Which NCL Catamaran and Snorkel Excursion?

I am sailing NCL's Escape in April, and I'm starting to look at excursion options. In one of the ports, I would like to do a catamaran and snorkel excursion, and I've found an option in Nassau and one in Costa Maya. So I am reaching out to both boards (yes, I'm double posting to both the Bahama and Costa Maya boards). Does anyone have recent feedback regarding the Seahorse Sail and Snorkel (Nassau) or the Catamaran Sail and Snorkel (out of Costa Maya, not sure which company is used)? If you have info on one or both, I'd be happy to take it! I am wondering about the condition of the boats, the experience while on board, the pleasantness/helpfulness of the crew, and the quality of snorkeling. If you can compare the two, then you're AMAZING!

Thanks in advance.

Did Seahorse several years ago and it was great.

Thanks! Can you give a bit more detail about what you enjoyed?

I can't imagine Costa Maya snorkeling being better than Nassau.