Mystery dinner question

Welcome to Cruise Critic! If you'd like to participate on our forums by joining in the conversation, please Register Now! Be sure to visit our FAMOUS Roll Call forums, where you can meet other cruisers sailing with you and share a tour or shore excursion and SAVE MONEY!

Sugar Land, TX
5,856 Posts
Joined Mar 2004
We did the mystery dinner at Portofino on Adventure in February. It was originally scheduled for the first formal night (second evening of the cruise) but was changed to the third evening. I'm not sure if Adventure usually holds it on the second or third evening. The price was $49.50 per person.

It's something different and worth doing once. The acting was way over-the-top and very silly. It's definitely not a Broadway production but it was fun. The food was not up to Portofino's usual standards because they do serve everyone at once. My shrimp was dried out like it had been sitting under a heat lamp for a while before being served.

We started the evening in the Viking Lounge with sparkling wine and some toast hors d'oueves. The actors gave a set-up for the mystery. We were then divided into 6 groups of around 16 people each and escorted to Portofino.

Once in Portofino, we were given a choice of red or white wine. If you don't drink wine, they will bring sodas or tea. The wine was unlimited. The appetizer was a choice of either ceasar salad or soup of the day. Our soup choice was creamy mushroom but that can vary. They also brought out a variety of breads. After the appetizer, the actors provided some more background on the mystery. Our entree choices were beef tenderloin or tiger shrimp. After the entree, each table was allowed to pick one actor to ask a question to help solve the mystery. Everyone wrote down their choice for the murderer. Then everyone got tiramisu for dessert, which was really good. After dessert, the mystery was revealed. The people who selected the correct murderer were put in a drawing to win a gift basket.

I enjoyed the mystery dinner once, but don't think that I would want to do it again for a while. The menu was very limited and the quality not up to Portofino's usual standards. We went back to Portofino later in the cruise to experience the full menu and had a wonderful meal.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Lindblad Delfin II - Oct. 28, '17 - 10 nt. Amazon River
RC Brilliance - Jan. 20, '18 - 5 nt. W. Caribbean
Viking Skadi - Sep. 8, '18 - 14 nt. Danube & Rhine Rivers
RC Liberty - Jun. 4, '17 - 7 nt. W. Caribbean
RC Enchantment - Oct. 31, '16 - 4 nt. Bahamas & Key West
=X= Silhouette - Jun. '16 - 12 nt. Baltics (Stockholm, Helsinki, St. Petersburg, Tallinn, Berlin, Copenhagen, Amsterdam)
RC Navigator - Jun. '15 - 7 nt. W. Caribbean (Galveston, Cozumel, Belize, Roatan)
PG Paul Gauguin - Apr. '15 - 11 nt. Cook, & Society Islands (Tahiti, Huahine, Aitutaki, Rarotonga, Bora Bora, Taha'a, Moorea)
Silversea Silver Explorer - Feb '14 - 10 nt. Antarctica (Ushuaia to the Antarctic Peninsula)
=X= Xpedition - Apr, '13 - 13 nt. Galapagos "B"/Machu Picchu (Quito, Baltra, Santiago, Rabida, Bartolome, N. Seymour, Santa Cruz, San Cristobal, Cusco, Sacred Valley, Lima)
=X= Silhouette - Sep '12 - 12 nt. Holy Land (Rome, Santorini, Nazareth, Jerusalem, Alexandria/Cairo, Naples)
RC Adventure - Feb '12 - 7 nt. S. Caribbean (San Juan, St. Croix, St. Maarten, Antigua, St. Lucia, Barbados)
RC Liberty - Dec '11 - 4 nt. Bahamas (Fort Lauderdale, Coco Cay, Nassau)
HAL Zuiderdam - Apr '11 - 10 nt. Partial Panama Canal (Fort Lauderdale, Half Moon Cay, Aruba, Curacao, Panama Canal, Costa Rica)
RC Serenade - Jan '10 - 7 nt. S. Caribbean (San Juan, Tortola, St. Maarten, Antigua, St. Lucia, Grenada)
HAL Maasdam - Apr '09 - 14 nt. Caribbean
RC Legend - May '08 - 13 nt. Italy/Croatia
RC Sovereign - Jan '08 - 3 nt. Bahamas
=X= Xpedition - Sept '07 - 10 nt. Galapagos
RC Rhapsody - Jan '07 - 7 nt. W. Caribbean
RC Radiance - Sept '06 - 7 nt. NB Alaska
RC Brilliance - Oct '05 - 12 nt. Med Greek Isles
RC Majesty - Jan '05 - 3 nt. Bahamas
RC Rhapsody - Oct '04 - 7 nt. W. Caribbean
RC Monarch - Jun '00 - 7 nt. S. Caribbean
Sugar Land, TX
5,856 Posts
Joined Mar 2004
Enchantment does not appear to have a mystery dinner but I'm not positive. According to the Royal Caribbean website, it is only on Freedom, Liberty, and Radiance class ships. I was on Adventure, which is a Voyager class ship and not listed as having a mystery dinner, but we had one. Adventure has a Portofino restaurant onboard, but Enchantment does not have a Portofino.

