Does Carnival Loose Money On You?

Welcome to Cruise Critic! If you'd like to participate on our forums by joining in the conversation, please Register Now! Be sure to visit our FAMOUS Roll Call forums, where you can meet other cruisers sailing with you and share a tour or shore excursion and SAVE MONEY!

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts
BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
All times are GMT -4.
The time now is 07:06 AM.
#1
345 Posts
Joined Jan 2011
Does Carnival loose money when you sail? Or, should they be sending you an invitation to the annual Shareholder Banquet?

I am not cheap, but I have to admit, when I sail, my Sign and Sail is VERY tiny. I rarely drink... I don't gamble... I rarely buy anything in the on-board shops (its always the same stuff)... I don't play Bingo... I don't buy shore excursions...

How about you?

Expand Signature
Collapse Signature




12/03/2016 - Carnival Vista - SOUTHERN CARIBBEAN
09/30/2016 - Carnival Valor - EASTERN CARIBBEAN
04/26/2015 – Carnival Splendor – EASTERN CARIBBEAN
1/7/2014 - Carnival Conquest - EASTERN CARIBBEAN
4/19/2014 - Carnival Sunshine - EASTERN CARIBBEAN
9/30/13 - Carnival Elation - - WESTERN CARIBBEAN
12/1/12 - Carnival Dream - EASTERN CARIBBEAN
5/20/2012 - Carnival Legend - WESTERN CARIBBEAN
2/19/2011 - Carnival Dream - WESTERN CARIBBEAN
1/13/2008 - Carnival Liberty - WESTERN CARIBBEAN
1/15/2007 - Carnival Imagination - GRAND CAYMAN and OCHO RIO
12/14/2006 - Carnival Imagination - KEY WEST and CALICA
1/13/2006 - Carnival Fascination - NASSAU
1/9/2006 - Carnival Fascination - KEY WEST & COZUMEL
11/18/2005 - Carnival Fascination - NASSAU
10/30/2005 - Carnival Conquest - WESTERN CARIBBEAN
1/9/2005 - Carnival Fantasy - FREEPORT and NASSAU
3/20/2004 - Carnival Miracle - FREEPORT and MEXICO
1/12/2004 - Carnival Fascination - KEY WEST & COZUMEL
1/20/2003 - Carnival Imagination - BELIZE and KEY WEST
1/7/2002 - Carnival Imagination - GRAND CAYMAN and CALICA
11/14/1993 - Carnival - Fantasy
1/20/1992 - Carnival - Fantasy
#2
3,377 Posts
Joined Jul 2004
The only bill we have are the tips. Like you, we don't gamble or play Bingo and we smuggle so our bar bill is zilch. A couple of cruises we bought a picture of us, but no trinkets at all.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature










Cruises

02/2017 Grand Princess - Hawaii
11/2016 Royal Princess - Caribbean
10/2016 Caribbean Princess - New England
5/2016 Carnival Legend - Alaska
4/2016 Coral Princess - Panama Canal
2/2016 Ruby Princess - Mexican Riviera
1/2016 Ruby Princess - Hawaii
12/2015 Island Princess - Panama Canal
9/2015 Carnival Miracle - Mexico
5/2015 Golden Princess - Alaska
4/2015 Crown Princess - California Coastal
1/2015 Star Princess - Hawaii
10/2014 Star Princess--Mexico
8/2014 Carnival Imagination--Mexico
5/2014 Star Princess (Alaska)
2/2014 Sapphire Princess--Mexico
11/2013 Grand Princess--Hawaii
8/2013 Carnival Miracle--Alaska
1/2013 Inspiration--Mexico
1/2013 Inspiration (b2b)--Mexico
10/2012 Island Princess (Panama Canal)
10/2010 Carnival Spirit--Mexico
10/2010 Carnival Spirit-b2b--Mexico
1/2010 Carnival Splendor--Mexico
1/2009 Carnival Spirit--Mexico
11/2007 Carnival Spirit--Mexico
1/2004 Diamond Princess--Mexico
11/2003 Carnival Pride--Mexico
12/2002 Carnival Elation--Mexico
1/2001 Carnival Elation--Mexico
5/2000 Carnival Elation--Mexico
1986 - RCCL Song of America--Caribbean
1984 - RCCL Song of Norway-
-Caribbean
#3
California
580 Posts
Joined Jan 2009
I wish I could say that I don't spend a lot on the ship, but that's not the case..it's just too easy to swipe that S&S card! I do agree with you about the funshops though...once you've been in one, you've seen pretty much everything they have to offer!

