Alaska cruise-northbound or southbound? Ships to avoid?

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts
BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
All times are GMT -4.
The time now is 01:33 PM.
#1
92 Posts
Joined Nov 2007
i am getting overwhelmed researching Alaska cruises. Do any of you have strong feelings about choosing northbound or southbound cruises (pros or cons) ? Also, any ships to avoid? Or consider?
Thanks for any advice!
#2
MotorHome Fulltime Western US
589 Posts
Joined Jun 2014
We couldn't decide either so just did both B2B on the Coral Princess beginning in Vancouver (May 2017). There is a 26 Glacier Cruise Tour out of Whittier just for B2Bers. Love the Coral.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
-- Warren and Marla
Home is where we park it!

Recent:
Ruby Princess Catalina 25 Nov 2017
Ruby Princess Sea of Cortez 29 Nov 2017
Emerald Princess Hawai'i/Samoa/Tahiti R/T LA Mar 30 2018

Upcoming:
Star Princess Hawai'i R/T LA Nov 19 2018
#3
Chico, California
10,988 Posts
Joined Sep 2012
If doing a cruise tour I prefer land first then southbound cruise. Coral is a great ship for this itinerary. My only caveat is that I don't like Island Princess since they hacked it up and took away public space while adding cabins. More people with less public space. Nope, nope, nope. It doesn't even have an International Cafe! It's my least favorite Princess ship. For Alaska Coral would be my first choice followed by maybe Ruby.

If you are just doing the cruise without the land tour then the 26 Glacier Cruise Tour out of Whittier sounds amazing. I didn't even know about that one so now I have to go look into it.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Thrak

Not Elite but having fun working on it...





#5
Suwanee & Ellijay, Georgia
928 Posts
Joined Nov 2010
We would go with the Southbound. Living on the East coast, it's about a five hour direct flight from either Seattle or Vancouver back to Atlanta. Much longer flight and typically a plane change flying from Anchorage if we had done the Northbound. We did our own land trip last year and was also another reason to enjoy those activities, then a relaxing cruise at the end of the trip.



Our first pick would be the Coral, as our favorite ship. We like the size of the ship and has lots of open deck space. We have not sailed on the Island, however after three trips on the Coral, we know we would not like the changes they made and would not sail on it.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
David & Ellen
-----------------------------------------

Caribbean Princess 10/2018 - Southern Caribbean Melody
Coral Princess 8/2017 - Alaska Southbound ....... Review & Pics ..................
Caribbean Princess 2/2017 - Western Caribbean ......... Review & Pics ............
Coral Princess 2/2016 - Panama Canal ......... Review & Pics .............
Emerald Princess 11/2015 - Western Caribbean
Vision Of the Seas 6/2014 - Western Caribbean
Coral Princess 2/2014 - Panama Canal
Sapphire Princess 9/2013 - Alaska
Golden Princess 9/2012 - Alaska
Golden Princess 9/2011 - Alaska
Celebrity Century 2/2009 - Caribbean
#6
84 Posts
Joined Nov 2010
We prefer the last then cruise, so southbound. And I agree with the other poster, stay away from the island. If you use the gym at at, it is on a lower level in a room with no windows..
#7
Greenville, SC, USA
54,339 Posts
Joined Apr 2000
About 2 years ago, we did a NB on the Coral, followed by a 7 day land tour and then a SB on the Star. Preferred the Coral.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Paul
#9
Kansas
475 Posts
Joined Jun 2004
I have read that the positive of NB is, you starts small and build up on scenery. Kind of the just gets better and better idea. With SB, has has been stated, start running, especially when doing land first, and then relax.

For is, it was a combination of timing of the offerings and building up works better for the husband. He is not a good relaxer.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Island Princess May 2018
Carnival Ecstasy March 19, 2011
Carnival Holiday July 25, 2004
#10
Toronto
57 Posts
Joined Nov 2011
Go on any ship that includes Glacier Bay National Park scenic cruising. That is my favourite place on earth and Princess makes a big deal of that day. I love the 14 day b2b from Vancouver. It took me awhile to get talked into an Alaskan cruise but once I went I couldn’t get enough. Take layers to wear and binoculars to see.


