Jump to content

Recommended Posts

6 hours ago, pierces said:

 

I am doing some construction around the house and am using both power saws and occasionally hand saws. I am not sure, but I don't think that the wise fellow who designed the Ryoba pull saw would think the battery-powered circular saw was cheating. 

 

Sky replacer is a tool. Tools make stuff easier. Necessity may be the mother of invention but Lazy is its daddy!

 

🙂

 

Dave

 

You misunderstand me..... I don't feel like I'm cheating because I'm replacing the sky. I feel like it's cheating that it's SO EASY, compared to the difficult layers and masking of photoshop.

 

Let's play a game, which are Luminar skies, which are real Paris skies?

 

1:

48815269218_7d3b355816_k.jpguntitled (22 of 1308).jpg by Adam Brown, on Flickr

 

2:

49093392766_ca94f3edd9_k.jpguntitled (53 of 1308)_L by Adam Brown, on Flickr

 

3:

49092884303_6d64440231_k.jpguntitled (102 of 1308)_L by Adam Brown, on Flickr

 

4:

48815783892_aef7989588_k.jpguntitled (33 of 1308).jpg by Adam Brown, on Flickr

 

5:

49093600092_777ae23d6e_k.jpguntitled (192 of 1308)_L by Adam Brown, on Flickr

 

6:

48815291018_13bbaff746_k.jpguntitled (40 of 1308).jpg by Adam Brown, on Flickr

 

7:

49092888988_d1ddcc6246_k.jpguntitled (243 of 1308)_L by Adam Brown, on Flickr

 

 

Link to post
Share on other sites
8 hours ago, havoc315 said:

 

You misunderstand me..... I don't feel like I'm cheating because I'm replacing the sky. I feel like it's cheating that it's SO EASY, compared to the difficult layers and masking of photoshop.

 

Let's play a game, which are Luminar skies, which are real Paris skies?

 

1:

48815269218_7d3b355816_k.jpguntitled (22 of 1308).jpg by Adam Brown, on Flickr

 

2:

49093392766_ca94f3edd9_k.jpguntitled (53 of 1308)_L by Adam Brown, on Flickr

 

3:

49092884303_6d64440231_k.jpguntitled (102 of 1308)_L by Adam Brown, on Flickr

 

4:

48815783892_aef7989588_k.jpguntitled (33 of 1308).jpg by Adam Brown, on Flickr

 

5:

49093600092_777ae23d6e_k.jpguntitled (192 of 1308)_L by Adam Brown, on Flickr

 

6:

48815291018_13bbaff746_k.jpguntitled (40 of 1308).jpg by Adam Brown, on Flickr

 

7:

49092888988_d1ddcc6246_k.jpguntitled (243 of 1308)_L by Adam Brown, on Flickr

 

 

You misunderstood me! 🙂

 

I was agreeing with you. That sawmaker would have been overjoyed to have a tool capable of saving so much time and effort on a necessary but tedious part of his craft. 

 

In the short time I have had to play with Luminar 4, I'm pretty impressed with how far they've come in the last couple of years.

 

Dave

Link to post
Share on other sites
4 hours ago, pierces said:

You misunderstood me! 🙂

 

I was agreeing with you. That sawmaker would have been overjoyed to have a tool capable of saving so much time and effort on a necessary but tedious part of his craft. 

 

In the short time I have had to play with Luminar 4, I'm pretty impressed with how far they've come in the last couple of years.

 

Dave

 

13 hours ago, havoc315 said:

 

 

 

Let's play a game, which are Luminar skies, which are real Paris skies?

 

Can't really tell but they all look good to me!

 

 

 

Link to post
Share on other sites
5 hours ago, pierces said:

You misunderstood me! 🙂

 

I was agreeing with you. That sawmaker would have been overjoyed to have a tool capable of saving so much time and effort on a necessary but tedious part of his craft. 

 

In the short time I have had to play with Luminar 4, I'm pretty impressed with how far they've come in the last couple of years.

 

Dave

 

Honestly, my feelings are mixed. There isn't a good user manual, it's impossible to figure out some of the features and controls. For some reason, I wasn't able to get cropping to work -- I don't know if it's a bug.

I wasn't super impressed with the portrait enhancements.

 

I don't like the implementation of their clone stamp or their content-aware eraser. You don't see the effect of the content-aware eraser in real time as you use it. 

