Our group just completed our cruise on the Seaside and in MY opinion, it was nothing short of fantastic.
There were 17 people in our group, ranging from 14 to 75 years of age.
The Pro's are the ship, as new as it was, was VERY clean. Plenty of chrome, stainless and mirrors - materials not usually used in other cruise lines I've travelled.
Public areas are great with plenty of seating, bars are great and the staff are mostly attentive. The Viche chocolate bar was a favorite before bed. The casino bar was always good if all other bars were packed.
The main dining room never disappointed. There was something for everyone - they had the staple entres such as a NY steak, chicken, pork and fish. There was, of course, nightly options such as seafood dishes, duck, pastas and of course, the prime rib which came to me as a surprise. I never order prime rib mainly because it's never cooked the way I'd like it. Everyone in our party commented on how PERFECT this was cooked. Cooking for 4000 people and to get it RIGHT is a feat all by itself. All in all, MDR food was fantastic.
The buffet is where we met for breakfast and it too was your typical breakfast that didn't disappoint.
But as far as the buffet went, in that venue was PIZZA. I have a pizza oven in my backyard and this was the same! Amazing pizza that was had each night before bed, and at lunch time. Simply amazing. Thin crust, just the right amount of sauce. A+
The Cons - The shows weren't long enough. That's it. ONE complaint. The quality of the shows were A+, just not long enough. The itinerary was horrible but that's my fault for choose it.
Otherwise, 7 days out, it was VERY enjoyable. We chose this itinerary for the ship this time and NOT for the ports. So I can't complain. We didn't get to Puerto Rico until 5pm and left at midnight, however with that arrival time, it doesn't lend to doing much at all because San Juan closes down more or less. We had a chance to have dinner at Raices which we always visit while there. St. Thomas was as it always is....shopping and beach. Nassau, same - beach.
The private island (Ocean Cay Marine Reserve) was mostly complete and was pretty good if all you want is beach. Lots of bars and the buffet they set up didn't disappoint either. Service was fantastic all around the island.
Again, the itinerary wasn't the greatest....
Overall, this was my first MSC cruise and certainly won't be my last. This was a brief review and would be happy to answer questions.