Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts
BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
All times are GMT -4.
The time now is 03:33 AM.
#1
Wisconsin
21 Posts
Joined Jun 2013
We have a balcony reserved for our cruise. We are not smokers. If by chance we end up surrounded by smokers with it coming over/up to us and bothering us do we have any recourse? I hate to "control" someone else, but I don't want to be "controlled" by their habit either. I would like to be able to enjoy my balcony too.

Really hoping not to have a problem but wondering about other peoples experiences with this.
#2
2,600 Posts
Joined Apr 2011
Originally posted by Billy overboard
We have a balcony reserved for our cruise. We are not smokers. If by chance we end up surrounded by smokers with it coming over/up to us and bothering us do we have any recourse? I hate to "control" someone else, but I don't want to be "controlled" by their habit either. I would like to be able to enjoy my balcony too.

Really hoping not to have a problem but wondering about other peoples experiences with this.
You will be flamed, flamed and flamed some more....

I decided to not get bothered by smokers and only book OV's or Spa balconies after being flamed here on CC...
#3
West Melbourne, FL
1,278 Posts
Joined Jul 2007
You really have no recourse as Carnival allows smoking on the balcony. You knew this before booking (or should have) so you should have educated yourself by exploring other options as the poster above me stated.

But with all of my cruises I have never been smoked out (or off) my balcony.
#4
Wisconsin
21 Posts
Joined Jun 2013
actually I didn't know that one side was preferred in regards to smoking over the other, I may call and try and change sides due to that. I also would point out that you aren't asked about your smoking preference when you make a reservation. And no place in the reservation process does it say that one side or the other is designated smoking.

However why does their "right" to enjoy their balcony as they wish superceed my "right" to enjoy my balcony. I am not doing anything on my balcony that has the possibility of leaking over to another balcony.

I understand that people choose to smoke, and I know they can choose to that that to their hearts content in designated areas. I avoid those areas. I know that if I go to the cigar bar, or the casino I will have to accept that there is smoking allowed there. I can choose to avoid those areas or not, my choice. But if people are smoking "onto" my balcony it doesn't give me any choice now does it.

I am not trying to start a war, I am just looking for ideas of how to handle a potential problem, for me, better armed in advance than unprepared. Based upon the research I am doing I am probably going to bring ear plugs in case noise bothers me.
#5
AZ
4,292 Posts
Joined Jun 2002
Realistically at this point, if you find yourself with neighboring smokers the only thing you can do is talk to them and try to come to some agreement regarding when they smoke on the balcony so you can avoid it. If they are not amenable, then as others have said you're pretty much out of luck. Balconies are one of the few remaining places smokers can indulge on-board.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
"What we've got here is... failure to communicate."
#6
Missouri via Portland OR
6,644 Posts
Joined Feb 2005
It's pretty unlikely that a smoker will be out on their balcony 24/7.

Like others have said, if you have a smoker next to you and it's bothersome, have a polite conversation. You might be surprised.

It won't do any good to change sides of the ship. Both sides are smoking when it comes to balconies.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Mona





