Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts
BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
All times are GMT -4.
The time now is 05:59 PM.
#1
3 Posts
Joined Jan 2018
We are wanting to do either a 5 or 7 day cruise with 2 adults and 4 children. Can you help with which one is best—5 or 7 day??
#3
Carolina Coast
3,893 Posts
Joined Jul 2011
By 5 days we;re just totally comfortable with the ins and outs of the ship and totally enjoy the final 2 days.
In 2016 We did a 7 day and a separate 5 day on the Sunshine. Five days was over too early
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Smooth Sailing -- Summersigh
HAL–Ryndam–Alaska 2006 Cunard–QM2–TA 2008 HAL–Westerdam–ECarib-Xmas 2009
CCL–Fascination–Bahamas 2010 RCCL–Enchantment OTS–NE/Can 2011 RRCL-FreedomOTS-WCarib-2012 CCL-Legend-ExoticWest-2013 HAL–Westerdam–EasCarib-2013 RCCL-GrandeurOTS-Bermuda-2014 HAL–Eurodam–WestCarib-2015 CCL-Sunshine-EastCarib-Jan 2016 and-May 2016 HAL–Zuiderdam–PC–Dec 2016 ** 2017 cancelled due to health issues :-( CCL-Elation-Eastern-May 2018 CCL-Breeze-Dec 2018
#5
Florida
579 Posts
Joined Dec 2017
I'm no expert cruiser, but the two Carnival cruises I have been on were 4 day and 3 day, and both were far, far, too short - 5 days wouldn't be long enough, for me. Which is why we booked an 8 day cruise for late 2018.

But, in both cases I was traveling with another adult, no kids. You may find that after 5 days the kids are bored silly and you will wish you had bought the Cheers package. So it probably depends more on how well your kids travel/cruise. Age ranges obviously are an impact.
#6
Baton Rouge
980 Posts
Joined Jun 2016
We've always done 7 days. Our two kids are 8 and 7 right now, and we've been taking them on cruises since the oldest was only 7 months old. Camp Carnival (Camp Ocean) is great, and the kids love it. Neither of them has ever been bored.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Upcoming Cruises:
11/18/18: NCL Breakaway (Coz, Belize, Harvest Caye, Costa Maya)
5/23/19: NCL Jade (European Cruise)

Past Cruises:
7/28/18: RC Majesty of the Seas (KW, Cuba)
6/10/18: Carnival Dream (MoBay, GC, Cozumel)
11/19/17: Carnival Dream (KW, Freeport, Nassau)
6/3/17: NCL Escape (St Thomas, Tortola, Nassau)
5/28/16: RC Adventure of the Seas
10/26/14: Carnival Dream
11/9/13: Carnival Conquest
10/1/11: Carnival Ecstasy
5/15/11: Carnival Victory
2/7/10: NCL Spirit
3/2/08: NCL Spirit
5/20/07: RC Adventure of the Seas
5/30/04: Carnival Conquest
7/7/02: Carnival Elation
5/27/01: Carnival Destiny
#7
1,786 Posts
Joined Jan 2012
5 day is sea day, port, port, sea day and over. What happened? But 7 day seems pretty short to me too. I know that the 7 days I have been on is a much less of a party atmosphere and you can get to nicer ports in the 7 day time frame.
#8
Charlotte, NC
11,120 Posts
Joined Nov 2004
Never been on a cruise shorter than 7 days. Weekend embarkations mean you only need to take 5 days off work. Your travel expenses to the embarkation port are the same no matter how many days the cruise is, so why not spread that travel cost over more cruise days?
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
08/18 Carnival Fascination | 04/12 NCL Spirit | 01/11 Carnival Liberty | 08/10 NCL Pride of America | 11/09 Carnival Miracle | 8/08 NCL Pearl | 5/08 NCL Majesty | 3/07 Celebrity Mercury | 9/06 Elation | 3/06 Carnival Valor | 2/05 NCL Majesty | 11/03 Jubilee | 9/01 Holiday
#9
Maryland
45 Posts
Joined Dec 2014
Another thing to keep in mind if you like the lobster in the MDR- there is no longer lobster served in the MDR on 5 day cruises. 7 is short enough for me, I’d just be getting unpacked on a 5 day. Lol


