I was on the same cruise and totally agree with your assessment. Putra was also our butler....exceptional. This is the first cruise ship I have been able to eat fish. The fish was perfectly prepared and appeared to be fresh, not frozen. The lamb and steaks were excellent. Ocean Cay was pleasant. The best private island of the cruise lines that I have been on. The only negative was the unruly children in the YC. Great idea to have YC 18+.