Disney vs Carnival

Welcome to Cruise Critic! If you'd like to participate on our forums by joining in the conversation, please Register Now! Be sure to visit our FAMOUS Roll Call forums, where you can meet other cruisers sailing with you and share a tour or shore excursion and SAVE MONEY!

Family Cruises
Cruising with kids? Best Family Cruise Advice
Cruise Critic's Family Cruising Resources
Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts
BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
All times are GMT -4.
The time now is 07:27 AM.
#1
Copperas Cove, TX
25 Posts
Joined Oct 2012
My wife and I cruised on Carnival several years ago, before we had any children. We enjoyed it immensely. We now have 2 daughters - age 11 and 8. We are considering a cruise next summer for family vacation so the girls will be 12 and 9 at that time. Just wondering if the additional cost of Disney is really worth it or if the girls would have as much fun on Carnival. We would take Eastern Caribbean and would go out of Galveston if on Carnival. Unfortunately, Disney doesn't sail out of Galveston during the summer. Any thoughts?
#2
90,176 Posts
Joined Jul 2000
Yes, I would book the Disney Cruise.

They are still at a perfect age for the cruise and they would remember this cruise for the rest of their lives.

As each year passes by in a blink of an eye they will be young adults and then be on their own.

Yes, I am sure they would have a nice time on any cruise but if the Disney cruise would work for your budget it would be very special.

Keith
#3
Fredericksburg, va. USA
84,334 Posts
Joined May 2001
Actually, most kids prefer the Carnival kid's club over Disney's.....
I can't imagine them not having fun on ANY cruise...they are at the perfect ages for either cruiseline.
#4
Michigan
6,898 Posts
Joined Apr 2005
Originally posted by cruisingTXfamily
My wife and I cruised on Carnival several years ago, before we had any children. We enjoyed it immensely. We now have 2 daughters - age 11 and 8. We are considering a cruise next summer for family vacation so the girls will be 12 and 9 at that time. Just wondering if the additional cost of Disney is really worth it or if the girls would have as much fun on Carnival. We would take Eastern Caribbean and would go out of Galveston if on Carnival. Unfortunately, Disney doesn't sail out of Galveston during the summer. Any thoughts?
If your kids are into Disney, then yes it really is worth the extra cost. We went on Disney when our kids were 4 and 7 and then again when they were 7 and 10. IMHO those were the perfect ages to take them and the Disney "experience" was worth the cost to us at that time. Since then we have cruised Carnival and NCL. I probably won't go back to Disney until I have Grandchildren to spoil. At 15 and 18, the Disney experience is not worth the extra cost to us like it was when they were younger.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Warm Breezes



Cruise History Summary: 17 Cruises, 98 Nights, 14 Ships, 4 Cruise Lines, 20 Ports of Call, 7 Embarkation Ports
Carnival Fantasy Oct. 2017 - 5 Night Western, Norwegian Escape Sept. 2017 - 7 Night Eastern...oops Irma says Western, Carnival Sunshine Oct. 2016 - 5 Night Canada, Carnival Dream May 2016 - 7 Night Western, Carnival Splendor April 2015 - 7 Night Eastern, Ruby Princess March 2014 - 5 Night Western, Norwegian Jewel Oct. 2013 - 7 Night Western, Carnival Freedom Aug. 2013 - 6 Night Western, Norwegian Epic Dec 2011 - 7 Night Eastern, Carnival Glory July 2011 - 5 Night Canada, Carnival Destiny Nov. 2010 - 4 Night Western, Carnival Freedom July 2009 - 8 Night Eastern, Norwegian Jewel Nov. 2007 - 5 Night Western, Carnival Elation Dec. 2006 - 5 Night Eastern, Carnival Inspiration Nov. 2005 - 5 Night Western, Disney Magic June 2004 -7 Night Eastern, Disney Wonder Nov. 2001 - 3 Night Bahamas
#5
172 Posts
Joined Dec 2007
I firmly believe that kids have fun on 95% of cruises because they do not worry about the things that we adults do. They enjoy having pools, beaches, fun activities, time with mom and dad and having friends in the clubs onboard. We have been on the whole gamut of cruise lines, my husband and I like some much better than others but my son has always had a great time. What I'm trying to say is that the extra few thousand dollars for a Disney cruise are not justified in my opinion. You can spend that on great activities on shore. Also, at this age I'm not sure that having dressed-up characters may be a bit childish for them, especially the older one
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Cruising the world with my family.
Visit my blog at http://travellinmommy.blogspot.com

