Go Back   Cruise Critic Message Board Forums > Cruise Lines "A - O" > Majestic America Line
 
Register here!
Forgot Your Password?


Notices

 
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
  #1  
Old July 13th, 2007, 01:31 PM
steamboats's Avatar
steamboats steamboats is online now
5,000+ Club
 
Join Date: Oct 2004
Location: Germany
Posts: 9,117
Default American Queen Review

Hereīs a review by Cruise Ship Historian and editor Peter Knego about a cruise on the American Queen in July

http://maritimematters.blogspot.com/...can-queen.html

steamboats
__________________
No hour spent with the river has ever been wasted... Ever!

Delta Queen 08/95 Pittsburgh - Cincinnati * Delta Queen 05/98 Cincinnati - Paducah (Nashville) * Delta Queen 07/01 St. Louis - Ottawa * Delta Queen 10/02 St. Louis - Clarksville (Nashville) * Delta Queen 07/03 St. Louis - St. Paul - Mississippi Queen 11/04 New Orleans roundtrip / Thanksgiving - Mississippi Queen 06/05 New Orleans - St. Louis / Great Steamboat Race - Columbia Queen 08/05 Portland roundtrip - Empress of the North 09/05 Juneau roundtrip - Deilmannīs Mozart 03/06 Passau roundtrip - Mississippi Queen 07/06 St. Louis - St. Paul / 30th Anniversary - Deilmannīs Dresden 05/07 Dresden - Hamburg - American Queen 08/07 Pittsburgh - Louisville - American Queen 08/08 St. Louis - Red Wing - MS Belvedere 12/11 Passau roundtrip - Queen of the Mississippi 08/13 Cincinnati - St. Louis - MS Amelia 12/13 Köln roundtrip

Grandeur otS 04/07 - Western Caribbean / New Orleans -Norwegian Gem 05/08 Barcelona / Western Med - Norwegian Jade 12/08 Barcelona / Eastern Med - Serenade otS aka MOS II 05/09 Vancouver / Alaska -Liberty otS 08/09 Miami / Eastern Caribbean - Oasis otS 11/09 Fort Lauderdale Pre Inaugurals -Celebrity Eclipse 04/10 Hamburg Pre Inaugural - Oasis otS 05/10 Fort Lauderdale / Eastern Caribbean - Majesty otS 05/10 Miami / Bahamas - Celebrity Summit 08/10 New England/Canada - Allure otS 11/10 Fort Lauderdale Pre Inaugural - Mein Schiff 1 01/11 Canary Islands / Morocco - Vision otS 04/11 Lisbon to Southampton - Norwegian Epic 06/11 Western Med - Celebrity Silhouette 07/11 Hamburg Pre Inaugural - Voyager otS 09/11 Venice - LīAustral 01/12 Antarctica - Norwegian Jade 05/12 Venice - Columbus 2 08/12 Norway - Celebrity Reflection 10/12 Eemshaven/Amsterdam - Splendour otS 05/13 Venice / Greece, Turkey - QM2 06/13 Southampton-Hamburg - Navigator otS 10/13 Eastern Med - Costa neoRiviera 04/14 Western Med check our website for reviews (all German)

Ad Sponsored By
  #2  
Old July 13th, 2007, 04:13 PM
tgo's tgo's is offline
Cool Cruiser
 
Join Date: Jan 2006
Location: Lynnwood, Washington
Posts: 160
Default

I have been enjoying this blog after seeing a link on the steamboats message board.

Very well writen - an I loved all the pictures.
I has been a great way to get ready for my cruise next week.
__________________
Julie

American Queen 7-2007
Carnival Glory 1-2007

  #3  
Old July 14th, 2007, 12:11 AM
Bowie MeMe Bowie MeMe is offline
Blue Ribbon Cruiser
 
Join Date: Jun 2006
Location: Bowie, Maryland (suburb of Washington, DC)
Posts: 4,379
Smile Thank you!

I felt like I was right there with you and I expecially liked seeing the pictures and the food descriptions. We are leaving Sunday for a week on the Oregon Coast/Crater Lake and then on the Queen of the West for the July 21, 2007 Three Rivers Cruise on MAL. Hope our cruise is as interesting as you described. Thanks for posting.