 

But generally, for landscapes, I'm impressed. Beyond the sky replacement, the AI enhancements usually come out pretty well. And the detail enhancements are better than lightroom. My only frustration is that Luminar doesn't seem to have built-in lens corrections for raw files. I may have to do my lens corrections in Lightroom and then export to Luminar for everything else. (And for now, I need to do cropping in Lightroom). 

 

Sky removal.... I still think ideally, you want to capture REAL beautiful skies. Shadows, etc, in the rest of the image won't really play naturally with a fake sky. Not to mention, things like -- in my Eiffel tower photo, the sun is setting in the south!

But when I get stuck with a totally overcast or a totally clear blue sky, I feel I'd want to use one of the more subtle fake skies.

If it's a picture of Notre Dame for example, I still want someone to look at it and say "what a beautiful picture of Notre Dame" -- Not, "wow, what a gorgeous sky over Notre Dame."

In other words, personally, I may use it to remove a boring element from a photo, but not to create a fake exciting element.

I feel like I achieved that balance in these examples -- except the Eiffel tower which I think went over the top.

 

Among the first 6 photos -- 3 have real skies, 3 have fake skies. The fact that you can't tell the difference is kudos to Luminar, but supports the way I hope to incorporate this tool into my workflow. 

 

I also will need to make a habit of shooting some custom skies of my own, so I'm not constantly using the same pre-set skies. 

 

 

 

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 3 weeks later...

I have a question for the Luminar users.  I am locked into the Adobe Lightroom / Photoshop combo for my own work, but I am looking at Luminar 4 as a Christmas gift for my brother.  He is looking for a way to organize his photos and I thought a program such as Liminar would do the trick for him without having to deal with a subscription plus it looks like a relatively powerful, easy to use editor.  I have read reviews and everything in this thread, but I haven't actually heard anyone say much about the cataloging capabilities except for the speed issues, I can't even find much detail on the Luminar website.  My question is how does it compare to the Lightroom catalog capabilities.  I see it has star ratings, but does it have keywords and other ways to filter you photos like Lightroom does?  Thanks for your help.

Dave

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 1 month later...
On 12/9/2019 at 2:39 PM, DCB9 said:

I have a question for the Luminar users.  I am locked into the Adobe Lightroom / Photoshop combo for my own work, but I am looking at Luminar 4 as a Christmas gift for my brother.  He is looking for a way to organize his photos and I thought a program such as Liminar would do the trick for him without having to deal with a subscription plus it looks like a relatively powerful, easy to use editor.  I have read reviews and everything in this thread, but I haven't actually heard anyone say much about the cataloging capabilities except for the speed issues, I can't even find much detail on the Luminar website.  My question is how does it compare to the Lightroom catalog capabilities.  I see it has star ratings, but does it have keywords and other ways to filter you photos like Lightroom does?  Thanks for your help.

Dave

 

 

Sorry! I completely missed this post.

 

It may be too late, but if your brother. Luminar is pretty good as a cataloging app. It is easy to organize folders and allows for some pretty complete editing, though not to the extent of Lightroom.

 

Recommended. With some caveats previously discussed here...and in the next post.

 

Dave

Link to post
Share on other sites

---------------------------
Luminar 4
---------------------------
OpenGL 3.3 and later is required for this application to run.
Try updating your graphics drivers.
---------------------------
OK   
---------------------------

 

Here is my experience with Luminar 4 on my new desktop. Extra special. No detailed method on the Skylum forums on how to correct it other than get the newest driver (my RTX 2070 has Open GL 4.something) and see you card manufacturer's site to learn how to set Luminar 18 to the default GPU. In case you haven't guessed, the manufacturers are generally oblivious to the existence of Luminar.

 

Researching.

 

For the record, Lightroom and Photoshop installed seamlessly.

 

Dave

Link to post
Share on other sites

I reset the Windows 10 installation with the option of apps removed and files left in place. Reinstalled the graphics driver and it fixed the OpenGL fatal error. Not a huge issue since I had only transferred files and installed a few programs.

 

Luminar now starts and runs very nicely. 

 

Only 999,999 things left to do....

 

 

Dave

 

Link to post
Share on other sites
  • 7 months later...

Another year...another Luminar.

 

Luminar AI is up for preorder and at this rate, It is hovering about even with my subscription to Lightroom over the same period. So much for the evil big-tech plot to skim our money with subscription business models.