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
#10
Washington, DC
953 Posts
Joined Aug 2010
I find the shorter cruises exhausting because there's not enough downtime after the ports. It's just go, go, go and d then you're home!
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature

Carnival Fantasy '95
Carnival Ecstasy '10
Carnival Paradise '12
Carnival Magic '13
Carnival Pride '14
Carnival Pride '15 (First time to HMC!!!)
Carnival Breeze '16
#11
44 Posts
Joined Nov 2017
Spring break, bachelor/bachelorette party... 5 days

Family .... 7 days.

As others have said, 5 is just so short. The only alternative is if you bundled the 5 day cruise with a few beach days or a Disney/universal experience. Doing that drives the cost up tho.

I did a 11 day two years ago. And a 5 day last year (after spending a weekend in Orlando for wresltelmania... don't judge).

We are ding an 8 day this month, and going to New Orleans in April for a long weekend for... (don't judge) wrestlemania.

The cost could go up if you do the 5 day/other 2-3 day activities, but I could see a scenario where that is actually more enjoyable for the kiddos
#12
New Mexico
2,407 Posts
Joined Sep 2014
I would like to ask a few questions first.....


where do you live? Will you be driving or flying to port?
what types of activities do you like to do?
what are the kids ages?

I think these questions will help make a realistic recommendation.

robin
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Our cruises: https://rnrtackett.smugmug.com/Cruises
Our full photo site: https://rnrtackett.smugmug.com/
All my videos: https://vimeo.com/user466791

Next cruise: Carnival VISTA - Apr 2019
Last cruise: Carnival Glory - May 2018: https://rnrtackett.smugmug.com/Cruis...Carnival-Glory
All Previous: Carnival Freedom (2x), Magic (2x), Liberty, Glory, Legend Alaska, Breeze.
#15
Scarborough ON Canada
4,193 Posts
Joined Jan 2010
Carnival also offers 6 days cruises (some of the ships do 6 day then 8 day cruises).

Longer is generally better; however, for us the ship also matters. If your choice was a 7 day on a Fantasy class ship or a 5 day on say the Vista, with kids I would be included to do the 5 night on the ship with more for them to do.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Patricia (Trisha to my friends and family) cruiseforfood.com
Disney:
Magic 10-30-2010
Dream 10-30-2011 & 11-03-2011
Magic 4-30-2012
Fantasy 10-26-2013
Magic 11-15-2015
Carnival:
Dream 3-12-2011 & 3-19-2011
Miracle 8-26-2011
Dream 10-27-2012
Pride 03-15-2015
Pride 01-17-2016 & 01-28-2016
Pride 07-10-2016
Pride 08-21-2016
Sunshine 05-29-2017
Pride 01-07-2018
Royal:
Explorer of the Seas 2-24-2013
Explorer of the Seas 2-23-2014
Navigator of the Sea 11-10-2015
Freedom of the Seas 02-12-2017
Celebrity:
Summit 06-01-2014
Equinox 11-21-2014
Summit 08-30-3015
Summit 02-18-2017

Princess:
Caribbean Princess 11-20-2017

Future Cruises:
Adventure of the Seas 05-18-2018 (7 nights) A Cheap getaway
Caribbean Princess 11-25-2018 (14 nights) Circle Caribbean
Caribbean Princess 12-10-2018 (10 nights) Partial Panama Canal
Caribbean Princess 12-19-2018 (14 nights) Circle Caribbean
Celebrity Infinity 01-05-2019 (5 nights) Because we're already in Florida
Carnival Sunshine 01-12-2019 (13 nights) Journey Cruise
Disney Fantasy 01-26-2019 (7 nights) Stars Wars at Sea
Disney Magic 02-03-2019 (5 nights) Marvel Day at Sea
#16
643 Posts
Joined Mar 2017
We have done the 5 and the 7 day. We enjoy the 7 day more as the 5 day you feel like you are just getting in and then go home again. However alot depends on how much time you have and what kind of deal you can find.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Upcoming:



Past Cruises:
Carnival Freedom- 7 day, November 18, 2017-Cruise Review
Carnival Freedom- 7 day, July 22, 2017-Cruise Review
Carnival Triumph- 5 day, July 30, 2012
Carnival Conquest- 7 day, July 22, 2007
#17
1,659 Posts
Joined Jan 2005
Originally posted by Julesn6
We are wanting to do either a 5 or 7 day cruise with 2 adults and 4 children. Can you help with which one is best—5 or 7 day??
If time and money are no object, go with the 7 day.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
9/11/05 - Carnival Miracle - 1st Cruise!!! (5 stars)
12/10/06 - Carnival Destiny - Family Cruise (4 stars)
1/17/09 - RCCL Serenade of the Seas - Family Cruise (5 stars)
4/17/15 - Carnival Valor - Family Cruise (5 stars)
4/24/16 - Carnival Conquest - Couples Cruise (4 stars)
4/22/17 - Carnival Vista - Couples Cruise (5 stars)
4/21/18 - Carnival Glory - Family Cruise (5 stars)




#18
601 Posts
Joined Jan 2017
I don't have a recommendation, but I feel the need to present an opposing viewpoint.

I like short cruises. They are usually cheaper than 7 days. I can usually go on two 4 or 5 day cruises for the price of one 7 day cruise. I cruise solo or with my mom.

My first cruise was on the Jubilee. I was 13. It was my mom, dad, and me. We were on a group cruise with some of my dad's Knights of Columbus friends. I had fun, and that ship didn't have all the bells and whistles of the current classes. I loved that the slide went into the main pool(there were three) because it meant a big splash at the end. I have been on the Holiday class, Fantasy class, Triumph class, and Spirit class(hated it).

I have never been on a 4 or 5 day cruise that felt like a booze cruise. I wouldn't be bothered if it was. It would give me interesting stories to tell. I have cruised in February(4 day Bahamas and 4 day Cozumel), May(8 day Alaska), June(5 day Grand Cayman and Cozumel), August(4 day Baja Mexico), and December(5 day Progreso and Cozumel).

I don't need 5 days to get comfortable. I feel at home immediately after boarding.

I have never thought short cruises were exhausting. I have always found that I have plenty of time and energy between getting back on the ship and early assigned dining, even after an all day excursion.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature
Carnival Jubilee 6/15/02
Carnival Sensation 2/7/16
Carnival Inspiration 8/15/16
Carnival Fantasy 12/26/16
Carnival Triumph 2/9/17
Carnival Legend 5/8/17
Carnival Triumph 1/20/18
Carnival Dream 1/28/18
-------------------------------------------------
Carnival Sunshine 2/10/19
Carnival Valor 12/30/19
#19
3,855 Posts
Joined Jun 2014
If you haven’t cruised before you may want to start out with 5 days and work your way up to 7 days.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature



Carnival Dream 8/26/18
Carnival Breeze 3/4/18
Carnival Triumph 9/11/17
Carnival Freedom 2/18/17
Carnival Triumph 9/12/16
Carnival Elation 2/29/16
Carnival Elation 8/31/15
Carnival Elation 7/7/14
#20
Near Baltimore, MD
1,935 Posts
Joined Feb 2004
OP
I noted this was your first post, welcome to CC.
Have you ever taken the kids before on a cruise?
Have you ever been on a cruise before?
You might want to look at the itineraries. Sometimes you can pack a lot into a shorter cruise. If you can find a 5 night with great ports then, as a first cruise it would be a good idea. You do not know how anyone will be on a cruise.
If you have cruised before, then I would go with the longer one...if you can make the flight and time off work all work for you and your family.
I love the longer cruises and even the back-to-back (B2B) but I take my family alot and most of the younger children cannot take much more than a week.
YOU know your family the best. Have fun.
Expand Signature
Collapse Signature


Addicted to cruising and hope I never kick the habit!!!!