Pictures & alcohol are where they get me...each time I go I say I won't purchase as many photos...
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Carnival Victory - 2007
Norwegian Dawn - 2008
Carnival Pride - 2009, 2010
Norwegian Jewel - 2011
Carnival Freedom - 2013
Carnival Fascination - 2014
Carnival Conquest - 2016

#4
New York
1,045 Posts
Joined Jan 2011
I have sailed with Carnival 6 times with the 7th sailing next week on the Splendor.

My first sailing was in Sep 2003 on the Inspiration. Back then the fares were higher and on this cruise I spent $1,000 in extras such as alcohol, shopping, spa, some pictures and excursions.

Now I spend about $200.00 in extras for the wine package, additional drinks, some onboard shopping and maybe one picture. I don't do excursions anymore. I now like to do my own thing.

So definitely Carnival likes first time cruisers because they probably do spend more than a lot of the veteran cruiser.
#5
Connecticut
20,526 Posts
Joined Apr 2006
The question does make one wonder what the average S&S bill is.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Carnival Celebration (1 sailing) 07/96 (Western Carib.)
Carnival Imagination (2 sailings) 07/98 (Western Carib.) 04/09 (Bahamas)
Carnival Destiny (2 sailings) 08/99 (West. Carib.) 08/03 (Southern Carib.)
Carnival Triumph (1 sailing)07/00 (Eastern Carib.)
Carnival Pride (4 sailings) 07/01 (Western Carib.) 07/05 (Mex. Riviera) 04/12 (Eastern Carib.)12/16 NYE cruise Eastern Carib
RCCL Majesty of the Seas (1 sailing)04/02 (Bahamas)
Carnival Spirit (2 sailings) 07/04 (Alaska) 07/08 (Alaska)
Carnival Valor (1 sailing) 08/05 (Eastern Carib.)
Carnival Ecstasy (1 sailing) 04/06 (Cozumel, Progresso) Platinum Cruise
Carnival Liberty (4 sailings) 07/06 (Med cruise) 02/07 (Panama Canal) 07/08 (Exotic Eastern Carib.)
02/07 (Panama Canal) 02/11 (Exotic Eastern Carib.)
Carnival Inspiration (1 sailing) 8/07 (Western Carib.)
MSC Orchestra (1 sailing) 2/09 (Eastern Carib.)
Carnival Splendor (3 sailings) 08/09 (Mexican Riviera) 08/13 (Eastern out of NYC) Milestone Cruise 08/14 (Eastern out of NYC)

Carnival Dream (1 sailing) 8/10 (Western Carib.)
Carnival Magic (2 sailings) 02/12 (Western Carib.) 02/15 (western Carib.)
Carnival Victory (1 sailing) 08/12 (Southern Carib.)
Carnival Legend (1 sailing) 02/13 (Western Carib.)
Carnival Breeze (3 sailings) 04/13 (8 day Eastern Carib.) 12/14 6 day Western NYE cruise 04/15 6 day western Carib. Diamond Cruise
RCCL Oasis of the Seas (1 sailing) 03/14 (Western Carib.)
Carnival Sunshine (2 sailings) 08/15 (8 day Southern Caribbean) 02/16 (8 day exotic eastern Caribbean)
Carnival Vista (2 sailings) 07/16 (8 day western Med cruise) 04/17 (8 day exotic eastern Caribbean)

Upcoming Cruises:

Carnival Pride 07/17 4th floor Vista suite... (7 day eastern Caribbean)
Carnival Breeze 11/18 (13 day Journey cruise Eastern Carib)
Carnival Horizon 7/18 (eastern out of NYC)
#6
Virginia
37 Posts
Joined Mar 2007
They definitely didn't get rich from me. Last summer my teenage daughter and I combined spent $16 on a 6 day cruise. We each had a non-alcoholic frozen drink on Half Moon Cay, I got a soda in the comedy club one night, and she bought some candy in one of the shops. That's it. But there were plenty of people who made up for our lack of spending!
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
#7
Arizona
464 Posts
Joined Apr 2007
We purchase one magnet of the ship for our souvenier. Then a magnet at each port.

We use on board credit for drinks. When we run out of free credit, we're done drinking. We bring on our allotted wine.

Other than that, tips are the only things on our account at the end.

Unfortunately, we purchased a wine tour in Ensenada thru Carnival. We never take the ships tours, always local ones, but I couldn't find a local one online.
If anyone knows of a good one, let me know, and I will try the Carnival tour refund guarantee out.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Carnival Vista. Feb 11, 2017. Carribean. 13th anniversary cruise.
Carnival Dream Jan.2, 2016. Southern Carribean. Jeannes birtthday cruise.[
Carnival Breeze Jan 31, 2015. Eastern carribean. 11th anniversary cruise
Carnival Imagination Feb. 5, 2014. Baja Mexico. 10th anniversary Cruise
Carnival Freedom Feb.5, 2012 Western Carribean. 8th Anniversary Cruise
Carnival Victory Feb.7, 2010 Southern Carribean 7th Anniversary Cruise
Carnival Pride July, 2007 Mexican Riviera Cruise
NCL Dawn Feb. 2006 Eastern Carribean Cruise with the kids
Carnival Valor Feb. 2005 Western Carribean Cruise with the kids
Carnival Destiny Feb. 2004 Southern Carribean Honeymoon Cruise