  #4  
Old July 14th, 2007, 01:36 AM
steamboats's Avatar
steamboats steamboats is online now
5,000+ Club
 
Join Date: Oct 2004
Location: Germany
Posts: 9,117
Default

Bowie MeMe,

Itīs not my review but Iīll be on the American Queen next month.

steamboats
__________________
No hour spent with the river has ever been wasted... Ever!

Delta Queen 08/95 Pittsburgh - Cincinnati * Delta Queen 05/98 Cincinnati - Paducah (Nashville) * Delta Queen 07/01 St. Louis - Ottawa * Delta Queen 10/02 St. Louis - Clarksville (Nashville) * Delta Queen 07/03 St. Louis - St. Paul - Mississippi Queen 11/04 New Orleans roundtrip / Thanksgiving - Mississippi Queen 06/05 New Orleans - St. Louis / Great Steamboat Race - Columbia Queen 08/05 Portland roundtrip - Empress of the North 09/05 Juneau roundtrip - Deilmannīs Mozart 03/06 Passau roundtrip - Mississippi Queen 07/06 St. Louis - St. Paul / 30th Anniversary - Deilmannīs Dresden 05/07 Dresden - Hamburg - American Queen 08/07 Pittsburgh - Louisville - American Queen 08/08 St. Louis - Red Wing - MS Belvedere 12/11 Passau roundtrip - Queen of the Mississippi 08/13 Cincinnati - St. Louis - MS Amelia 12/13 Köln roundtrip

Grandeur otS 04/07 - Western Caribbean / New Orleans -Norwegian Gem 05/08 Barcelona / Western Med - Norwegian Jade 12/08 Barcelona / Eastern Med - Serenade otS aka MOS II 05/09 Vancouver / Alaska -Liberty otS 08/09 Miami / Eastern Caribbean - Oasis otS 11/09 Fort Lauderdale Pre Inaugurals -Celebrity Eclipse 04/10 Hamburg Pre Inaugural - Oasis otS 05/10 Fort Lauderdale / Eastern Caribbean - Majesty otS 05/10 Miami / Bahamas - Celebrity Summit 08/10 New England/Canada - Allure otS 11/10 Fort Lauderdale Pre Inaugural - Mein Schiff 1 01/11 Canary Islands / Morocco - Vision otS 04/11 Lisbon to Southampton - Norwegian Epic 06/11 Western Med - Celebrity Silhouette 07/11 Hamburg Pre Inaugural - Voyager otS 09/11 Venice - LīAustral 01/12 Antarctica - Norwegian Jade 05/12 Venice - Columbus 2 08/12 Norway - Celebrity Reflection 10/12 Eemshaven/Amsterdam - Splendour otS 05/13 Venice / Greece, Turkey - QM2 06/13 Southampton-Hamburg - Navigator otS 10/13 Eastern Med - Costa neoRiviera 04/14 Western Med check our website for reviews (all German)

  #5  
Old July 19th, 2007, 09:57 AM
steamboats's Avatar
steamboats steamboats is online now
5,000+ Club
 
Join Date: Oct 2004
Location: Germany
Posts: 9,117
Default

Hereīs another review from the same cruise

http://www.steamboats.org/forum/showthread.php?t=1599

steamboats
__________________
No hour spent with the river has ever been wasted... Ever!

Delta Queen 08/95 Pittsburgh - Cincinnati * Delta Queen 05/98 Cincinnati - Paducah (Nashville) * Delta Queen 07/01 St. Louis - Ottawa * Delta Queen 10/02 St. Louis - Clarksville (Nashville) * Delta Queen 07/03 St. Louis - St. Paul - Mississippi Queen 11/04 New Orleans roundtrip / Thanksgiving - Mississippi Queen 06/05 New Orleans - St. Louis / Great Steamboat Race - Columbia Queen 08/05 Portland roundtrip - Empress of the North 09/05 Juneau roundtrip - Deilmannīs Mozart 03/06 Passau roundtrip - Mississippi Queen 07/06 St. Louis - St. Paul / 30th Anniversary - Deilmannīs Dresden 05/07 Dresden - Hamburg - American Queen 08/07 Pittsburgh - Louisville - American Queen 08/08 St. Louis - Red Wing - MS Belvedere 12/11 Passau roundtrip - Queen of the Mississippi 08/13 Cincinnati - St. Louis - MS Amelia 12/13 Köln roundtrip

