Ranking of Antarctica Cruise Lines

** Please post your recommendations ONLY in response to request...do not start a new thread. Thanks!
Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts
BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
All times are GMT -4.
The time now is 04:44 AM.
#1
Baltimore
36 Posts
Joined Sep 2016
We want to do a cruise where we can fly 1st class to departure point, and probably prefer Buenos Aires to Santiago or vice versa. We also would like a December to January trip. We were thinking in terms of Seabourne but saw that it had mixed reviews. Perhaps unfair? A massage person on board is a must. We are old enough to want a fair amount of luxury, but are not super fussy either. Suggestions?
#3
Baltimore
36 Posts
Joined Sep 2016
Thanks, Keith. That is what I found on one site, but I wondered how reliable it was. Is there a place on this site where cruise lines are generally rated?
#4
101,670 Posts
Joined Jul 2000
Originally posted by der110
Thanks, Keith. That is what I found on one site, but I wondered how reliable it was. Is there a place on this site where cruise lines are generally rated?
You are very welcome.

Cruise Critic does do ratings but a good thing is to read member reviews.

The challenge is take three different people on the same cruise and you can get three different opinions.

Keith
#7
Oslo, Norway
1,718 Posts
Joined Aug 2006
In addition to Seabourn, Silversea, Ponant, National Geographic, and at least one of the Hapag Lloyd expedition ships all offer massage.

You'll find more Antarctica trip reviews on TripAdvisor
#8
ExPerth, Now Melb Aus
763 Posts
Joined Feb 2010
Yep we have loads of trip reports on the Trip Advisor Antarctic forum. List by ship name is here
http://antarcticafaqs.boards.net/boa...rted-ship-name
I can't add to the massage query. Never had time to think about needing one on any of my voyages.


Sent from my iPhone using Forums
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Antarctica
Kapitan Khlebnikov Nov 2010 (West Antarctica, Weddell Sea, Riser Laarsen Coast, Sth Sandwhich & Sth Georgia Islands)
Kapitan Khlebnikov Dec 2011 (Final voyage - East Antarctica & Heard Island)
Sea Adventurer: Feb 2014 (East side of Antarctica Peninsular, South Georgia Is, Falkland Is).

Ortelius: Feb 2014 Bluff NZ, Ross Sea, West Antarctica, Peninsula, Peter 1st Island, Ushuaia
Other regions: too many to list so just the highlights:
P&O Oriana 1984 (Indian Ocean) and 1986 (Pacific Ocean), Superstar Virgo 2003 (Indian Ocean),
Radiance of the Seas: Nov 2014 Bravo Theatre Opera cruise - Noumea.

#9
Encino, CA
1,151 Posts
Joined Mar 2009
Originally posted by der110
We want to do a cruise where we can fly 1st class to departure point, and probably prefer Buenos Aires to Santiago or vice versa. We also would like a December to January trip. We were thinking in terms of Seabourne but saw that it had mixed reviews. Perhaps unfair? A massage person on board is a must. We are old enough to want a fair amount of luxury, but are not super fussy either. Suggestions?
Check out the newly revamped Silver Cloud (Silversea). We are booked for February.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
FUTURE CRUISES
Scenic Eclipse - Tromso to Oslo (Arctic) - July, 2020
Viking Sky - Bergen to Reykjavik - August, 2019
Regent Explorer - Cape Town to Cape Town - December, 2018