#8
773 Posts
Joined May 2013
Don't know. We bring our own booze and mixers, tip in cash, and do our own tours. We end up with a very little S&S charge.
#9
Along LI Sound, CT
935 Posts
Joined Jun 2011
At the end of my last cruise, I owed a little over $2.00. My mother had an upset stomach and I bought her a ginger ale. They lose money on me.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Heidi-

CCL Mardi Gras
CCL Glory
CCL Legend
NCL Dawn
CCL Splendor
CCL Valor
NCL Dawn
CCL Pride
CCL Conquest
NCL Dawn (8/11/17)
#10
Virginia
974 Posts
Joined Aug 2011
They probably lose on some and make up for that on others. My first Carnival cruise was the least spent, second one was pretty modest, the most recent one we spent a lot, and the upcoming one i put a lot into it because it's for my Mom's b-day and being that she is 73 and active i want her to get a lot out of the experience and make a lot of memories.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
RCCL x 4
Carnival Pride 9/25/11

Carnival Legend 3/17/13

Carnival LIBERTY 10/12/13

Carnival Victory 1/20/14

Carnival Liberty 10/11/14
Carnival Pride 9/13/15
Carnival Magic 9/24/16
#11
Stone Mountain GA
9,280 Posts
Joined Jul 2009
We may purchase 6 non alcoholic drinks between the 2 of us for a weeks cruise. We do buy one picture on each cruise. Smokes. We don't drink, I don't gamble if DH does, he does it on his own card. Last cruise they gave us money back from our pre paid S & S card. Including the smokes we spent about 150.00.

I have friends who's booze on the cruise cost over 700 in 4 days and they are experienced cruisers and smuggled stuff on too, so it's not just the newbies they make money on, it's the gamblers and those who want a good drink.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Past Cruises
Cunard-Queen Mary 1961 NY to Cherbourg
Cunard-Queen Elizabeth 1963 Cherbourg to NY
MWA- Heritage 8/05, 8/06
Carnival- Sensation-10/08
Carnival- Legend 01/10, 9/12, 9/16
Carnival- Fascination 12/10,11/11,10/13,11/14, 9/15
Carnival- Elation 1/14, 1/16

I will try one thing today,
that I have never done before,
and when I have finished something new,
I'll go try one thing more.
aem

"Hurray for ships!.....Let us keep them alive as a token of love,to make the last romantics happy. Let us use them to cure the depressed. Let us prescribe sea journeys..." Tiziano Terzani

America-It doesn't matter what ship our ancestors came here on, we're all in the same boat now.


[

[/url]
#12
Mainer in Florida
4,714 Posts
Joined May 2000
Carnival makes money on us and we have a great time. Our biggest S&S was $1700 on a 7-day cruise. We usually buy excursions through the cruise line, always buy our drinks and almost always get spa treatments.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
#13
29,344 Posts
Joined Dec 2007
Good question.

Always spend about 100 on internet package and on occasion we buy booze or jewelry which is from an outside company..

Do go steakhouse about every other cruise.

Have no idea
#14
San Diego County
2,599 Posts
Joined Feb 2008
Originally posted by Andoria
At the end of my last cruise, I owed a little over $2.00. My mother had an upset stomach and I bought her a ginger ale. They lose money on me.
You must have pre-paid tips or....
#16
Tennessee
412 Posts
Joined Feb 2012
It seems my trend is about $300. We pre-pay tips and tip room service in cash each time they deliver. I usually buy excursions online before the cruise, so if you add those in it would raise it up a couple of hundred. We only have one DOD at sail away and then no more alcohol for us. Most of the $300 is photos.

