We just got off of Edge and we found the quality of everything to be excellent and on par with our pre-pandemic 2020 cruise. When we compared our Edge cruise with our 2023 Millenium cruise, we found the buffet offerings and overall food quality to be superior on Edge hands down. Entertainment was pretty equal overall, and ship service, cleanliness and maintenance were excellent on both ships.
Perhaps we are easier to please than other cruisers, but we were very satisfied with everything on both cruises.