PAST CRUISES
Silver Cloud Expedition - Ushuaia to Ushuaia (Antarctica) - February, 2018
Oceania Marina - London to London - August, 2017
Viking Star - Puerto Rico to Puerto Rico - February, 2017
Oceania Marina - Amsterdam to Barcelona - September, 2016
Oceania Marina - Sydney to Auckland - February, 2016
Viking Star - Venice to Istanbul - September, 2015
Oceania Marina - New York to Montreal May, 2015
Viking Njord - Budapest to Prague - August, 2014
Viking Emerald - Shanghai to Beijing - April, 2014
Silversea Whisper - Hong Kong to Singapore - February, 2013
Regent Voyager - Stockholm to Copenhagen - September, 2012
Regent Mariner - Barcelona to Rome - May, 2011
Regent Mariner - Istanbul to Athens - August, 2010
Regent Mariner - Alaska - August, 2009
Carnival cruise - Mexico - 2000
Disney cruise - Bahamas - 1989
#10
Memphis, TN
105 Posts
Joined Apr 2009
We LOVE being on Le Boreal (Ponant) ... all balcony suites, luxurious and well appointed, great food, spa and massage - best part is the excursions. Off the ship twice a day, in cold weather gear to be ashore in that magnificent place.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
DadainTN

Sailed on Le Boreal to the Arctic - August 2016 with Abercrombie & Kent
Sailing on Oceania- Nautica - March 26, 2015 to China, Japan & Vietnam
Sailed on Oceania Marina December 28, 2103 Santiago to Papeete
Sailed on Le Boreal to Antarctica January 2, 2013 with Abercrombie & Kent
Sailed on Regent Seven Seas Voyager May 3, 2012
Sailed on Oceania Regatta March 9, 2011
Cruised the Loire Canal September 12,2010
Sailed on Oceania Insignia July 26, 2009
Sailed on Celebrity, February 2008
Sailed on Oceania Regatta 2006
Sailed on Holland America 2005
#11
Oslo, Norway
1,718 Posts
Joined Aug 2006
Originally posted by PerfectlyPerth
I can't add to the massage query. Never had time to think about needing one on any of my voyages.
I have definitely thought about it after a couple of landings where we opted into some high-energy steep hill climbs in deep snow!

But since anything higher than "Medium" luxury level feels too fancy for my expedition tastes, I'm pretty sure I'd be uncomfortable on any ship that offered them! I'll save my luxe cruising for other parts of the world where I can use my luggage allowance for my evening gowns instead of for my GoreTex and thermals!
#13
ExPerth, Now Melb Aus
763 Posts
Joined Feb 2010
Originally posted by der110
Thanks for all of the feedback. I have back issues, hence the massage query.
I have done 4 Antarctica expeditions complete with 2 bulging discs. Never had or needed a massage in my life - not a fan of strangers touching me - personally. Just not something I am into.
BUT!
I take serious medication and I pack plenty of it. I also pack the nurofen stick on heat patches that last 8 hours. So after a physical day of zodiacs and expeditions I have a long hot shower and slap the stick on patches, pop the pills - and head to bed. I pack my travel sized TENS machine too - slap it on for 30 - 60 minutes once I am in bed or if I am sitting at the desk doing photo sorting. Let it do its job.
I also use spare pillows to prop around my back when I sleep - first trip I didnt and I rolled around in rough seas too much and popped the disc. (Thank you to the ship dr who did the morphine shot straight into my spine - kept me mobile for the next few landings). So next trips I used extra pillows and it stopped me from moving too much in bed when the sea was rough.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Antarctica
Kapitan Khlebnikov Nov 2010 (West Antarctica, Weddell Sea, Riser Laarsen Coast, Sth Sandwhich & Sth Georgia Islands)
Kapitan Khlebnikov Dec 2011 (Final voyage - East Antarctica & Heard Island)
Sea Adventurer: Feb 2014 (East side of Antarctica Peninsular, South Georgia Is, Falkland Is).

Ortelius: Feb 2014 Bluff NZ, Ross Sea, West Antarctica, Peninsula, Peter 1st Island, Ushuaia
Other regions: too many to list so just the highlights:
P&O Oriana 1984 (Indian Ocean) and 1986 (Pacific Ocean), Superstar Virgo 2003 (Indian Ocean),
Radiance of the Seas: Nov 2014 Bravo Theatre Opera cruise - Noumea.

