Which itenarary would you pick?

[cellfree]

First or second one, 8 days a plus, along with great ports, either one would be a good choice.

First one will have more days at sea, perhaps that would be your deciding factor, either more days at sea or an extra port day.

 

[alpha0meqa]

Thank you so much to everyone. I was almost certain everyone would pick Mardi Gras, as it's the newest ship. Definitely surprised there. I think we will go with the consensus and try out the ABC route #1 on the Horizon.
 

Honestly having been on 4 cruises, I have not been THAT impressed with the locations I've been to (Cozumel, Grand Turk, Nassau, Falmouth(Jamaica), and Grand Cayman. They all seemed to blend together mostly. We usually do tours though and swimming with dolphins once.

 

We will have a 2yr+4yr old with us at the time, so excursions may be hard to do. We are excited either way for our first family cruise :).