"Finger on the pulse" was meant as Carnival has a better idea of what's going on in this South Sea arena, because they are interacting with the local governments. Another thread I am following, someone called the PNG Embassy in Washington, D.C. Granted it was a couple of weeks ago, but the Embassy response "we are open to tourists, but still closed to cruise ships". New Caledonia is pretty much the same, I received a response from the "official" tourism site that stated we are still officially closed to cruise ships, regardless of what is being said in the media. We anticipate opening soon and will update our website when the government announces the opening.
It is clear Carnival has made the decision to go forward with both PNG and New Caledonia. HAL recently updated its Westerdam itinerary cancelling Vanuatu, and rearranging its New Caledonia and PNG port calls, That said, the cruise lines are not always candid with its customers on what's going on. As an example, about a month ago a problem with a HAL itinerary for Auckland, NZ, came up. HAL said the port call date was Nov 19 and the Port Authority said the date was Nov 20. Several booked passengers challenged HAL, including myself. HAL stood by their date, even when provided a copy of an email from the Port Authority. Lo and behold, couple days ago, change of itinerary notice was sent out. Port Authority was correct all along.
My hope is that both PNG and New Caledonia are open when the Westerdam reaches those ports. My purpose in posting my concern was to get additional input. I appreciate you take on the situation.