts afloat. Before Celebrity she thought the best were on Cunard. I can't comment here as desert for me if I even have it is another appetizer. We have had very good meals on both and we have had some not so memorable ones on both as well. We cruise Princess almost exclusivly now as they offer far more longer itineraries to our liking then does Celebrity.
I hope the food in Holland America is still good...
I hope that the food in Holland America is still good because I just got back from a Celebrity cruise in the Infinity and the the food is nothing like it was even just two years ago. Most of the food in Celebrity is barely passable now and some is down right awful (anything beef, cold soups and buffet ice-cream ). Room service menu very limited now and again very poorly done. The buffet restaurant is a zoo at lunch ( very understaffed ). Wake up Celbrity!, my next cruise will be in Holland America and if that cuisine has gone to the dogs too, I will keep looking.