We have done Garden Villa (Jade), 2 bdrm (Epic, Jewel, Gem), and Aft Haven on Breakaway multiple times. While we like the space in Aft with our two children, there is a bit of disconnect once you walk to Haven in my opinion. Our butler's have been very good but the concierge staff never really got to know us unless we made a point to utilize them. We gave a very generous tip to asst. concierge on Breakaway last Feb cruise because she went out of her way to talk to us and our kids. We are booked in DOS on Escape this Feb so I will be able to see if there is a definite difference. Obviously we were treated great when we were in GV but there were also less Haven/suites to deal with. It depends on size of room you need vs. pampering you want.