I remember asking the waiter when using our platinum voucher if I could exchange my dessert option for 2 starters. He said sure, but when it came time or order dessert he was willing to throw it in as well.I didn't take him up on his offer because I was too full. On another cruise, different ship I was charged extra $2 for surf and turf in Cagney's and the waiter wasn't even pleasant about it> I think it does vary from ship to ship.