Liberty 02/08/15 (Grand Turk, (missed) San Juan, St Maarten)
Legend 05/11/14 (Cozumel, Belize, Roatan, Grand Cayman)
Liberty 09/14/13 (HMC, St Thomas, San Juan, Grand Turk)
Valor 02/04/12 (St Thomas, Antigua, Tortola, Nassau)
Valor 05/09/10 (Grand Cayman, Roatan, Belize, Cozumel)
Valor 09/13/09 (Grand Cayman, Roatan, Belize, Cozumel)
Glory 05/16/09 (Cozumel, Costa Maya, Belize, Nassau....I mean Nassau, St Thomas St Maarten...Thanks H1N1)
Destiny 02/09/09 (Nassau, Half Moon Cay, Grand Turk) Pics: http://photobucket.com/Destiny2009
Liberty 09/13/08 (Cozumel, Grand Cayman, Ocho Rios)
Legend 05/11/08 (Grand Cayman, Cozumel, Belize, Roatan)
Glory 09/08/07 (Cozumel, Costa Maya, Belize, Nassau....I mean Nassau, Cozumel, Key West, Progreso...Thanks Dean)
Valor 5/13/07 (Grand Cayman, Belize, Roatan, Costa Maya)
Valor 9/10/06 (Nassau, St Thomas, St Maarten)
Victory 5/7/06 (Grand Cayman, Costa Maya, Ocho Rios)
Destiny 05/01/05 (San Juan, Dominica, Aruba, Barbados, St Thomas)
Destiny Capers/Photos: http://community.webshots.com/user/monakenny
Elation 05/09/2004 (Progreso, Belize, Cozumel)
Victory 05/11/2003 (Grand Cayman, Cozumel, Ocho Rios)
Ecstacy 05/18/1998 (Key West, Cozumel)
#7
U.S.
6,194 Posts
Joined May 2006
Originally posted by Billy overboard
We have a balcony reserved for our cruise. We are not smokers. If by chance we end up surrounded by smokers with it coming over/up to us and bothering us do we have any recourse? I hate to "control" someone else, but I don't want to be "controlled" by their habit either. I would like to be able to enjoy my balcony too.

Really hoping not to have a problem but wondering about other peoples experiences with this.
Hey, Billy. It does seem like non-smokers might as well not book a balcony anymore because the smokers flock to them since they can't smoke in the cabins now. Ditto for the casino. It's very smoky too. Sorry, but there isn't much recourse that I can think of if you're already booked unless you can upgrade to a spa balcony cabin or ask to change to a forward balcony if possible where when the ship is moving the smoke will blow aft. Once onboard, there isn't much you can do since the ship will likely be full and changes impossible. Maybe in time Carnival will reconsider their policy that exposes non-smoking passengers and their employees to unhealthy smoke. Carnival needs those enclosed smoking booths like they have at the airports. :-)

You'll likely be flamed incessantly here on this board though.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
40 's and counting. Next up: Carnival Dream.
#8
Boston,Mass
2,124 Posts
Joined Dec 2006
Originally posted by Billy overboard
actually I didn't know that one side was preferred in regards to smoking over the other, I may call and try and change sides due to that. I also would point out that you aren't asked about your smoking preference when you make a reservation. And no place in the reservation process does it say that one side or the other is designated smoking.

However why does their "right" to enjoy their balcony as they wish superceed my "right" to enjoy my balcony. I am not doing anything on my balcony that has the possibility of leaking over to another balcony.

I understand that people choose to smoke, and I know they can choose to that that to their hearts content in designated areas. I avoid those areas. I know that if I go to the cigar bar, or the casino I will have to accept that there is smoking allowed there. I can choose to avoid those areas or not, my choice. But if people are smoking "onto" my balcony it doesn't give me any choice now does it.

I am not trying to start a war, I am just looking for ideas of how to handle a potential problem, for me, better armed in advance than unprepared. Based upon the research I am doing I am probably going to bring ear plugs in case noise bothers me.
They do not have smoking or non smoking sides in regards to the balconies, that pertains to the open deck, where one side is smoking and the other is smoking.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
1.RCCL-Majesty of The Seas- 3/04-My 1st cruise.
2.Carnival- Facination 2/07-1st solo cruise
3.Carnival- Facination 9/07-2nd solo cruise
4.Carnival-Imagination 6/08-Grandma/Grandaughter cruise
5.Carnival Victory 9/26/10-3rd solo cruise
6.Carnival Victory 9/18/11- Girls Cruise.
7.Carnival Liberty 8/25/12 -Grandma/grandaughter cruise pt2
8.Carnival Liberty 2/9/13 4th solo cruise for my 50th birthday.
9.Carnival Freedom 8/10/13 Grandma/Grandaughter cruise Pt3-my first suite!-Premier Cruise
10.Carnival Freedom 8/18/13 My first b2b
11.Carnival Breeze 11/9/13 Platinum Cruise and 5th solo cruise.- Premier Cruise
12.Carnival Freedom 12/9/13 6th solo cruise- Premier Cruise.
#9
Massachusetts
1,529 Posts
Joined Mar 2011
As another poster said, they won't be out there 24/7.

