Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts
BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
All times are GMT -4.
The time now is 06:02 PM.
#2
small town in the Midwest
365 Posts
Joined Aug 2011
They're both nice ships. Freedom is 10 years old, Breeze is 5. Breeze carries 25% more passengers but has a few more venues. I would base my decision on itinerary, cruise fare & cost to travel to port.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Carnival Holiday 1994 * Carnival Festivale 1996 * Carnival Sensation 1998 * Disney Magic 1999 * Carnival Elation 2002 * Carnival Glory 2005 * Carnival Spirit 2006 * Caribbean Princess 2007 * Carnival Valor 2010 * Carnival Miracle 2011 * Carnival Destiny 2012 * Carnival Freedom 2012 * Carnival Ecstasy 2013 * Carnival Dream 2013 * Carnival Sunshine 2014 * Carnival Imagination 2015 * Carnival Inspiration 2016 * Carnival Conquest 2016 * Carnival Breeze 2017 *
#3
Twin Citties
210 Posts
Joined Apr 2012
Been on both twice and loved them both. If you like the itinary of both ships, I would go with the breeze. newer and more dining options

Sent from my SM-N950U using Forums mobile app
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Booked: Carnival Vista Mar 4-18, 2018 B2B

Carnival Vista Feb 2017.
Carnival Breeze Feb 2016.
Carnival Breeze Feb 2015
Carnival Liberty Mar 2014
Carnival Freedom Feb 2013
Carnival Freedom Feb 2012
RCI Freedom of the Seas Mar 2011
Carnival Liberty Feb 2010
#4
Texas
1,707 Posts
Joined Mar 2009
I have been on both and would easily pick the Breeze over the Freedom if I had a choice. I like the decor much better and the options for deck activities and dining options. As was said above, itinerary and schedule availability would probably weigh more toward my decision between the two ships.

Sent from my SM-G950U using Tapatalk
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Jenny

2019 - Carnival Vista April
2018 – Ruby Princess Mar; Carnival Vista Oct (Friend’s Cruise)
2017 - Carnival Breeze April; Carnival Valor Sept (Girl’s Cruise)
2016 – Carnival Freedom Feb (Girl’s Cruise) & Sept
2015 - Carnival Triumph Feb (Girl’s Cruise); Emerald Princess Feb; Celebrity Eclipse Bucket List Transatlantic Nov
2014 - Carnival Magic Feb, July Family Trip, & Aug
2013 – Carnival Conquest (Feb & Nov); Carnival Triumph (Aug)
2012 - Disney Magic (Sept Family Dream Trip)
2011 - Carnival Conquest (Feb); Carnival Victory (May)
2010 – Carnival Ecstasy (Feb Family Cruise); Carnival Spirit (Aug Bucket List Cruise) Review http://boards.cruisecritic.com/showthread.php?t=1270083
2009 – Carnival Conquest (Sept)
2007 – Royal Caribbean Splendour of the Seas (Jan); Carnival Conquest (Sept)
2006 - Carnival Ecstasy (Aug) I fell in love with cruising
#5
mansfield, tx
3,493 Posts
Joined Mar 2004
I like both ships. Breeze has the outdoor walkway on deck 5 with comfy seating as well as 2 large water slides, ropes course. However, there is no adult pool. Freedom's size is a bit more manageable and the aft pool is adult only. There is only the 1 large water slide and no ropes course.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Carnival Vista 5/25/19
Carnival Magic 5/5/18 - 7441 balcony
Regal Princess 11/6/16 - M311 balcony Thank you, Imperial Sugar!!
Carnival Freedom 4/30/16 - 9209 interior
Carnival Breeze 9/26/15 - 7441 balcony
Carnival Freedom 5/16/15 - 9204 interior handicap
Carnival Magic 1/25/15 - 8409 balcony
Carnival Glory 9/06/14 - 1056 balcony
Royal Caribbean Oasis of the Seas 9/15/12 - 12710 balcony
Carnival Liberty 11/05/11 - 9246 balcony
Royal Caribbean Enchantment of the Seas 9/18/10 - window
Carnival Liberty 7/10/10 - 7246 interior
Carnival Conquest 8/2/09 - 9250 balcony
Carnival Valor 7/13/08 - 9235 interior
Carnival Elation 8/8/04 - R86 interior
Carnival Jubilee 6/23/03 - U93 window
www.facebook.com/deannamcs
#6
H-Town
789 Posts
Joined Jun 2008
I would agree that it depends on the cost and ports. Freedom and breeze compared side by side for me is a toss up. I love them both. Breeze for the newness, I love the sky course and open, sunny spaces. Freedom, I love the old school feeling of cruising . The freedom has a nice gym and free hot sauna in the gym whereas I didn’t find that same amenity on the breeze for free. Breeze had the deluxe ocean view with two restrooms in the cabin. Freedom does not. I love the cruise director on freedom but they are moving around soon. I am cruising freedom and breeze this year and both times new experiences. Freedom I have my first aft balcony. Breeze I have my first 4J cabins. I couldn’t decide between the two.


