Equinox, Reflection or Silhouette

We have been on the Reflection and the Equinox. I love both! I really enjoy the Glass Blowing shows and the open usable lawn on the Equinox! I love the Sunset Bar on the Reflection although the sea views on the lawn are blocked by cabanas on this ship. They are both beautiful ships and you cannot go wrong! I can't speak yet for the other 2, although we will be on the Silhouette Nov 26.:D

I'd go on the one with the longest itinerary ... ;)

Nor would I. But OP specifically mentioned food being mostly the same on all ships and I was just pointing out the lack of Lawn Grill on Equinox.

I would definitely book Silhouette or Reflection to get LCG.

Have sailed all Celebrity ships, and my rating of these in order of preference is Equinox, Silhouette, and then Reflection (the latter being the most crowded). But you cannot be disappointed with any of them. I would pick the longest, but you indicated that doesn't matter (although I think 14 nights on Celebrity beats a combo with another cruise line IMHO)