Jump to content
Cruise Critic Community
cruisinisforme

Just returned from 2 weeks on the edge

Recommended Posts

I just spent two weeks on this ship, the first week in a concierge club and the second in a sky suite. I've seen a lot of negative reviews on the ship, some I agree with some I do not. Personally I feel a cruise is a cruise and even with problems you should be able to enjoy yourself. I also think we are all different people and see things in our own way. A great example is several people in my group went to Eden for dinner and absolutely loved it, in fact some went back. Then others in our group did not like it at all. Same thing with the infinite verandahs. Personally they are not for me and most of our group agreed with that, but I talked to many people on the ship who loved them and booked the ship again. So it is all a matter of you like not what someone else like.

I think the ship is beautiful but designed poorly. The chairs at the pool bar are so high you cant get on them unless you are really tall. The chairs at the sky bar are the same way, the martini bar half the chairs you slide off if you sit in them and the other half are shorter and ok but getting seats at the bar is a prize that most people cannot do since there are not many chairs. The first week on the ship we never got to the bar once but the second week we did (mostly because we did dinner on off hours so people were not there when we got there)

 

I loved the big mail pool area and just one pool, I never found it crowded at all. I missed the lack of bars and lounges, the reason the martini bar is so crowded is because in the evening there is no other choice. The staff on this ship did an incredible job even with all the difficulties they faced. There were so many exceptional staff members it would be hard to name them all.

The second week I was in a suite, we loved the retreat area pool, I wish it was not in the front of the ship because it made it very windy, but it was never crowded and almost seemed like you were on the ship with just a few people instead of many.

 

There are still a lot of issues to work out, the first week in concierge cabins we had a pipe break outside one of the cabins and there was a sewer smell they had to fix, the second week another cabin had shower issues and had to be moved. I absolutely do not like that the captain gets to choose when the window opens. It was closed more than it was open even when we were in port, dont tell me i have a balcony window when I dont. We were leaving an island and it was so calm out yet they wouldnt allow the windows to be open.

 

I went to the rooftop garden when we were in port in san juan, what an absolutely wonderful experience it was and the meal was excellent, but with that said the week before dinner was cancelled more than it was on because of winds, so you never know if you are going to dinner or not there.

 

I ate at all of the main dining room restaurants and loved them. air conditioning problems a couple of nights made dinner very hot but the meals were still good. I loved the steak house and went 3 times in 2 weeks. I also went to Le Petit I, myself, was very disappointed my meat was very undercooked and I did not like the show, but that is because I have seen the other show and loved it much better. On the reflection and silhouette our dinner choices were lobster and filet mignon but on this ship it is chicken and strip steak, a lot of people cancelled it when they saw the menu.

The air condtioning on the ship wasnt great, and that was in all our rooms, it said 66 on the thermostat but my BIL actually had a clock that kept the temp and it said 71 and I believe it, it seemed warm in all of our rooms all the time and we had 22 rooms so it wasnt just one room.

 

I dont want to sound negative about this ship, I had a great two weeks and was sad to go home. Yes there were things I did not like but we just made the best of it and moved on. I just didnt like the infinite verandahs and would not book them again, to us it was a glorified oceanview and I was so happy the second week to get into the suite with a regular balcony.

Oh I just remembered, they did something very odd with the new balcony doors. When you go outside you no longer have the ability to close the door with the latch, you just push the door closed which makes an annoying whistlining sound on both sides. It can only be closed from the inside. And we met a couple in the retreat who told us her husband was reading a book when the room steward came in, he asked to clean the room and he said yes and when he was done he closed the door, since you cant open it from the outside the man was stuck on his balcony until his wife came back 25 minutes later.

 

I am sure there is more i can say I guess the best thing I can say is go on the ship yourself and make your own opinions. Good or bad you will still have a good time. We met lots of wonderful people both weeks and I gladly would have stayed another week

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, cruisinisforme said:

Personally I feel a cruise is a cruise and even with problems you should be able to enjoy yourself.

 

1 hour ago, cruisinisforme said:

Yes there were things I did not like but we just made the best of it and moved on.

Great review and thanks. However with the premium you are paying for this ship right now I can't agree with the above...it should be a flawless experience not just acceptable cause it's a cruise. If a cruise is just a cruise then you can accomplish that at less than half the cost on any another ship.

Edited by bajathree

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Thanks for your balanced review.  I was on the ship in January and while I had a wonderful cruise and thought the ship was beautiful, there were some areas for improvement.  I am so glad that you mentioned the AC.  Our Sky Suite was always warm.  The thermostat was set to 66 but I also have a clock with a thermostat in it and it was consistently reading 71 degrees which, in my opinion, is much too warm to be comfortable.  A few times it would dip to 69 but then within an hour it was reading 71 again.  

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

We were on the NY Eve cruise in a sky suite.  So much better then the Infinite balcony we originally had.  We were fortunate and able to upgrade once on board.  Didn't like the huge rocking chair and lack of a real table in the suite or balcony.  Loved the suite deck- but the cost of even an entry level suite is high.

 

We enjoyed the steak house and le petite chef-but didn't like the food or strange characters walking around eden this isn't Disney- never again. 

 

We will be on the Edge again- in a sky suite in about one year when the rates go down.  We have also booked an aft balcony cabin as the infinite balcony is really an outside cabin with a window that may or may not open.

 

While our AC experience was fine, the ship had a horrible waste smell near the martini bar a few days- clearly they have a problem with that system.

 

Thanks for sharing.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 2/4/2019 at 8:49 AM, bajathree said:

 

Great review and thanks. However with the premium you are paying for this ship right now I can't agree with the above...it should be a flawless experience not just acceptable cause it's a cruise. If a cruise is just a cruise then you can accomplish that at less than half the cost on any another ship.

I dont disagree with that, we certainly paid more for this ship then any sailing I have in a long time, most of it was about the hype and unless the prices come down significantly I wont be back.  I can go on a 10 night reflection in a suite for less then 7 nights on the edge or apex and I would rather do that.  I have heard they are making significant changes to the apex, which will help with a lot of things, but it is still too high priced for me too

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, cruisinisforme said:

I have heard they are making significant changes to the apex, which will help with a lot of things, 

May we ask what things?

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

We are sailing in a sky suite 10267 which has the oversized balcony. The negative I’ve read is that there are no lounge chairs on the balcony. Can you request loungers on the oversized balconies?

 

great review 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Excellent review. I think you captured the reality of EDGE.. We were only on for 7 days in AQ,  but going back with a real balc in Nov. We did not mind the IV  but  a real balc is preferred!

 

Wonder if anyone knows why AC and sewer systems are not operating as well as expected??? It is a new ship and should be  at peak performance.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now

  • Forum Jump
    • Categories
      • SAIL-AWAY GIVEAWAY - Enter for a chance to win a $3,000 Norwegian Cruise Line Gift Card
      • Forum Assistance
      • New Cruisers
      • Cruise Lines “A – O”
      • Cruise Lines “P – Z”
      • River Cruising
      • ROLL CALLS
      • Digital Photography & Cruise Technology
      • Member Cruise Reviews
      • Special Interest Cruising
      • Cruise Discussion Topics
      • UK Cruising
      • Australia & New Zealand Cruisers
      • North American Homeports
      • Ports of Call
      • Cruise Conversations
×
×
  • Create New...