Michigan Takes the Liberty 03/31/12 (Eastern) Two Minute Review

Welcome to Cruise Critic! If you'd like to participate on our forums by joining in the conversation, please Register Now! Be sure to visit our FAMOUS Roll Call forums, where you can meet other cruisers sailing with you and share a tour or shore excursion and SAVE MONEY!

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts
BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
All times are GMT -4.
The time now is 08:05 AM.
#1
Michigan
425 Posts
Joined Oct 2007
My detailed review with lots of pics will follow, but here is the quick list for those going soon:

Ports: HMC: still paradise Cabana #8 was in a perfect place, St.Thomas: beautiful, Fury Charters Sail and Snorkel was fabulous, San Juan: Interesting, cultural and Olde World Charm, Grand Turk: not much to see outside of the Port Cruise center...Cruisett pretty much worthless for establishing port load

Ship Life: 2.0 upgrades were all worthwhile but left lido deck quite a bit more crowded, chair hogs out very early on sea days (I became one on second sea day, ya ya flame-away), waiters room stewards bar staff cruise directors were all excellent and very accommodating

Lido Life: DJ Electra was great for the 21- crowd, but really needs to mix up her mix for the rest of us (Party Rock and the Wobble song still ringing in my ears incessantly), pools crowded, water slide quick, very clean

Food: Guys burgers good to great, Blue Iguana Cantina was very good, Diamond Steakhouse awesome, Dining room noticeable quality reduction, Breakfast Buffet was not good except for Omlette station, Dinner Buffet was institutional at best....

Entertainment: Adult comedy was hit or miss....two were very good, two were ok, where did the Filipino rock bands go (miss Blood Power) casino 4 piece average, stage shows were same old, ventiloquist was very good, towel show was good, stage band and female singer were quite good. Alchemy bar looked great and well attended, Piano bar was good for a one-timer, Cruise directors Jaime(f) and Christian were good to great and not annoying

Ride/Weather: Substantial swells between San Juan and Grand Turk, cool thunderstorm on way to Miami at sea that we sailed right through, poured rain at embarkation, and HMC before tendering, but 80-87 and sunny in all of the ports (could not have hoped for better)

Embark/Debark: Seamless....at port at 10:30 and on board by 11:30....back at 7AM and off ship by 8:15

Luggage Express: Worked perfectly as it was intended, however, had I known that we had to meet and get off the ship at 8AM for a 1PM flight out of MIA I would have skipped the $20 per person and just did self assist as we had a 4 hour airport wait.

We will do Carnival again, but hope that they go back to adding some dining quality back into the core offerings. The addition of Guy's and Blue Iguana are welcome changes however I agree with many others that the main dining offerings have slipped in terms of flavor and quality.

Any quickfire questions...ask away....big review will follow soon...
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
RCL Soverign of the Seas -Bahamas -1991
RCL Nordic Empress - Bahamas - March 1999
RCL Majesty of the Seas - Bahamas - Nov 2000
RCL Monarch of the Seas- Bahamas - Nov 2004
CCL Carnival Spirit -Hawaii/TransPacific- Oct 2007
CCL Carnival Destiny- E Caribbean - Nov 2009
CCL Carnival Valor-W Caribbean - Apr 2011
CCL Carnival Liberty 2.0-E Caribbean- Apr 2012
CCL Carnival Valor-Southern Caribbean- Apr 2014

CCL Carnival Breeze-Western Caribbean- Apr 2016


We Have the Cruising Bug!
#6
Zeeland, MI
455 Posts
Joined Jan 2010
We are from Michigan as well and going on the Liberty for spring break 2013. Was wondering if you booked the St. Thomas excursion through the cruise line or on your own?
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
#8
Carolina
8,695 Posts
Joined Aug 2006
Thanks for the quick summary! Can't wait to see your pictures!
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature



2/10/18 Summit (Smooth Jazz Cruise)
10/29/17 Vista (Halloween)
10/29/16 Conquest (Halloween)
2/21/16 Eurodam (Smooth Jazz Cruise)
9/19/15 Victory (5 days with friends)
1/8/15 Eurodam (Smooth Jazz Cruise)
11/8/14 Breeze (Feelin' the Breeze Part 2)
1/12/14 Eurodam (Smooth Jazz Cruise)
10/10/13 Victory B2B (Victory is Mine)[/font]
1/13/13 Westerdam (Smooth Jazz Cruise)
11/24/12 Breeze (Feelin' the Breeze)
1/15/12 Westerdam (Smooth Jazz Cruise)
12/4/11 Miracle (x-mas on the beach)
1/16/11 Noordam (Smooth Jazz Cruise)
9/18/10 Fantasy
9/20/09 Sensation
11/08 Westerdam (Dave Koz & Friends)
2008 Caribbean Princess
10/2/06 Celebration
10/9/05 Destiny
2002 Costa Cruise Line
#9
Michigan
425 Posts
Joined Oct 2007
Originally posted by mimxmom
We are from Michigan as well and going on the Liberty for spring break 2013. Was wondering if you booked the St. Thomas excursion through the cruise line or on your own?
direct with fury and capt. mike....just do a google search.....well worth it
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
RCL Soverign of the Seas -Bahamas -1991
RCL Nordic Empress - Bahamas - March 1999
RCL Majesty of the Seas - Bahamas - Nov 2000
RCL Monarch of the Seas- Bahamas - Nov 2004
CCL Carnival Spirit -Hawaii/TransPacific- Oct 2007
CCL Carnival Destiny- E Caribbean - Nov 2009
CCL Carnival Valor-W Caribbean - Apr 2011
CCL Carnival Liberty 2.0-E Caribbean- Apr 2012
CCL Carnival Valor-Southern Caribbean- Apr 2014

CCL Carnival Breeze-Western Caribbean- Apr 2016


We Have the Cruising Bug!