Grandeur otS 04/07 - Western Caribbean / New Orleans -Norwegian Gem 05/08 Barcelona / Western Med - Norwegian Jade 12/08 Barcelona / Eastern Med - Serenade otS aka MOS II 05/09 Vancouver / Alaska -Liberty otS 08/09 Miami / Eastern Caribbean - Oasis otS 11/09 Fort Lauderdale Pre Inaugurals -Celebrity Eclipse 04/10 Hamburg Pre Inaugural - Oasis otS 05/10 Fort Lauderdale / Eastern Caribbean - Majesty otS 05/10 Miami / Bahamas - Celebrity Summit 08/10 New England/Canada - Allure otS 11/10 Fort Lauderdale Pre Inaugural - Mein Schiff 1 01/11 Canary Islands / Morocco - Vision otS 04/11 Lisbon to Southampton - Norwegian Epic 06/11 Western Med - Celebrity Silhouette 07/11 Hamburg Pre Inaugural - Voyager otS 09/11 Venice - LīAustral 01/12 Antarctica - Norwegian Jade 05/12 Venice - Columbus 2 08/12 Norway - Celebrity Reflection 10/12 Eemshaven/Amsterdam - Splendour otS 05/13 Venice / Greece, Turkey - QM2 06/13 Southampton-Hamburg - Navigator otS 10/13 Eastern Med - Costa neoRiviera 04/14 Western Med check our website for reviews (all German)

  #6  
Old October 2nd, 2007, 04:53 PM
vincent vincent is offline
Cool Cruiser
 
Join Date: Dec 2002
Posts: 74
Default Amercian Queen

We took this cruise in May, and absolutley loved it. The staff were wonderful, entertainment fun (no big production shows of course), food was excellent, and the ports were great - some small town America, some full of tourist opportunities
It's quite a different experience from the big cruise ships of course, but that's part of what makes it so wonderful. Much more intimate and evocative of our American past.
We highly recommend the american Queen on the Mississippi!!!
It's such a shame the Delta Queen is going out of service!!!

  #7  
Old February 28th, 2008, 04:32 AM
john_meri john_meri is offline
Cool Cruiser
 
Join Date: Feb 2008
Posts: 2
Default American Queen Steamboat

The American Queen is the largest paddle wheel steamship ever built. At 418 feet in length and 90 feet in width, she is a wonderful size for cruising. She was purpose built as a themed floating resort and she accomplishes the task quite well. You can get more and more information about American Queen
__________________
Interactive hotels of hank freid and their luxury experiences.

Last edited by john_meri; February 28th, 2008 at 04:45 AM.

  #8  
Old February 28th, 2008, 01:29 PM
Calliope's Avatar
Calliope Calliope is offline
Cool Cruiser
 
Join Date: Sep 2001
Location: Covington, Kentucky, U.S.A.
Posts: 1,430
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by john_meri View Post
The American Queen is the largest paddle wheel steamship ever built. At 418 feet in length and 90 feet in width, she is a wonderful size for cruising. She was purpose built as a themed floating resort and she accomplishes the task quite well. You can get more and more information about American Queen

I'm sorry, but your statement is plain old wrong. The AMERICAN QUEEN's size is paled by Isambard Kingdom Brunel's 22,500 ton GREAT EASTERN. She was built and launched in Great Britain in 1859 to run in the England to America transatlantic trade. Like the AMERICAN QUEEN the GREAT EASTERN also was equipt with a propellor which delivered greater horsepower than the paddlewheels.

Yes, the AMERICAN QUEEN was designed as you said as a themed floating resort. Al Luthmers, then The Delta Queen Steamboat Company's Senior Vice President of Development stated in the 1993 annual stockholders' report for The Delta Queen Steamboat Co. stated so, "Figuratively speaking the AMERICAN QUEEN is a thematic resort hotel driven by a paddlewheel." Unfortunately, that management of The Delta Queen Steamboat Co. is no more; their vision of surrounding the passenger in a Victorian experience is gone. American steamboats of the Victorian era were not painted blue, in fact American steamboat owners considered it very bad luck to paint their boats blue. Much of the AMERICAN QUEEN is now painted blue. Cheap TV screens have now been placed in the staterooms, further detracting from the one time Victorian feel.

