Paradise Beach or Mr. Sanchos for family?

Which is better Paradise Beach or Mr. Sanchos for family?

Which has the better beach? Restaurants? Staff etc

I know Mr. Sanchos is AI and Paradise is not so assuming two adults and two kids, plus lunch for 4, 10 alcoholic beverages, drinks for kids etc would we probably end up spending the same at both places?

Sanchos has a better beach, but PB offers better facilities and a HUGE pool. You are correct that with what you estimate purchasing, the AI and pay as you go options will cost about the same. Service and food are about the same IMHO. Your call. ;)

Paradise Beach has water toys if your kids would like that for $18 per person.

Can you make ressy ahead of time?

No, you just show up.

No reservations for PB -- you can pre-book for Sanchos AI side

we did mr sanchos 2 years ago with 2 kids.. ages 4 and almost 2. They had a blast!

Note for older kids mr sanchos also has the inflatable water stuff $18pp