One over the other

Welcome to Cruise Critic! If you'd like to participate on our forums by joining in the conversation, please Register Now! Be sure to visit our FAMOUS Roll Call forums, where you can meet other cruisers sailing with you and share a tour or shore excursion and SAVE MONEY!

Honeymoon & Wedding Cruises
Ready to say "I do?" Plan a honeymoon cruise here.
Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts
BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
All times are GMT -4.
The time now is 02:22 PM.
129 Posts
Joined Jan 2003
Hey everyone,

What made you choose one cruiseline over the other for your wedding. Just curious, because I'm partial to Princess, just wondering what other options and reasons why you chose other cruiselines to host your wedding!

Also, if you looked into Princess why did you opt out of using Princess and choosing another line?


I greatly appreciate your feedback and comments!
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Sea Princess: 08/2000
RCCL Voyager of the Seas: 12/2002
Golden Princess: 07/2003
Princess ship....sometime in year 2007 (Getting married)

Can NEVER get ENOUGH cruisin

Keep on Cruisin!
178 Posts
Joined Apr 2005
We chose Princess b/c we wanted to get married at sea by the ship's captain. We originally were looking at RCCL, but since they didn't offer the above option and they took FOREVER to release their summer 2006 itineraries, we went with Princess.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature

Caribbean Princess - 5/27/06 (Wedding Voyage!)
Carnival Ecstasy - 04/04
RCCL Navigator of the Seas - 11/03
1,017 Posts
Joined Jul 2004
We were open to Princess, NCL or RCCL. But in the end itinerary and timing made the decision for us. The 6 day Western Carib itinerery offered on the then brand new Jewel of the Seas helped swing us toward RCCL. But I think each of the cruise lines has their pluses and minuses. It all depends on which features are most important to you.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature

RCL Jewel of the Seas 1/21/2018 (Team Cocktail) - Southern Caribbean
RCL Adventure of the Seas 1/28/2017 (Team Cocktail) - Southern Caribbean
RCL Brilliance of the Seas 3/3/2016 (Team Cocktail Spring Fling) - Western Caribbean
RCL Jewel of the Seas 1/10/2016 (Team Cocktail) - Southern Caribbean
RCL Adventure of the Seas 1/18/2015 (Team Cocktail) - Southern Caribbean
Celebrity Summit 1/11/2014 (Team Cocktail) - Southern Caribbean
RCL Brilliance of the Seas 1/19/2013 (Team Cocktail) - Southern Caribbean
Carnival Victory 1/15/2012 (Team Cocktail) - Southern Caribbean
RCL Majesty of the Seas 4/22/2011 - Bahamas
MS Queen of Hansa 1/24/2011 - Nile Cruise
Norwegian Star 7/10/2010 - Alaska
Disney Wonder 2/18/2010 - Bahamas (cancelled)
Norwegian Jewel - Western Caribbean 1/17/2010
RCL Serenade of the Seas 1/17/2009 (Team Cocktail) - Southern Caribbean
Carnival Miracle 5/9/2008 (C&V's Wedding) - Eastern Caribbean
RCL Mariner of the Seas 9/23/2007 (IRA Memorial Cruise) - Western Caribbean
RCL Mariner of the Seas 9/4/2005 - Eastern Caribbean
RCL Jewel of the Seas 2/6/2005 (Our Wedding!) - Western Caribbean
Norwegian Dream 3/14/2004 - Repositioning
Carnival Mardi Gras 6/1986 - Bahamas
Lee's Summit, MO
505 Posts
Joined Jun 2004
We were only open to Princess as we wanted to get married at sea by the ship's captain and we also would hate for our guests to miss a port. I just couldn't imagine it any other way. Good luck with you choices!!
2,951 Posts
Joined Nov 2000
We originally were very serious about choosing Princess (Golden Princess) out of Florida and marrying at sea. However, hubby and I realized what we truly wanted was our toes nestled in the sand as we repeated our vows. Because we decided to marry in port, it did not matter what cruiseline we chose as long as we chose a ship that went to that specific port during our timeframe.

We chose the island we wanted to marry on, then chose the itinerary. Because I am a teacher and cannot take vacation on school days, our vacation time was dictated to be either summer, Christmas break, or Spring Break. Wanting to avoid hurricane season (summer), as well as the extremely high prices of Christmas break, we chose Spring Break (March). Our previous experiences had been on NCL and Celebrity, but we kept an open mind and created a spreadsheet of all possible ships leaving during Spring Break from Florida that would have port in St Thomas. We eventually decided on the ship that would have the longest time in St Thomas, as we were marrying on St John. This happened to be with NCL and turned out to be terrific for us.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Upcoming: 04/18 P&O Australia (Pacific Aria), 04/18 RCCL Explorer TransPacific, 9/18 NCL Bliss.
Previous: 08/17 Diamond Princess,
06/17 HAL Noordam NB Alaska, 03/17 RCCL Liberty of Seas, 11/16 Celebrity Infinity (full Panama Canal transit), 05/16 Fathom, 04/16 NCL Escape, 03/16 NCL Dawn, 11/21/15 NCL Jade, 11/30/15 NCL Sky (15th anniversary of cruising - same stateroom!), 01/16 DCL Wonder, 05/14 Carnival Dream , 08/14 Norwegian Star - Baltics from Copenhagen , 09/14 Westbound Transatlantic on Disney Magic BCN-SJU
12/13 Disney Magic Bahamas, 11/13 Caribbean Princess, 06/13 NCL Spirit Barcelona to Venice with Turkey and Croatia,
05/13 Disney Eastbound Transatlantic Galveston-BCN ,
11/12 - Disney Western Caribbean,
09/11 - Disney Westbound TransAtlantic BCN-MCO , 03/09 - Celebrity Southern Caribbean
03/06 - Celebrity Infinity Eastern Caribbean , 06/05 - NCL Sun Alaska
11/04 - HAL ms Zuiderdam Eastern Caribbean , 11/03 - HAL ms Maasdam Western Caribbean
03/2003 S/S Norway E. Caribbean Wedding Cruise ~ Married on the beach on St John, USVI!
12/01 - Celebrity Galaxy Southern Caribbean , 12/00 - NCL Sky Western Caribbean
6 Posts
Joined Jun 2005
We will be getting married on the Carnival Sensation on 8/22. We picked it for a couple of reasons.

We knew we wanted to get married in August or September, and we live in New Orleans. The wedding is going to be very small (we're older and have both been married before) and we originally planned to have it "on land" somewhere here in town, maybe at an inn or B&B, then go on a cruise for the honeymoon. While shopping around for a honeymoon cruise we started seeing all this information about cruise-ship weddings (which I had never heard of before) and thought it sounded like a neat alternative. What the hell, I'm going to be on the ship for the honeymoon anyway! LOL Turns out it will also be less expensive than the "on-land" options we were looking at, which is a plus.

We looked at RCCL and Carnival because they both have departures out of New Orleans (and hold weddings in the departure port), which would allow a few friends/family members to attend without having to travel far. Wound up choosing Carnival for three reasons: 1) we really liked the different packages they offered, especially the "Just the Bride & Groom" and the "luncheon" packages; 2) their sailing dates worked better with our schedules; and 3) we are pretty casual people and Carnival seems like it might be a more casual, down-to-earth line than RCCL.

Obviously the wedding itself hasn't happened yet, but I've been real happy with the wedding coordinator so far, and with the choices they have offered us (re: flowers, vows, unity candle at the ceremony, special readings, etc.)