I just got off Valor a few weeks ago and my DH smokes. He only went out on balcony very briefly to smoke only a couple of times. For the most part, people are out and about most of the day.

I am sure it will be fine...and ship is moving and wind is blowing if you are at sea.

Just be thankful you didn't have what we had...group of loud drunks blowing on life jacket whistles out on balcony next to us when we were in our cabin trying to sleep and blasting their music..thank GOD it was only for a couple of hours on very last day. I know I couldn't tolerate that all week.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
SAILED TO OVER 20 PORTS ON:
Carnival: Holiday ** Destiny ** Freedom ** Valor ** Breeze ** Sunshine ** Magic
RCCL: Radiance of the Seas ** Allure of the Seas
Princess: Ruby Princess ** Regal Princess
NCL: Southward ** Escape


UPCOMING....


#10
Taylor, TX
584 Posts
Joined Jun 2010
I've never smelled anything worse than s faint whiff of smoke. Walking through the casino is much worse.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
GeckoGal

Magic - October 2012
Elation - July 2012
Triumph - April 2012

Triumph - October 2011
Conquest - April 2011
Conquest - August 2010
Conquest - May 2009
#11
Raleigh, NC
25 Posts
Joined Jan 2008
My wife and I are smokers and here is our own personal policies regarding smoking on the balcony. And, from what we've seen, most people seem to follow something similarly.
  1. We try not to smoke too much when in port, especially if the wind is down.
  2. We generally don't sit out there for much longer than to have one smoke then go back to what we were doing.
  3. We always bring a brand new travel ashtray with a lid. This keeps the butts from flying off.
  4. We never let the cigarette hang out over the balcony rail. This helps keep ashes from flying.
Now that's not to say you won't end up near someone who doesn't do these things but I think it's rare. You might get a whiff of some cigarette smoke but it won't be over bearing or long lasting. Now the casino might be too much if you're sensitive to smoke. If so, you might want to steer clear of that area.



My advice is to not focus too much on it and enjoy your cruise!!
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature


Carnival Vista 6/2017
Carnival Dream 6/2016
Carnival Breeze 7/2015
Carnival Breeze 6/2013
Carnival Valor 7/2012
Carnival Dream 4/2011
Freedom of the Seas 10/2008
Carnival Valor 3/2008
Carnival Imagination 6/2002
#12
Montreal / Stowe
4,691 Posts
Joined Apr 2010
Here is my solution - When you want a balcony, book Celebrity. Frankly if you really really hate smoke, book Celebrity.
Enjoying our balcony on the Summit was such a pleasure to say nothing of the smoke free casino and almost everywhere else.

DW and I will hesitate before booking a balcony on any other cruise brand. This is not specific to Carnival.

One smoker several balcony's away can really spoil breakfast on the balcony.
I don't want to pay the balcony premium just to be annoyed. Still waiting for one side of cruise ships to be non-smoking.
And waiting.