#14
Baltimore
36 Posts
Joined Sep 2016
I don't know if that post was encouraging or discouraging. I have never used nurofen sticks, but bring a heating pad with me. I have a Therastem machine, sort of a massage machine, but have never tried Tens machines much. What kind do you use? We ended up booking on Seabourn. It was a mix of price, timing of the trip, bigger stateroom, and the ability to see more of Chile which offsets somewhat less time ashore in Antarctica. I found a German expedition ship that has a trip at the right time, but the trip is conducted in German, which I speak, but my girlfriend does not. Also, quite expensive.
#15
ExPerth, Now Melb Aus
763 Posts
Joined Feb 2010
I have used TENS machines since the 80s - mine is just a small hand held unit about the size of an iphone 6 plus and 1.5cm thick, with multiple small pads and also a big spinal pad. Runs off battery or powerpoint. Current one is about 10 years old so I cant remember where I bought it. Chemist Warehouse has a fairly small one that would be good for travel http://www.chemistwarehouse.com.au/b...s-Unit-HVF-128

If I am doing a carry-on only style holiday I take this type http://painmate.com.au

The stick on therapeutic heat pads I use are https://www.aussiehealthproducts.com...ads-pk-10.php?
And the deep heat ones are pretty good too https://www.deepheat.com.au/product/...-back-patches/
The Nurofen ones are good and last longer than the promised 8 hours http://www.chemistwarehouse.com.au/b...in-Heat-2-Pack
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Antarctica
Kapitan Khlebnikov Nov 2010 (West Antarctica, Weddell Sea, Riser Laarsen Coast, Sth Sandwhich & Sth Georgia Islands)
Kapitan Khlebnikov Dec 2011 (Final voyage - East Antarctica & Heard Island)
Sea Adventurer: Feb 2014 (East side of Antarctica Peninsular, South Georgia Is, Falkland Is).

Ortelius: Feb 2014 Bluff NZ, Ross Sea, West Antarctica, Peninsula, Peter 1st Island, Ushuaia
Other regions: too many to list so just the highlights:
P&O Oriana 1984 (Indian Ocean) and 1986 (Pacific Ocean), Superstar Virgo 2003 (Indian Ocean),
Radiance of the Seas: Nov 2014 Bravo Theatre Opera cruise - Noumea.

#16
1 Posts
Joined Jan 2018
Originally posted by der110
We want to do a cruise where we can fly 1st class to departure point, and probably prefer Buenos Aires to Santiago or vice versa. We also would like a December to January trip. We were thinking in terms of Seabourne but saw that it had mixed reviews. Perhaps unfair? A massage person on board is a must. We are old enough to want a fair amount of luxury, but are not super fussy either. Suggestions?
A key point of difference in Antarctica is the size of the ship. Abercrombie & Kent limits Ponant ships to less than 200 guests for the largest choice of landing sites. We went ashore at least twice daily and sometimes there was also a Zodiac cruise to see icebergs or wildlife. A great learning experience with University type briefings by members of the Expedition Team.
#17
ExPerth, Now Melb Aus
763 Posts
Joined Feb 2010
Just adding that I got the catalogue for the release of the new Aurora Expeditions ship - the Greg Mortimer - and it mentions a massage room and staff in their wellbeing centre. Der110 one to add to your list of maybes https://www.auroraexpeditions.com.au/ship/greg-mortimer
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Antarctica
Kapitan Khlebnikov Nov 2010 (West Antarctica, Weddell Sea, Riser Laarsen Coast, Sth Sandwhich & Sth Georgia Islands)
Kapitan Khlebnikov Dec 2011 (Final voyage - East Antarctica & Heard Island)
Sea Adventurer: Feb 2014 (East side of Antarctica Peninsular, South Georgia Is, Falkland Is).

Ortelius: Feb 2014 Bluff NZ, Ross Sea, West Antarctica, Peninsula, Peter 1st Island, Ushuaia
Other regions: too many to list so just the highlights:
P&O Oriana 1984 (Indian Ocean) and 1986 (Pacific Ocean), Superstar Virgo 2003 (Indian Ocean),
Radiance of the Seas: Nov 2014 Bravo Theatre Opera cruise - Noumea.