Jump to content

Review - Magic 8 Day Maarten/Kitts/San Juan/ Grand Turk - Steakhouse and Excursions

Recommended Posts

Just back from our 8th cruise with Carnival.  Didn't take my computer with us this time because I was determined I wasn't going to fight with the wifi to do any work so I'll put a review and synopsis together over multiple posts.  All in all we had a good time and will certainly be cruising again.  Had a few things that I'll mention that we'd change or avoid given the opportunity to do it again.  We had a cove mid-ship, late dinning, and did the steak house.  Our group was 12 total and always had something to do!

We live in Central Florida so we didn't have to deal with flights or transfers.  Other than Port Canaveral, we always go down the evening before and this time was no different.  Since it was Super Bowl weekend, rooms were scarce when we started looking about 7-8 months out!  We couldn't figure out what the issue was and finally did a search for Miami and the dates and it became obvious.  We were going out of Ft Lauderdale but best room that wasn't crazy expensive was an hour north near West Palm.  It was a Best Western that was fine for the price.  We had hoped to sit by the pool and order in a pizza.  It rained all night and the only chairs for our group of 10 that drove down was in the lobby so we ate fairly quick and then headed to rooms.

With no place for the group to gather, we ate breakfast and headed to the port.  We had planned to get there early anyway since we'd rather wait in port than staring at a hotel wall and we were glad that we did.  Getting to the port was easy, and luggage drop off went great.  Since we had 10 people and 2 cars the plan was to drop luggage and 8 people at the curb, park, and then meet up for check in.  Luggage drop went fine, but we didn't realize that the parking garage that we dropped luggage right next to the ship wasn't the garage we would park in.  That garage is still under construction so we ended up headed out of that garage and then around to the other side to park in the existing garage.  It was pretty busy and the signage was limited at best. Took a wrong turn but finally found a place.  Then the signage got worse on the way back to the check in terminal but we eventually met up with the others.  To get from the garage you walk through scaffolding and gates and come in from the backside of the terminal and then we had to walk against the line of people trying to get on the ship to get to the end of the line.

Check in went super easy.  We used passports and boarding passes and breezed right through.  We didn't pack and soda because we had Cheers and Bubbles.  2 in our group that flew in brought some soda in cans and they never even opened his backpack to check what it was.  In other ports we've been required to each carry one bottle of wine through so they could match the person with the bottle.  This time we just sent the two bottles through and the adults weren't together.  All in all they didn't seem nearly as picky as some of the other terminals we've used so the line kept moving and we were done in no time.  Our boarding check in time was I believe 12:30-1.  We met up after parking at just after 10:30 and were on the Lido with a drink at 11:03.  As we walked though the end of security they did an all call for all zones.  Had we been about 2 minutes earlier we could have beat the 'rush' since our boarding number was part of the group already called and we ended up behind the terminal of people that were after our zone.  BUT, to be on Lido at 11:00 and had already dropped bags off in a cabin that was platinum was great.  The whole process (other than parking and meeting back up with our group) was great and very efficient.

We used our paper boarding passes for drinks and headed to Cucina for a sit down lunch.  They didn't open until noon so we found a spot to sit and waited knowing that we didn't have anywhere to be for the next 8 days.  It was nice to have a sit down, get waiting on, lunch for a group of our size.  As we were being seated the other 2 that flew in met up with us and we were all 12 able to sit at the same table.  Doing that in lido at noon would have been a challenge.  We walked back down through there after lunch and it was of course packed.  I don't know how we would have found a place with a couple of tables near each other.  The food in Cucina was decent.  We never ended up back there again for lunch or dinner.  The ability to sit, out of the way of the crowd, and actually talk to everyone was nice so we'd do that again probably.  There are always plenty of food options and we ended up filling up on pizza before we sailed away.


Our bags were delivered before muster and we had everything unpacked well before we had to report for the drill.  This was the first time that we had to actually check in with our keys for attendance and maybe that helped to speed up the process.  It went quickly and easily and was over before we knew it.  We are so thankful they changed long ago from going down to get your vests, meet in the meeting point, put the vests on, then go outside on deck!


I'll put together some more thoughts through the next couple of days.  We have some of the FunTimes but they are available online too.  We didn't get them delivered to the cabin every day and just used our phone most of the time anyway.  I'll share our excursions that we booked direct in St Maarten, St Kitts and Grand Turk.  We also did the steakhouse and might have a few pictures from there.  Did most of the shows and I'll put some thoughts together about entertainment, service, and everything overall!

Link to post
Share on other sites

Came back with some sort of a head cold and low grade fever, guess I should have been taking the immune supplements even on the ship and when I got home.  I noticed it some about mid-week and thought maybe it was just allergies but it’s getting the better of me now for sure.

The first two days on this itinerary were sea days.  Sea days then have sea day brunch on the menu too.  Most of our group actually preferred the port day breakfast menu.  We sampled quite a bit from the brunch menu on our three days total.  The crowd favorite was the chia seed parfait and I’m going to try and find the recipe to recreate that at home.  It seemed a lot like an overnight oats type of thing that would be easy to make in a batch and take to work.  Breakfast service was decent but always seemed painfully slow every morning.  It didn’t matter if it was a port or sea day, it was just slow.  We only did the lido buffet for breakfast one morning and that was our first port day in St Maarten because we had to meet the excursion early.