Sorry - just needed to vent.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Carnival Pride -January/2011 Bahamas
RCL Mariner -July/2011 E Mediterranean
Carnival Fascination -January/2012 Bahamas
Celebrity Summit -March/2013 S Caribbean
Carnival Glory -July/2013 Canada/New England
Celebrity Constellation -March/2014 Caribbean
Princess Regal -March/2015 Caribbean
HAL Veendam -July/2015 Canada/New England
NCL Epic -July/2016 Mediterranean
HAL Veendam -July/2017 Bermuda
#13
Montréal, Canada!
4,940 Posts
Joined Oct 2010
Originally posted by solesman
My wife and I are smokers and here is our own personal policies regarding smoking on the balcony. And, from what we've seen, most people seem to follow something similarly.
  1. We try not to smoke too much when in port, especially if the wind is down.
  2. We generally don't sit out there for much longer than to have one smoke then go back to what we were doing.
  3. We always bring a brand new travel ashtray with a lid. This keeps the butts from flying off.
  4. We never let the cigarette hang out over the balcony rail. This helps keep ashes from flying.
Now that's not to say you won't end up near someone who doesn't do these things but I think it's rare. You might get a whiff of some cigarette smoke but it won't be over bearing or long lasting. Now the casino might be too much if you're sensitive to smoke. If so, you might want to steer clear of that area.



My advice is to not focus too much on it and enjoy your cruise!!

Well said
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Past cruises:
Carnival Vista - Repo - November 2016
Carnival Conquest - December 2015
Carnival Breeze - September 2014
NCL Epic - November 2013 *Review*
Carnival Liberty - November 2012
Carnival Liberty - March 2012
Carnival Liberty - November 2010
Carnival Valor - November 2008

Coming up!






Group website: https://sites.google.com/view/carniv...ys-cruise/home
#14
Maryland
2,048 Posts
Joined Sep 2009
Princess no longer allows balcony smoking either.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Denise