Sent from my iPhone using Forums
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Caribbean Princess December 2008 - Eastern Caribbean
Crown Princess October 2010 -Western Caribbean
Ruby Princess January 2011 -Eastern Caribbean
Crown Princess November 2011 - Southern Caribbean
Coral Princess November 2012 -Panama Canal
Ruby Princess June 2013 - Greek Isles & Mediterranean
Caribbean Princess September 2013 -Canada/New England's
Royal Princess January 2014-Eastern Caribbean
Royal Princess February 2014 - Eastern Caribbean
Grand Princess April 2014 - Hawaii
Crown Princess August 2014 - Alaska Northbound
Crown Princess September 2014 - Alaska Southbound
Caribbean Princess November 2014 - Eastern Caribbean
Regal Princess November 2014 - Eastern Caribbean
Regal Princess November 2014 - Eastern Caribbean
Celebrity Reflection April 2015 - Eastern Caribbean
Grand Princess August 2015 - Alaska Northbound
Grand Princess September 2015 - Alaska Southbound
Royal Princess November 2015 - Eastern Caribbean
Crown Princess May 2016 - Alaska Inside Passage With Glacier Bay
Crown Princess September 2016 - California Coastal
Crown Princess September 2016 - Mexican Riviera
Regal Princess February 2017 - Caribbean East/West Adventure

Regal Princess November 2017 - Caribbean East/West Adventure
Regal Princess February 2018 - Caribbean East/West Adventure
Regal Princess - August 2018 - European Transatlantic
#11
Northern California
7,140 Posts
Joined Oct 2002
Originally posted by Coral
I also prefer the Coral Princess.

I would avoid the Royal Princess next year.
Why would you avoid the Royal in 2019?
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Karen

http://www.shutterfly.com/lightbox/v...#1367718572321 (Mis. Alaska photos -2008, 2011)

http://s657.photobucket.com/albums/u...railingspouse/ (Alaska 2012)

https://millenniumalaska2014.shutter...%3dSHARE3SXXXX (Alaska 2014, 2010, 2009)

https://millenniumalaska2015.shutter...%3dSHARE3SXXXX (Alaska 2015)

https://radiancealaska2016.shutterfl...%3dSHARE3SXXXX (Alaska 2016)

https://alaska2017princessandhal.shutterfly.com/ (Alaska 2017)











#12
Texas
1,978 Posts
Joined Aug 2011
I highly recommend the 15 day connoisseur escorted cruise tour offered by Princess. No hassles with luggage, lodging, or transportation, most meals and some excursions included. Tour land first so you can relax more on southbound cruise. Pick the Coral Princess as it is a great ship. It has fewer passengers, the Bayou Cafe Steakhouse, and the production show "On The Bayou".
The Royal Princess has some good features such as the best buffet design of any ship in the Princess fleet. It has a nice large atrium also. The balconies are very small on the Royal class ships however and the ship carries a lot of passengers. That makes getting on and off the ship a little more time consuming and finding a seat in the theater for a production show more inconvenient.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
USS Greenling SSN614
Atlantic Ocean/Barents Sea
#13
26,346 Posts
Joined Jul 2001
Originally posted by Italy52
Why would you avoid the Royal in 2019?
There is no promenade deck, no covered pool, etc... While I don't go into the pool, I like that space to relax and on the ships with out the covered pool (Ruby, Emerald, Crown), when the weather is not good, everyone goes inside and the ships get really crowded. So this enclosed pool area provides a beautiful indoor area.

I prefer promenade deck for glacier days and to be able to move around. There is no promenade deck which will make the top deck more crowded. Not sure how viewing would be on that top deck anyway.

Balconies are small on Royal Princess.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Email Me
#14
Southern California
1,178 Posts
Joined Jan 2009
Regarding north vs south. Take the 10 day RT out of San Francisco and get them both.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Paul

Future
Mexico Thanksgiving 2018. Ruby
South America: Fort Lauderdale to LA Feb/Mar 2019 Royal