As for the ship on sea days, there was plenty to do.  Of course, if you didn’t get to the pool by some silly hour the chairs were gone, so we worked around that.  We were able to find enough room up near the slides on 12 that still could see the activities on 10 and provided a little shade too.  Our favorite spot on sea days was probably 5 forward on the shade side of the ship.  There were literally dozens of loungers sitting empty with nobody around.  On 5 you wouldn’t really expect any bar service and there wasn’t any, but overall it was normally difficult to find a bar server even in the busier parts of 10-12 and often even the showroom.  Back in the day it seemed like there was a conga line of people with the drink of the day and that isn’t the case any longer.  This was actually something that we noticed in a lot of places on the ship and I’ve seen it mentioned before.  The crew to guest ratio seems to have changed fairly significantly.  It wasn’t uncommon for it to be 2 guests deep at the Red Frog or Blue Iguana on lido and just 2 or 3 bar tenders taking order as best they could.  I thought on a number of occasions that it would be helpful to have a well or pass at each bar for walk up service so that everyone would be in a line.  I noticed a lot of aggravated people that felt like they were there before someone else that got served but the bartender really didn’t have any way of knowing what was what based on the crowd of people looking for a drink.

OH! On the first day I believe before we even left port the Red Frog Pub was doing happy hour.  We had seen that posted in a few places and it didn't really impact us because we did the Cheers! package.  We stopped by to see what was happening and it was like Black Friday at a big box store with $199 big screen televisions.  It was no less that 3 people deep at the bar and crazy loud with everyone trying to get bottled beers.  People were walking out with 3-5 buckets per passenger and heading back to their cabins with them.  We actually passed someone walking out with an entire case, still in the cardboard.  If you aren't doing Cheers and drink bottled beer, you may want to consider fighting the crowds to stock up on half price beer before you set sail!

In the past we played bingo a few times each cruise before the show or whatever.  We only played once this time and realized the odds vs the payout has changed significantly.  The game we played I believe it was a $125 and $250 payout.  The final game was a $2000 payout… and then when he claimed his bingo they brought him up on stage to throw corn hole bags and would pay per bag that was in the hole.  They helped and pushed some in for him anyway so he didn’t go away with nothing, it just seemed a little deceptive.  Also, if you didn’t get your cards early in the day, they would “sell out” of the $20 packets and only had the $40/$60 available.  I just can’t see putting $40/$60 on the line in hopes of $125 with a few hundred cards in play!

Link to post
Share on other sites
3 hours ago, jdcml said:

Came back with some sort of a head cold and low grade fever, guess I should have been taking the immune supplements even on the ship and when I got home.  I noticed it some about mid-week and thought maybe it was just allergies but it’s getting the better of me now for sure.



Thank you for reporting your cruise experiences and hope you feel better soon!

Link to post
Share on other sites
On 2/11/2020 at 6:27 PM, Valor2005 said:

Tell me about the half-price beers in the Red Frog.  Is it all beers or just Red Frog?  

Pretty sure all beers, but only at the Red Frog Pub.  There are 2 Youtube videos by High Seas Cindy that show it.  They said it was available when they first got on board, and from 3-5 daily. The sign says 50% of all Caribbean Cocktails and Beer.


Very much excited to hear a more recent account, since I'll be going in May and will be trying to get some cheap drinks.

Link to post
Share on other sites

We were on the Magic this past October.  Same itinerary.  It's amazing that your observations are mine as well.  


Embarkation was extremely easy. Fast and efficient.  I had 4 bottles of wine in my carry on luggage and not one question about it.  


Service at the bars for the entire weak was SLOW SLOW SLOW.  No fault of the crew, there just wasn't enough of them.     Getting a server to take a drink order outside of the bar was non-existent.     It didn't effect my trip in any way whatsoever.  But having five CCL cruises and one RCI cruise under my belt, I'd never had this experience before.  Typically you can sit and listen to the band and someone will come along and take your drink order.  Not on the Magic.


Overall, one of my favorite ships so far.  In fact, we are scheduled for her sister ship, the Breeze, in September.  

Link to post
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Forum Jump
    • Categories
      • Forum Assistance
      • SPECIAL EVENT: Q&A with Barbara Muckermann, CMO Silversea Cruises
      • ICYM Our Cruise Critic Live Special Event: Explore the Remote World with Hurtigruten!
      • Q&A with the Quark Expeditions Team: New Ship Ultramarine
      • New Cruisers
      • Cruise Lines “A – O”
      • Cruise Lines “P – Z”
      • River Cruising
      • ROLL CALLS
      • Digital Photography & Cruise Technology
      • Special Interest Cruising
      • Cruise Discussion Topics
      • UK Cruising
      • Australia & New Zealand Cruisers
      • Canadian Cruisers
      • North American Homeports
      • Ports of Call
      • Cruise Conversations
  • Create New...