I know this is an old thread...but the same way I just came across it, I wanted to provide an alternate perspective and different point of view.
We loved Eden, from its carpet to its drinks, and meandering design with many places to engage with others or quiet time for yourself. We loved the magic carpet, for a drink, a relaxing place to sit, or for dinner when offered.
Our friends stayed in an infinite veranda and loved it and want to book it again.
I came across this thread and thought it would be helpful to note that, while not for everyone, some of us think the ideas deserve a promotion rather than firing. This is not a slide against prior posters, but a different point of view. Yes, with any new ship, there are improvements to be made and Celebrity, as with the Millennium and Solstice class ships, will make adjustment with each ship release. There were 10 of us in varied cabins and after 14 nights we all walked off loving it and looking forward to booking again in the future. Personally, I look forward to trying the Apex and future cruises on other older and newer Celebrity ships.