Completed
California Coastal March/April 2018. RubyRuby Princess Mexico Nov. 2017
Diamond PrincessJapan and SE Asia Oct 2017
Ruby Princess Cabo Nov. 2016
Alaska June/July 2016
California Coastal Apr/May 2016
Vancouver to Seattle (1 Day)
Santa Barbara Nov. 2015
Golden Princess Buenos Aires to Santiago March 2015 Part 1
Golden Princess Santiago to Los Angeles March 2015 Part 2
Grand Princess Mexico Rivera Nov. 2014
Sapphire Princess Southern California Jan. 2014 Part 2
Sapphire Princess Southern California Jan 2014 Part 1
Ruby Princess Eastern Mediterranean Rome to Barcelona Oct 2013 Part 3
Ruby Princess Eastern Mediterranean Athens to Rome Oct 2013 Part 2
Ruby Princess Eastern Mediterranean Venice to Athens Sep/Oct 2013 Part I
Coral Princess: Panama Canal Feb 2013
Emerald Princess Southern Caribbean Apr 2012 Part 2
Emerald Princess Eastern Caribbean Apr 2012 Part 1
Sapphire Princess South Pacific Oct 2011
Sea Princess Alaska July 2011
Golden Princess Hawaii March 2011
Sapphire Princess Mexico Rivera Dec 2010
Sea Princess, Alaska, Sep. 2010
Crown Princess, West Caribbean, Apr. 2010
Diamond Princess, Australia and NZ, Jan. 2010
Carnival Splendor, Mexican Rivera, Dec. 2009
Coral Princess, Panama Canal, Sep. and Oct 2009
Grand Princess, West Europe, Apr. and May 2009 Part 2
Grand Princess, Transatlantic and UK, Apr. 2009 Part 1
Star Princess. Mexican Rivera, Oct. 2008
#15
Pennsylvania
131 Posts
Joined Jan 2015
Southbound. We've done it twice, first time on the recommendations of several friends. We flew in to Fairbanks a day early each time, rented a car for the day and toured Fairbanks. Visited the University of Alaska Museum of the North, it is awesome. Also ate at the Turtle Club; delicious food and local favorite. We asked for local suggestions and found everyone to be very friendly. Walmart had some of the best prices for souvenirs. The first time we did a Princess cruisetour, the second time we did one from Best Cruises and Tours out of New Jersey. Both were excellent. Princess hotel in Denali is located very centrally to the park and stores. Princess McKinley Lodge has a great view of the mountain (when she decided to appear). Make sure you get a cruisetour that included the scenic train rides and tour into Denali.
Have fun and enjoy planning!
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature



September, 2007 - Island Princess to Alaska, cruisetour
August, 2014 - Crown Princess to Alaska, cruisetour
February, 2015 - Royal Princess to Southern Caribbean
January, 2016 - Island Princess to Panama Canal
February, 2017 - Regal Princess to Eastern Caribbean with St. Maarten
September, 2017 - Regal Princess to British Isles and Norway Passage and Transatlantic
February, 2018 - Royal Princess to Eastern Caribbean Voyager

#17
2,037 Posts
Joined Apr 2005
Avoid Island.

We chose Star this year because we’re going early and prefer a ship with a magrodome, which left Coral, Star or Golden. I *love* Coral but DH has this weird dislike of Island/Coral for the most ridiculous of reasons (pool configuration, Horizon Court layout, phase of the moon, I don’t know), so Coral was right out. Golden vs Star came down to timing.

I’m on Team Northbound Start because the ports and scenery improve day by day. I’m also Team B2B because it improves the odds of glorious weather when you’re in that port. My ultimate itinerary would probably be a northbound start, a few days of land touring and a Southbound on a different ship.
#18
26,346 Posts
Joined Jul 2001
Originally posted by VibeGuy
I’m also Team B2B because it improves the odds of glorious weather when you’re in that port. My ultimate itinerary would probably be a northbound start, a few days of land touring and a Southbound on a different ship.
I agree! Even B2B on the same ship is fine also.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Email Me
#19
Victoria, BC
5,244 Posts
Joined Jul 2008
i like the coral also... except in 3 weeks i'll be doing a southbound on the island. i've been to alaska on the island when she was the same as the coral. i won't like the changes but its still a cruise, i will be traveling with a bunch of family and i have my own room. its all good.

for me the southbound works because i don't have a plane ride at the end.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Email me


#20
Austin, Texas area
760 Posts
Joined Oct 2004
For the southbound cruises starting with land tours, what's the difference in starting in Anchorage/Whittier vs. Fairbanks? I've noticed that the cruise tours start in both places and seem to include some of the same lodges, etc.

We're looking at June 2020. I checked out the 2019 prices for the Connossoieur cruise tour; I don't think I can swing that price for four people. Will have to stick with a regular 3 or 4-day tour.