Caribbean Princess - January 2012
Carnival Pride - Bahamas, October 2009
Carnival Sensation - E. Caribbean, December 1993
#15
Sanbornton, NH
73 Posts
Joined Aug 2012
I'm a smoker and my DW is not. She has asthma and several other issues. I have never had a problem with my neighbors due to my smoking a few cigs during the day or night. My DW had issues on our last cruise when the cigars came out next door and she went back in the room. I think the worst thing is the loudness of people at night, as in Music and parties and swearing and people hanging off their balconies at port cat-calling and just not respectful with the language used. I will keep on booking balconies for many more cruises to come. I agree with above, book a room forward enough that chances of smoke blowing downwind is less.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
6/22/1980 Mardi Gras (First Honeymoon).
2/14/2009 Carnival Destiny GRAND CAYMAN/OCHO RIO (Second Honeymoon)
1/31/2010 Carnival Valor EXOTIC WESTERN CARIB (First Anniversary).
1/29/2012 Carnival Glory EXOTIC EASTERN CARIB (Third Anniversary) And Cruised with my Bro & Di.
1/27/2013 Carnival Victory SOUTHERN CARIBBEAN (Fourth Anniversary).
1/26/2014 Carnival Valor SOUTHERN CARIBBEAN (Fifth Anniversary).
2/1/2015 Carnival Dream. (Sixth Anniversary) on Super Bowl Sunday which is our Anniversary (AND THE PATS WON). Six years ago, married at 4PM and Super Bowl Party @ 6:00PM.
Jan 31, 2016 Carnival Splendor. 7 Day to Eastern Caribbean. (Seventh Anniversary).
#16
PA
102 Posts
Joined Oct 2008
We have only ever had balconies and I never remember being bothered by smoke. Maybe we have just been lucky. We really aren't out there to much when the ship isn't moving. The casino is really bad, but I can take it.
#17
92 Posts
Joined Jun 2012
recourse, dont complain about smokers having an open area in the back on one side of the ship to smoke. dont take away our few smoking areas so we are forced to only smoke on our balcony. i try to be polite but our areas are VERY limited
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
2015 (booked) Carnival Dream, Roatan, Cozumel, Belize
2014 Carnival Dream, Jamaica, Cozumel, Grand Cayman
2013 Carnival Liberty, Half Moon Cay, St. Thomas, Puerto Rico, Grand Turk
2012 Carnival Splendor, Puerto Vallarta, CaboX2
2010 Carnival Splendor, Puerto Vallarta, Mazatlan, Cabo
2007 RCC Monarch of the Seas, Catalina, Ensenada
2004 RCC Monarch of the Seas, Catalina, Ensenada
1980 Carnival Mardi Gras, Nassau, St Thomas, Puerto Rico
#18
Worcester,Massachusetts
596 Posts
Joined Dec 2011
This has become a growing problem. And its not just smoking, if a person might be denied doing something. Regardless of how it effects the rights of others his/her right to do it wins out.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
2004 Carnival Imagintion - Grand Cayman -
Ocho Rio Jamica
2006 Carnival Valor - Nassau - St. Thomas -
St. Maarten
2008 Carnival Liberty-Cozumel-Limon Costa Rica-
Colon Panama
2010 Carnival Spirit-Acapulco-Zihuatanjo/Ixtapa-
Manzanillo
2012 Carnival Freedom-Cozumel-Limon Costa Rica-
Colon Panama
2014 Carnival Freedom-St. Thomas-Antigua-Tortola-Nassau
2016 Carnival Sunshine-Aruba-Curacao-Grand Turk
2018 Carnival Vista- Grand Turk- San Juan- St. Kitts- St. Marrten
#19
Yellowknife, Canada
1,013 Posts
Joined Jul 2007
I believe booking a Spa balcony cabin would be the way for a non smoker to go as there is no smoking allowed on those balconies. Unfortunately, the complaining from the non smokers over the years has led to more and more public areas being marked as "Non Smoking", forcing the smokers to smoke on their balconies.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Carnival Pride Sept. '07 Puerto Vallarta, Mazatlan, Cabo San Lucas
Carnival Miracle Jan. '09 St.Marten, St.Kitt's,Tortola
Carnival Freedom Oct. '10 Key West,Grand Cayman,Ocho Rios
Carnival Freedom Oct. '10 San Juan,St.Thomas,Antigua,Tortola,Nassau
Carnival Miracle Nov.'11 St. Maarten, St. Kitts, St. Lucia
Carnival Liberty Oct.'12 Cozumel, Belize, Mahogany Bay, Roatan, Grand Cayman
Carnival Liberty Oct.'12 Half Moon Cay, St.Thomas, San Juan, GrandTurk
Carnival Breeze Nov.'13 Grand Turk, Dominican Rep, Curacao, Aruba
Carnival Breeze Nov.'13 Grand Turk, Ocho Rios, Nassau
Carnival Pride Repo Mar.'15 Grand Cayman, Limon Costa Rica, Colon Panama, Aruba, Bonaire, St.Maarten
Carnival Vista Dec.'16Grand Turk, Aruba, Bonaire, LaRomana
#20
Tucson, Arizona and San Carlos, Mexico
4,260 Posts
Joined Jul 2009
I'm very sensitive to smoke and never have been bothered by someone smoking on the balcony. I always have an aftwrap suite on Carnival and there definitely is no problem there. On my HAL cruises, the breeze took any smoke away.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature




2016, Carnival Miracle, Mexican Riviera
2016, Carnival Miracle, Mexican Riviera
2014, Carnival Legend, Long Beach to Sydney
2014, Carnival Miracle, Mexican Riviera
2012, Oasis of the Seas, Eastern Caribbean
2012, Noordam, Southern Caribbean
2012, Carnival Legend, Western Caribbean
2011, Carnival Legend, Western Caribbean
2011, Carnival Legend, Western Caribbean
2011, Rotterdam, Peru to Fort Lauderdale
2011, Royal Princess, French Polynesia
2010-2011, Carnival Spirit, Mexican Riviera
2010, Noordam, Southern Caribbean
2009, Maasdam, Western Caribbean
1989, Stardancer, Mexican Riviera
1989, Regent Star, Panama Canal/Caribbean
1988, Noordam, Alaska
1972, Italy to Greece