Help pick a new island!

[FloridaGram]

We have never been to the southern islands. I am looking at two cruises and would appreciate any help from others who have been there. One includes Antigua, Barbados and St. Lucia. The other includes Antigua, Barbados, Greneda and St Kitts. (in addition to the usual ports like St. Thomas)

 

So I guess my real question is St. Lucia vs Grenada and St. Kitts.Thanks for your input.

[blue_water]

St Lucia is beautiful and there is a great excursion that is 1/2 land-based and 1/2 cat sail with beach. But I would go with the other option because you get another island. St Kitt's has nice beaches and an island tour with a beach stop is a nice day. Or the cat over to Nevis is a very nice day. We haven't yet been to Grenada so that would be another reason for us to choose the Grenada and St Kitt's cruise.

Enjoy whatever you choose! :)