Majestic American Line provides a cheapened product with a much higher per diem price attached. No longer are crawfish boils offered, the six piece floor band has been replaced by a four piece band to front the shows. Certain instruments are prerecorded and mixed into the evening shows now, so there is nor live brass for Dixieland. That's certainly not what I grew to appreciate and expect on a steamboat. Four singers/entertainers have been cut down to two, so no longer is there the staff to offer the numerous daytime diversions that were once there. The popular pastime of kiteflying over the rolling red wheel is a thing of the past along with the Mike Fink Seafood Party with its "Floozie Parade." Not the entertainment that I expect when I pay a premium fare.

Most days now are spent tied up in a town. The days of being out on the river steamboatin' are over. Of course this is my opinion, but just spending a whole day watching the ever changing shoreline go by was magical to me. This is not what is being offered now. The current management might be offering a product that some might enjoy, but it's not on the biggest steamboat ever built. It's also not on the Victorian fantasy that was originally operated, and that is truly too bad.
__________________
"When we presently got under way and went poking down the broad Ohio, I became a new being and the subject of my own admiration. I was a traveler!"
Mark Twain

  #9  
Old February 28th, 2008, 08:56 PM
shipguyCA shipguyCA is offline
Cool Cruiser
 
Join Date: Mar 2007
Posts: 4
Default American Queen, at present

I understand that loyal passengers can feel differently about these things but as a many times past passenger with Delta Queen, I have a slightly different view of the American Queen in her present condition than Calliope does.

While a steamboat with blue highlights (the boat is not blue!) may not be historically accurate, I doubt 98% of the passengers onboard care or notice. The fact is that the boat still turns heads wherever she goes, which I take as a good sign. Few people stop to stare and wave at an Airbus or Amtrak train.

Similarly, the complaint about 'cheap TV screens' is not fair since many passengers LIKE the option of catching the news, or watching a movie in their room. A complaint before was the boat was 'boring' and for some people, this does provide another option for the evening. It is not mandatory to watch it.

I was on the AQ in August and far from a cheapened product, I found it a considerably improved product from a few years earlier with generally superb meals served by a caring and attentive crew. I found both the quality and breadth of the menu far superior to a year or two earlier and most of my fellow passengers did. I do agree on the current entertainment choices which are reduced, in my view, but the Engine Room Bar was packed nightly by many folks who found it a fun spot each evening.

I have the current brochure in front of me and many days are spend cruising on the river, not all tied up in a town. Here too, I would suggest the companmy is trying to find a balance between a more sedentary holiday that some people prefer and a bit more active one. I see no harm in this.

I do not work for Majestic but wanted to make clear, based on my trip last July, where virtually everyone onboard, including first-time travelers were firm in saying this was one of their best vacations ever, that there is more than one way of looking at this.

  #10  
Old February 29th, 2008, 03:01 AM
steamboats's Avatar
steamboats steamboats is online now
5,000+ Club
 
Join Date: Oct 2004
Location: Germany
Posts: 9,117
Default

Calliope and shipguyCA,

Calliope, john_meri quoted out of the 2005 review he also linked to. And you know we agree with you that the AQ is not a "true" steamboat with her Z-drives.

I also agree with you regarding the blue paint two decks high in the dining room area. Itīs simply ugly and you canīt even read the boats name out of the distance. At least the paddlewheel is opposing to the marron which is more or less gone. I think the trims are looking nice in that blue/marron but of course both are no typical steamboat colors.

shipguyCA, yes the food did improve very much compared to the previous years. Service in the dining room was good and they were still working on training new crew. Itīll take some time to get all the crew up to the new standards in the dining room. Anyway Iīm missing the Southern touch of the waiters. At least they changed the menue throughout the season 2007 and brought back a lot of the old stuff (including the daily bread pudding).

I never tried out the TV in our cabin and I donīt need it. I think our DD (7y then) turned it on once just for a try. She was so busy strolling around that she never needed a DVD movie for entertainment. I appreciated the WiFi connection (o.k., sometimes you couldnīt call it "connection" at all). It helped to keep up with problems at home which occured right during our cruise. BTW I did not understand why they were still showing movies in the movie theater. I think itīll be easier to use the cabin TV system for that. And I missed the historic steamboat videos.

Yes, the entertainment was cut down. Not only the evening entertainment but also the onboard entertainment throughout the day. The solo shows and the Lewis Hankins as Mark Twain were great. The two singers gave a perfect show but I didnīt like the shows except for one. You were able to see that they are fleet wide productions where everyone can be replaced easily. And in some shows I wasnīt able to see a "red line" guiding me through the show. It was more like adding one song to another. The four singers and their shows were much better.