Mystery Dinner Theater
Our professional cast hosts an evening of theater packed with mystery, intrigue and lots of laughs. Solve the crime in Portofino, our gourmet Italian specialty restaurant, over an exquisite multi-course dinner paired with fine wine. An exclusive event on Freedom-, Liberty- and Radiance-class ships; sailings vary. Limited space, reserve early.
When you check your reservation online, there should be an option to book specialty restaurants. If the mystery dinner is offered, it will show up there. I booked online before our cruise because I heard that it often sold out.
East Hanover, New Jersey
349 Posts
Joined Jun 2008
Originally posted by Ocean Dancer
You answered my question that it is on the Explorer, but you said that the first night is formal night which it is held. We have done about 29 cruises and formal night has never been on the first night on any line. Some people do not even have their luggage yet. Are you sure that Explorer has formal night the day you embark???????????? We are sailing on her this December.
Usually the 1st formal night on the Explorer is the 2nd night. We are going to the Mystery Dinner on our cruise on May 24th. It is on the 2nd formal night which is night 8 of our 9 day cruise.

Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Previous Cruises
Disney Wonder - August 2002
Disney Wonder - August 2003
Explorer of the Seas - May 25, 2007
Explorer of the Seas - April 11, 2008
Explorer of the Seas - May 28, 2009

Celebrity Summit - July 31, 2011
Explorer of the Seas - May 24, 2012
Explorer of the Seas - May 22, 2014
Liberty of the Seas - May 21, 2015

Anthem of the Seas - May 25, 2017
Anthem of the Seas - August 26, 2017

Central Illinois
115,427 Posts
Joined Apr 2008
Originally posted by kyriecat
Enchantment does not appear to have a mystery dinner but I'm not positive. According to the Royal Caribbean website, it is only on Freedom, Liberty, and Radiance class ships. I was on Adventure, which is a Voyager class ship and not listed as having a mystery dinner, but we had one. Adventure has a Portofino restaurant onboard, but Enchantment does not have a Portofino...
You are correct, the Mystery Dinner Theater is currently only available on ships with Portofino.

Which brings up the question that since all Portofino restaurants are being replaced with Giovanni's Table, I wonder what will happen with the Mystery Dinner Theater?
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature

Past Cruises

Celebrity: Mercury
RCCL: Adventure, Allure, Brilliance, Enchantment, Explorer, Freedom, Independence, Legend, Liberty, Majesty, Mariner, Monarch, Navigator, Oasis, Radiance, Rhapsody, Serenade, Sovereign, Vision, Voyager
Omaha, NE
724 Posts
Joined Mar 2000
I would like to do the mystery dinner theater. But I am not willing to give up a formal night in the MDR. We cruise so infrequently that formal night is a big treat.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Jen and Randy
Omaha, NE
(Sailing with F/U Crew on AOS)

The best vacation on earth!!!

Adventure of the Seas-RCI 1/28/2017

Independence of the Seas-RCI 1/18/14
Adventure of the Seas-RCI 2/10/13
Sun Princess 12/8/05
Nordic Empress-RCI 12/14/02
Monarch of the Seas-RCI 5/02
Grandeur of the Sea-RCI 2/01
Nordic Empress-RCI 3/98

5,923 Posts
Joined May 2010
Thanks Fred for clearing that up

Jen and Randy, agree, love formal night and also don't want a conflict with the show

Everyone, have a great cruise!!!!!!!!!!!!! 8 months of planning for us!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature

The Sunny Southwest
101 Posts
Joined May 2008
For FOS sailing July 15, 2012, the Mystery Dinner is on the first night, Sunday. The two formal nights are on the second and sixth nights, so we won't be missing out on formal nights if we do the Mystery Dinner. I think our older teens will enjoy it since they are in Drama at school.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Some white rabbits can be brown, can't they?