New Year's 2018 - Celebrity Reflection Caribbean
January 2017 - Celebrity Reflection Caribbean
April 2016 - Carnival Breeze
April 2015 - Celebrity Eclipse Southern Caribbean
January 2015 - Celebrity Equinox Caribbean
March 2014 - Celebrity Silhouette Caribbean
December 2013 - Celebrity Equinox New Year's Cruise
July 2013 - Celebrity Eclipse Norwegian Fjords
April 2013 - Celebrity Reflection
December 2012 - Celebrity Eclipse New Year's Cruise
May 2012 - Azamara Journey
March 2012 - Oceania Marina
2/11/2012 - Celebrity Silhouette
12/31/2011 - RCI Enchantment of the Seas
7/27/2011 - Regent Seven Seas Mariner
11/20/2010 - Crown Princess
7/13/2010 - Celebrity Equinox
3/5/2010 - NCL Epic
2/20/2009 - Crown Princess
2/12/2008 - Crown Princess
2/20/2007 - Caribbean Princess
#6
18,838 Posts
Joined Feb 2006
Pick the cruise that is more convenient to your area. If we lived near a cruise port - then those would be the ones we would be cruising on.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Michele
NCL Breakaway 11/26/17
RCI Enchantment of the Seas 05/20/16
RCI Anthem of the Seas 11/8/2015
RCI Allure of the Seas 5/4/14
Norwegian Getaway PreInaugural 1/27/14
NCL Breakaway PreInaugural 5/8/13
NCL EPIC 11/24/12 - Ewes Baby!
RCI Enchantment 8/3/12 - Addicted to BERMUDA!
NCL Gem 10/2/11 - Back to Bermuda!
RCI Enchantment of the Seas 5/28/11 - Bermuda
RCI Grandeur of the Seas 9/11/10
Carnival Triumph 6/7/09
RCI Independence of the Seas 2/1/09
Disney Wonder 09/11/08
Carnival Sensation 08/07
RCI Freedom of the Seas 5/07
Carnival Elation 11/06
Disney Magic 2/05
NCL Norway 6/02
RCI Sovereign of the Seas 9/98
RCI Sovereign of the Seas 9/97
Kids club schedules and children's menus
http://photobucket.com/cruisekidpages
#7
USA
8,951 Posts
Joined Feb 2008
Disney Mouse experience is always pricey, the do a few very special things. IMHO it is unique just like Disney Land/world etc, but that isn't to say you can't have a memorable vacation on any other mainstream line.

If you have the budget, then it becomes very personal about how much you budget and what you give up to make those kind of incremental experiences happen; skip a 401K payment, 529 payment, skip eating out a few years or whatever
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Princess: 1999, 2008, 2010, 2014, 2015 Disney: 2000 Carnival:2005
#8
NYC
159 Posts
Joined Jan 2009
My daughter and I have been on 4 Disney cruises since she was 7 (now 10) with our 5th scheduled for next August. She absolutely loves it! It's all a matter of opinion. I obviously think Disney is worth it but I always keep my options open. We're sailing Carnival in March. It will be my daughter's 1st CCL cruise. I had a hard time convincing her to come.

The 2 lines are different in a lot of ways. Disney caters to families especially in their cabin design & size. Like a PP said there isn't a casino. Assigned dining times and rotational dining. Lots of activities for the kids if the adults would like some grown up time. No charge for the kids clubs after a certain time. Dedicated adults only area on the pool deck. You're able to carry on your own alcohol.

I've never sailed CCL with my daughter so cannot compare kids clubs. Although I did feel claustrophobic in my balcony stateroom whenever I was in it on the Destiny. I'm hoping my experience will be different on the Valor. Food was about the same to me.

I think the biggest drawback for me on Disney is the lack of itineraries during the summer months. I'm sick of the Bahamas at this point & don't think I can do the eastern and western Caribbean more than once each. Alaska is not in our plans just yet & the Med is very port intensive so we're leaving that for when she's older.
#9
389 Posts
Joined Apr 2005
Just got off the Carnival Magic.

We like to gamble so it was an easy decision for us....Disney cruises do not have casinos.

Carnival Magic: The splash pad is absolutely the best part of this cruise for us. This is our second time on this ship. My boys are 4, 4, 3. They have smaller slides along with all kinds of water shooting spouts in this area. If your kids are older...the larger slides are a blast (I totally loved it ). The sky course is also pretty cool. I didn't do it...but my husband said it was a lot of fun! My kids were too little for this. Between the splash pad area, slides, sky course, putt putt, pool table, arcade, pools....there is just a ton of stuff to do.

Shows on Carnival: We really didn't do many shows. We did see the magic show..and that was fantastic and totally worth it.

Camp Carnival: I can tell you that we had repeat counselors and they are sweet and fun loving. My kids couldn't wait to go back to camp everyday. They loved it!
#10
333 Posts
Joined Aug 2009
Hey,

Right now kids under 17 are free (just taxes and fees) on the Dream out of TX. this brought the price pretty darn close to carnival. We might be crazy, but we're gonna try Disney (And if it sucks, I'll never turn my back to Carnival again!) I wouldn't do it for the extra cost (my kid's only 1, at 3-5 I might)
#11
354 Posts
Joined Aug 2009
Originally posted by CarnivalGirl3
Hey,

Right now kids under 17 are free (just taxes and fees) on the Dream out of TX. this brought the price pretty darn close to carnival. We might be crazy, but we're gonna try Disney (And if it sucks, I'll never turn my back to Carnival again!) I wouldn't do it for the extra cost (my kid's only 1, at 3-5 I might)
Carnivalgirl - just want to make sure you realize that it is the Disney Magic that sails out of Texas. The Dream sails out of Port Canaveral. The ships are different, so just want to make sure you are aware.
#13
210 Posts
Joined Feb 2011
I will say that we are Disney lovers, go to WDW every year. However, I just can't bring myself to spring for a Disney cruise when Carnival is less than half the price, we are booked on the Carnival Legend in Jan., total price for 2 adults and a 9 year old in a balcony room, $1671, Disney is $3500 for an inside room, same time frame and ports. We took DD9 on a Carnival cruise this past Feb. and she LOVED it! Would she love a Disney cruise? I'm sure she would, but this way she got to go on a cruise AND go to WDW.