Sent from my iPad using Forums
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
We LUV to Cruise! We LUV to Travel!

Carnival Holiday - May 2002
Carnival Celebration - May 2003
Carnival Triumph - August 2007
Carnival Conquest- August 2008
Carnival Victory - May 2009
Carnival Freedom - June 2011
Carnival Triumph - June 2014
Carnival Triumph - June 2015
Carnival Breeze - June 2016
Carnival Freedom - November 2016 - My sisters 50th birthday
Carnival Freedom - June 2017
Carnival Valor - October 2017 - My birthday cruise
Carnival Valor - November 2017 - Thanksgiving cruise
Carnival Breeze - August 2018

Upcoming cruises planned:
October 2018 - birthday cruise
November 2018 - Thanksgiving cruise
#7
Southern NJ near Philly
7,952 Posts
Joined Nov 2010
They are both sailing out of Galveston, so that is a draw. Have sailed on the Breeze once in 2013 and the Freedom twice in 2009 and 2015. Would choose the Breeze simply because it was my favorite Carnival cruise out of the 17 I have been on and since she now has the Alchemy Bar after her dry dock, it's a slam dunk because it would heighten the cruise experience that much more.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Norwegian Bliss 2/2/19 Eastern Caribbean
Carnival Horizon 8/24/19 Southern Caribbean
Celebrity Edge 1/5/20 Western Caribbean
32 Trips 26 Ships 7 Cruise Lines 40 Ports
#8
Sunny San Diego
1,793 Posts
Joined Apr 2009
I've been on both and prefer the bells & whistles of the Breeze. The thing that I remember most about the Freedom was how difficult it was to navigate. It just seemed like it was hard to get from point A to point B and we always ended up getting lost. Even after 7 days. That's never happened on any other ship.
Not a deal breaker by any means. We had a great time. But I found it the most difficult ship to get around on out of all my cruises.

Loved the Breeze!
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
2018- Carnival Horizon- 7 night Mediterranean
2016- Carnival Breeze- 7 night Western Caribbean
2016- Carnival Miracle- 7 night Mexican Riveira
2015- Carnival Freedom- 7 night Western Caribbean
2014- Carnival Miracle- 7 night Mexican Riviera
2010- Carnival Spirit- 8 night Exotic Mexican Riviera
2000- Carnival Elation- 7 night Mexican Riviera
2000- Royal Caribbean Explorer of the Seas- Inaugural cruise

I’m no longer a Warm Chocolate Melting Cake Virgin!
#9
Southern NJ near Philly
7,952 Posts
Joined Nov 2010
Originally posted by MaiTaiMary
But I found it the most difficult ship to get around on out of all my cruises.
All you really needed to know Mary was how to get from bar A to bar B to see if they made your favorite alcoholic concoction any differently.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Norwegian Bliss 2/2/19 Eastern Caribbean
Carnival Horizon 8/24/19 Southern Caribbean
Celebrity Edge 1/5/20 Western Caribbean
32 Trips 26 Ships 7 Cruise Lines 40 Ports
#10
Texas
41 Posts
Joined May 2010
Originally posted by joetrucker
Booked on Carnival Freedom for June sailing . I'm second-guessing and thinking about going on the breeze has anyone sailed both could you tell me the pros and cons

Sent from my SM-G935V using Forums mobile app
I prefer the décor on the Breeze- prettier!
I prefer the food on the Freedom!
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Carnival CL 24- Tropicale 7/84, Dream 5/10, Magic 3/14, 12/14, 3/15, 5/15, 9/15, 12/15, 3/16,
Triumph 4/15, 5/15, Freedom 6/15, 2/16, 7/16, 12/17, 2/18, Sunshine 5/16,
Breeze 9/16, 12/16, 3/17, 5/18, Valor 1/17, 2/17, Pride 7/17, (159 days)
Princess CL 13 - Island 11/15, Caribbean 2/16, 5/17, 5/18 Emerald 9/17, 9/17,
Ruby 1/18,
Crown 8/18 (104) days)
Celebrity 1, Chandris 1, Fathom Adonia 1 4/17, HAL 1 9/17,
Royal CI 2, (36 days) Total - 299 days

Upcoming:
Majestic Princess 10/18, Valor 2/19