Upcoming changes on Celebrity

Welcome to Cruise Critic! If you'd like to participate on our forums by joining in the conversation, please Register Now! Be sure to visit our FAMOUS Roll Call forums, where you can meet other cruisers sailing with you and share a tour or shore excursion and SAVE MONEY!

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts
BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
All times are GMT -4.
The time now is 10:40 AM.
Toronto, Ontario, Canada
637 Posts
Joined Sep 2002
While on our March 26th Summit cruise we learned that the menus will be changing in September. Sure hope they don't mess with our favourite French Potatoe Pie and the creme brulee. Also, due to the HUGE number of Captain's Club members, changes are in the air. We enjoyed the Elite cocktail party but when we got off the elevator and saw the horrendous line the next night for the regular Captain's Club cocktail party we left. We didn't need a free drink that bad! Also, the "Elite/Founder" check-in line at Embarkation was busier than the regular lines.
North Bay.Ont.,Canada
2,238 Posts
Joined Feb 2001
"HUGE number of CC members"...Wow, I never saw that coming!! Who would of thought that if you give out memberships for free a huge number of people would consent to take them...bet they all feel special now.



Zenith to Bermuda Oct/04
Century to E.Caribbean Feb/05
10,007 Posts
Joined Jul 2003

I agree with you. When we joined the Captain's Club there was a fee. Now that it's free, well you know the old saying, "you get what you pay for." So I guess we are going to be getting "nothing."

7 Night Eastern Carribean on Infinity

Big Red Boat II – New York to Canada/New England, August 2000
Regal Empress – New York to Canada/New England, August 2001
Millennium – 10 Night Southern Caribbean, August 2002
Millennium – 13 Night Mediterranean, August 2003
Infinity – Eastern Caribbean, April 2004

Jacksonville, FL USA
48,553 Posts
Joined Jan 2003
Hi maybe we were just on the right cruise..but had no trouble getting into the Captain's Club Cocktail Party...found a nice comfy area for the 6 of us to sit..met the Captain too .
And for disembarking....it was a breeze (for me anyway)...off the ship at 9:20...luggage was very easy to find...and the buses for the airport were right there------>.

Now, I will miss that French Potatoe Pie if they remove it from the menu

Next up...HORIZON Sept 18th to Bermuda!

See My Century and Mercury Pictures at:
New Jersey, USA
4,543 Posts
Joined Dec 2002
Hi Senga

We were on Summit on 3/15 and heard that the Elite members would be finally getting extras since at this point it's the top of the line and there are no incentives to continue sailing once you reach that level. I noticed that in one year's time from Millie that a lot more "perks" were added for Elite. Also, they separated the Captain's Club cocktail parties into early and late seatings on our sailing. It was fine. For a few years previously they had combined them to a party in between meal seatings. This worked out much better. I hope they do change some things on the menu and bring back some oldies but goodies.

Dolphin - 1990
Horizon - 1994, 1995, 1995
Century - 1997, 2000, 2001
Galaxy - 1998
Zenith - 1992, 1999, 2002
Millennium - 2003
Summit 2004
Summit 2005

Countdown to Summit 2005
Virginia, USA
2,962 Posts
Joined May 2000
Danno -- when I joined Captains Club we had to pay a fee. Now that it is free, are they reimbursing the fee to us and if so, how do we go about doing that
Staten Island, NY, USA
1,774 Posts
Joined Apr 2003

That's good to hear about the Captain's Club Party.I remember on our Millie cruise, they held it in the Revelations nightclub between the 2 sittings instead of holding it in the Theater. Big mistake!!!! Diners coming from First sitting were SRO while the second seating passengers were gulping down their drinks trying to get to the DIning Room. Splitting the 2 seatings is a great idea, especiallysince they Captain's Club has grown!

Now getting back to the topic on hand, I believe that they go over their menus every 6 months and see what moves and what doesn't. I would think something like the Potato Pie and the Creme Brulee would be safe. When taking the Galley tour, someone asked the executive chef about menu changes. He told us that there were at least 14 planned menus for any given week. Hey, it's better than the first years on Celebrity when you could predict what meal you were getting on what night,even if you sailed on a different ship in the same year!


And now Infinity 2005!
Millennium 2003
Century 2002
Summit 2001
Century 2000
Zenith 1996
Horizon 1994
Horizon 1993
Sunward 1992
Star Princess 1990
Maxim Gorky 1974 & 1975
2,248 Posts
Joined Mar 2004
In the Captain's Club newsletter Vol. II (2003) (can't remember exactly when we got it, I think it was in the Fall) there was a little note telling passengers that the fee had been eliminated, and the brochure included a coupon for a $50 shipboard credit that was supposed to offset the $35 you paid at one time. If you didn't get that, I would call and see what they're doing for people.
Pittsburgh, PA
1,220 Posts
Joined Oct 2003
It's time, man. You have to do it. Change your board name to "Cynic'.
When we got off our first cruise ship, the CC cost $35. No way! A month later, it's free...
Guess what? We joined immediately. A few months later, we were demanding our upgrade on a new booking.
Here is my point. 'GO WITH THE RULES."
The primary sponsor (owner) establishes the rules. They have the rights to change the rules. The users have to live by the rules.
I do agree with "no whining about the price you paid" if you were satisfied with "the price you paid."
997 Posts
Joined Sep 2002
I for one will be excited (ever the optimist) if the menus are indeed changing this fall. We have been blessed with four chances to cruise in the past 19 months and have now memorized the menus, to the point where, when our dear waiter last week on Mercury accidentally gave me the wrong menu one night, my husband took a glance at it, said "Oh, that's the menu for the LAST night," and handed it to the waiter, who said, "You certainly know our menus!" (And who can forget the ever-festive dish named "Red Cusk Congrio," anyway?) However, if it goes, I *will* miss the Jalapeno Cheese Polenta appetizer. FWIW.