True story: I had a VP where I used to work who took his wife on a 4 night cruise (first cruise for both) and their bill was $1,700. They are Scotch drinkers.... When he got back I asked if they enjoyed the cruise and he said he could 'take it or leave it' and they 'didn't get out of the cabin much'. When he later told me about the bar tab I kinda figured it out - they were too snockered to leave the cabin.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Pride of America – 7 nt – Honolulu – Hawaii Inter-Island 6/10/17 ***Son's Senior Trip
Carnival Dream – 7 nt – New Orleans – Western Caribbean 7/24/16
Carnival Elation - 4 nt - New Orleans - Western Caribbean 1/14/16
RC Adventure of the Seas - 7 nt - San Juan - Southern Caribbean 8/8/15
Carnival Breeze - 8 nt - Miami - Southern Caribbean 6/21/14
RC Monarch of the Seas - 3 nt - Port Canaveral - Bahamas 3/29/13 ***Farewell Cruise
Carnival Legend - 7 nt - Tampa - Exotic Western Caribbean 10/7/12
Carnival Freedom - 6 nt - Ft. Lauderdale - Western Caribbean 9/30/12
RC Liberty of the Seas - 7 nt - Miami - Eastern Caribbean 10/3/10
NCL Norwegian Dawn - 5 nt - Miami - Western Caribbean 2/7/10
Carnival Paradise - 4 nt - Long Beach - Baja California 10/5/09
RC Sovereign of the Seas - 4 nt - Port Canaveral - Bahamas 10/1/07
Carnival Elation - 5 nt - Port Canaveral - Eastern Caribbean 1/6/07
#17
Flowery Branch, GA
879 Posts
Joined Feb 2011
We average between 800 and 1,000. This is what we budget for. We only cruise once a year so we enjoy.

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I337 using Tapatalk
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature


Magic 9/2017 Booked, Fantasy 7/2015, Glory 1/2015, Freedom 2/2014, Liberty 2/2013, Valor 4/2012, Fantasy 2/2011, Legend 3/2010
Triumph 4/2009, Celebration 5/2007
Save
Save
Save
#18
Portland Maine
4,207 Posts
Joined Jun 2010
They make money on us. We like to live life to the fullest. You can't take it with you and you only have 1 life. LIVE IT UP!!
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
REGAL PRINCESS NOV 2018
CARNIVAL VISTA JAN 2018
REGAL PRINCESS OCT 2017
REGAL PRINCESS OCT 2016
CARNIVAL SUNSHINE APR 2016
REGAL PRINCESS OCT 2015
CARNIVAL LIBERTY JAN 2015
CARNIVAL SUNSHINE MARCH 2015
CARNIVAL SPLENDOR OCT 2014
CARNIVAL FREEDOM FEB 2014
CARNIVAL LEGEND OCT 2013
CARNIVAL MIRACLE SEPT 2012
CARNIVAL GLORY MARCH 2012
CARNIVAL DREAM OCT 2010
CARNIVAL LIBERTY OCT 2009
RCL LIBERTY OF THE SEAS DEC 2008




#19
Arizona
1,880 Posts
Joined Sep 2013
Our first cruise, definitely. We purchased 3 Igor Medvedev paintings at Park West Gallery. We've purchased 3 more on Ebay, which ended up costing just as much by the time you have it framed (on a black Friday sale, with discounted Michael's giftcards!).

No regrets, but we're good on art, so will likely tip over into the less profitable customers. I did book excursions on RCL next month, because when I called in about a reduced price, they where throwing sales at me I didn't even know about! For saving me $400, I let them make an extra $40 on excursions
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Upcoming
-Carnival Imagination - Baja 2017
-Nieuw Amsterdam - Alaska Cruise Tour 2018
-Celebrity Millennium - Japan Repo 2019


Sailed
-Carnival Victory - S Caribbean 2011
-Navigator of the Seas - W Caribbean 2014
-Celebrity Millennium - Alaska 2014
-Carnival Elation - Nola & Progreso 2015
-Celebrity Summit - Bermuda Repo 2016
-Carnival Pride - Panama / Caribbean Repo 2017
#20
Boca Raton
3,790 Posts
Joined Mar 2011
I like to hit the pay restaurants. I already budgeted my Sunshine cruise on the 26th. $12 to eat at JiJi's and Cucina del Capitano and another $15 for Bonsai sushi and $35 for fajrenheit 555 with tips is around $100. So, not bad, since I'm not very fond of Carnival food...
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Nordic Prince (1983)
Enchantment of the Seas(2007)
Serenade of the Seas
Noordam
Caribbean Princess
Carnival Destiny
Norwegian Pearl
Carnival Valor (2008)
Ruby Princess (inaugural)
Carnival Splendor
Independence of the Seas
Liberty of the Seas (2009)
Carnival Liberty
Eurodam
Radiance of the Seas
Mariner of the Seas
Carnival Freedom
Carnival Triumph
Navigator of the Seas (TA)
Carnival Dream
Celebrity Solstice (2010)
Costa Fortuna
Summit
Norwegian Dawn
Carnival Glory (2011)
Brilliance of the Seas (2012): *Diamond cruise*
Mariner of the Seas (TA)
Liberty of the Seas
Carnival Breeze( Sept 2013)
Carnival Conquest *Platinum Cruise*
Serenade of the Seas (TA)
Carnival Sunshine (2014)
Independence of the Seas
Vision of the Seas
Vision of the Seas
Majesty of the Seas (Diamond Plus)
Eurodam
Regal Princess
Regal Princess