By the beginning of the 2007 season there have been lots of complaints about the onboard entertainment and they changed some things back. Anyway there are no Mike Fink parties, no Floozies, no arts&crafts stuff (o.k. a napkin folding, but there used to be papers, scissors, glue and more out for everyone to make a hat or door decoration). There are still talks of the onboard historian (former riverlorian) but most of them where at lunch time. I thought those breakfast time talks (have been on the MQ) were great. There were also guest speakers. But: unfortunately those talks werenīt attended very much. Why: The talks were scheduled during the port time, mainly by the end of the port time. Therefore lots of passengers werenīt aboard yet. Sure the speaker has to leave the boat again.

They put back the repeat passenger party. And Iīm quite sure that the pins and giveaways will be back in 2008 too.

Regarding the port times: shipguyCA, Calliope is correct. Have a look on the schedule. There arenīt many cruises left including at least one steamboating day. And most of the port stops on our Ohio river cruise last year were 8-17 / all day stops. So there isnīt much steamboating left during daylight. And spending a whole day in Wheeling might be nice but a whole day instead of a half day in Marietta would be much nicer. I donīt have my schedule at hand (and I do have a day by day schedule including the port times) but for the AQ I think itīs only the St. Louis - St. Paul cruise which has a whole steamboating day (not the opposite cruise, that one has a port stop every day).

steamboats
__________________
No hour spent with the river has ever been wasted... Ever!

Delta Queen 08/95 Pittsburgh - Cincinnati * Delta Queen 05/98 Cincinnati - Paducah (Nashville) * Delta Queen 07/01 St. Louis - Ottawa * Delta Queen 10/02 St. Louis - Clarksville (Nashville) * Delta Queen 07/03 St. Louis - St. Paul - Mississippi Queen 11/04 New Orleans roundtrip / Thanksgiving - Mississippi Queen 06/05 New Orleans - St. Louis / Great Steamboat Race - Columbia Queen 08/05 Portland roundtrip - Empress of the North 09/05 Juneau roundtrip - Deilmannīs Mozart 03/06 Passau roundtrip - Mississippi Queen 07/06 St. Louis - St. Paul / 30th Anniversary - Deilmannīs Dresden 05/07 Dresden - Hamburg - American Queen 08/07 Pittsburgh - Louisville - American Queen 08/08 St. Louis - Red Wing - MS Belvedere 12/11 Passau roundtrip - Queen of the Mississippi 08/13 Cincinnati - St. Louis - MS Amelia 12/13 Köln roundtrip

Grandeur otS 04/07 - Western Caribbean / New Orleans -Norwegian Gem 05/08 Barcelona / Western Med - Norwegian Jade 12/08 Barcelona / Eastern Med - Serenade otS aka MOS II 05/09 Vancouver / Alaska -Liberty otS 08/09 Miami / Eastern Caribbean - Oasis otS 11/09 Fort Lauderdale Pre Inaugurals -Celebrity Eclipse 04/10 Hamburg Pre Inaugural - Oasis otS 05/10 Fort Lauderdale / Eastern Caribbean - Majesty otS 05/10 Miami / Bahamas - Celebrity Summit 08/10 New England/Canada - Allure otS 11/10 Fort Lauderdale Pre Inaugural - Mein Schiff 1 01/11 Canary Islands / Morocco - Vision otS 04/11 Lisbon to Southampton - Norwegian Epic 06/11 Western Med - Celebrity Silhouette 07/11 Hamburg Pre Inaugural - Voyager otS 09/11 Venice - LīAustral 01/12 Antarctica - Norwegian Jade 05/12 Venice - Columbus 2 08/12 Norway - Celebrity Reflection 10/12 Eemshaven/Amsterdam - Splendour otS 05/13 Venice / Greece, Turkey - QM2 06/13 Southampton-Hamburg - Navigator otS 10/13 Eastern Med - Costa neoRiviera 04/14 Western Med check our website for reviews (all German)

 

Bookmarks


Ad Sponsored By
Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Forum Jump


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 02:32 AM.


Đ 1995 - 2014, The Independent Traveler, Inc. All rights reserved.
"A Community of People Who Love To Cruise"
All of the information contained within Cruise Critic is protected by copyright. You may, however, download a single copy only for your personal use.
Check Cruise Prices
Destination:
Cruise Line:
Month:
Compare deals from top travel sites
Loading vendors ... please wait.
No vendors are available. Try selecting options