Millennium 12/12/04
Mercury 4/04, Infinity 8/03, Century 3/03 & 9/02
4,220 Posts
Joined Aug 2001
We just got off the Galaxy on April 5th. Being Select CC members we were invited on the Galley Tour, and the Food Manager Hans had told us that the new menus would include more low fat and low carb selections. Many in our group applauded. Hopefully they'll keep all the old favorites too, but being a "carb-watcher" I'll be eager to see what this new menu includes.


SAILING THE GALAXY IN: <img src=http://escati.linkopp.net/cgi-bin/countdown.cgi?trgb=000000&prgb=0000CC&cdt=2005;03; 21;20;0;00&timezone=GMT-0800> <Marquee direction=left width=45%>Fantasy/97~~~Mercury/98~~~Century/99~~~Splendour/00~~~Zenith/01~~~Summit/02~~~Galaxy/03~~~Galaxy/04~~~Galaxy/05</Marquee>

Lake Norman
1,268 Posts
Joined Sep 2001
"Carb watcher"...what could be worse other than perhaps a reformed smoker! Your diet is fine but I can see it putting a serious damper on us "fat freedom fighters". Fat lovers unite!!! McDonalds is even joining the lunacy. Where will it end; next thing you know, Wal-Mart will only allow customers in the door who pass a weight test....and airlines will cut another 1" off the width of their seats!!

************************************************** ****
With Compassion for others we build...we fight for peace and freedom
Virginia, USA
2,962 Posts
Joined May 2000
Warmwinds -- thanks for the reply -- I must have missed the coupon and will call Captains Club to see what they will do for us.

Regarding menus, I will apparently eat anything they put in front of me and so will hubby. The distinction between eating at home and eating on the cruise is so great I don't think I would ever "tire" of a particular menu, but then, I can only cruise once a year.

4,220 Posts
Joined Aug 2001
Sorry you feel like that Seabee. There are some of us who would rather not watch carbs or our weight, but Dr.’s orders. I was having severe health problems. On our cruises I eat regularly, but pay for it for weeks when I return. As long as I watch the carbs my “insides” behave. Otherwise I’m one sick cookie. I assure you I’m not out to change the world, just my problems.


SAILING THE GALAXY IN: <img src=http://escati.linkopp.net/cgi-bin/countdown.cgi?trgb=000000&prgb=0000CC&cdt=2005;03; 21;20;0;00&timezone=GMT-0800> <Marquee direction=left width=45%>Fantasy/97~~~Mercury/98~~~Century/99~~~Splendour/00~~~Zenith/01~~~Summit/02~~~Galaxy/03~~~Galaxy/04~~~Galaxy/05</Marquee>

The Bluegrass State
1,209 Posts
Joined Aug 2003
trcori and Jan,

I, too, am glad to see some changes. Got flamed the last time I mentioned it. The food does taste great, but one would like a change after a couple of cruises. It begins to taste the same (especially on a longer trip). Some alternative for low carb, etc are great and am sure they will still provide us with the tasty, high calorie sweets when we crave them!
442 Posts
Joined Sep 2003
I LOVE the food on Celeb, but since we cruise twice a yr....a change would be nice. We have our favs, but it would be nice to change some of the entree's....CHANGE is good.
New York
5,227 Posts
Joined Jan 2000
Ya know.........

We were on in Jan. The food was great!

But....it was not the foo-foo shi-shi orgasmic extravaganza that the line tries to make it sound like it is! We were a little disappointed. Not with the food itself, but more with the fact that we were expecting "more". It was not like dining in the Queen's grill on "QE2", which is what we were almost expecting, the way they carry on about how head and shoulders above the rest they are. We are pretty loyal to "X", but prior to January '04 we had not been on for 2 years. As far as the past cruisers club for a fee vs. no fee. I never understood why they would offer a loyaly perk, but for a price.
Virginia, USA
2,962 Posts
Joined May 2000
Okay -- for the record -- hubby and I are on a low carb "diet" -- actually, way of life. But, have you ever had Summit's french fries??? They are to die for -- and the ice cream???? HMMM -- anyway, only gained three pounds on our cruise in March. Hubby conceded and had only ONE entree at dinner each night .

Marco - can' compare QE2 to Summit, because haven't been on QE2, but I bet you paid alot more money for your cruise than we did, based on what they want for the QM2. It should have been better (for the money). But, you will never hear me complain about the food on Summit!

I'll talk to CC about getting that on-board coupon reimbursement.
Petite Riviere, Nova Scotia, Canada
84 Posts
Joined Mar 2002
As for the Captains Club, we paid the fee to join a few years ago and used the $50 coupon on The Mar. 26 sailing. We didn't see any problem with the group size as the early and late seatings were at different times. We always thought the CC events were Celebrity's thank you to their repeat customers and larger groups shows the satisfaction of their customers to return. As they get more repeaters they may have to schedule different events but that wouldn't be a bad thing.