 

I still use Luminar rarely since there is still absolutely no way to migrate a bazillion non-destructive edits from Lightroom. Again I'll state that just exporting all my photos with adjustments applied and maintaining a separate space for the old unretouched versions isn't an option I'll pursue. I could bite the bullet and just accept the changes made and move forward from this point on, but the combination of Lightroom and Photoshop still provides more basic organizational and editing power. If I didn't have years of experience in both and was starting from scratch, the story might be different. Luminar lacks much of the organizational power of Lightroom, but for a user with no need or desire for detailed keywording and facial recognition (Lightroom is a bit stupid on faces), the ease of use and automated retouching with "looks" can make digital life easier. I am also a bit put off by the creative direction Luminar is going with image manipulation. The pre-order trailer video was big on improving your "like" count on social media and lean on detail but the rest of the page hints at features to add atmosphere, alter body and facial features like Anthropics Portrait Pro and of course, change the sky from the one you took to the one someone else took and sold you in a bundle for $45 on a special introductory price. For me, capturing a great sky is like finding a shiny gold nugget in a stream bed. Buying a nugget just doesn't feel as good. 🙂

 

Again, much of my reluctance to adopt Luminar is from being not only invested in the Adobe environment but my personal preference for mostly realistic photography without all the added replacements and effects. If this appeals to you and you don't have thousands of non-destructive edits in a Lightroom database, Luminar is reasonably priced, powerful and offers some pretty good and rather powerful image editing tools. Paid upgrades and add-on packs can add up over time, but if you aren't blown away by the new bells and whistles, skipping an upgrade cycle is a money saving option.

 

Since it is only $79, I'll probably give the AI version a look and if I do, will outline my experience here.

 

Take a look for yourself: https://skylum.com/luminar-ai

 

Happy Shooting!

 

 

Dave

Edited by pierces
Link to post
Share on other sites

I've been having a lot of fun with the product, adding some cool skies to pictures that are otherwise a bit flat.  Like any technique (especially HDR processing, which people use to excess) it's possible to have too much of a good thing, but for everyday manipulations it's a blast.

 

A couple of "before and after" examples - 

 

"Grandfather Looses the Ponies," a sculpture commemorating the region's wild horses, set on a clifftop overlooking the Columbia River in central Washington state:

 

20130409_42-27Jul-psp.jpg

 

20130409_42lum-27-Jul-01psp.jpg

 

Mont Saint-Michel (base image)

 

20100824_13b-1.jpg

 

20100824_13b3.jpg

 

20100824_13b2.jpg

 

While dramatic, these illustrate (to me at least) that one has to limit the use of this, especially in the case of backlit scenes or when the foreground is going to be very different from the sky in terms of luminescence and tint.  For example, in the last image you can see what looks like fill light on the side of the Mont, inexplicable given the strong sunset background sky.  It's nothing that can't be fixed in some further processing (I haven't bothered for this post) but you can see what I'm talking about.

 

Still, it's a blast to transform some otherwise meh images.

Link to post
Share on other sites

Well, it looks like they want people to upgrade. My previous purchases qualified me for a $59 for one or $69 for a two user deal. 

 

I'm officially on the pre-order list and will be commenting on what I find when it magically appears in my inbox.

 

I may also have my darling granddaughter install it on her laptop and share impressions from a newbie to photo organization and editing.

 

Dave 

Link to post
Share on other sites
22 hours ago, pierces said:

 

 

I'm officially on the pre-order list and will be commenting on what I find when it magically appears in my inbo

 

Dave 

 

With the stay-in-place orders, probably all offers look good - something to do!

 

So I ordered the AI version.

Look forward to your comments!

 

Stay well!

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Forum Jump
    • Categories
      • Forum Assistance
      • Q&A with Chris Prelog, President of Windstar Cruises!
      • Register Now for Cruise Critic Live Special Event: Royal Caribbean
      • New Cruisers
      • Cruise Lines “A – O”
      • Cruise Lines “P – Z”
      • River Cruising
      • ROLL CALLS
      • Digital Photography & Cruise Technology
      • Special Interest Cruising
      • Cruise Discussion Topics
      • UK Cruising
      • Australia & New Zealand Cruisers
      • North American Homeports
      • Ports of Call
      • Cruise Conversations
×
×
  • Create New...