Krystal or Secrets Vallarta Bay in Puerto Vallarta?

We are cruising in 3 weeks and have narrowed our P.V. beach day down to either Krystal or Secrets, which I believe may now be called Amber??? There are 7 of us travelling total ~ 5 adults and 2 young children.

Based off what I've read, Krystal no longer allows entrance to cruise passengers at no charge, purchase food and drink, but does not require a taxi ride. Amber/Secrets requires a taxi ride and I figure will cost about $25.00 more per person for the true all-inclusive everything.... I am leaning more towards Secrets... but would love to know what other fellow CC'rs think! Thank you.

My group is interested in doing Secrets also, but I reached out and have not heard anything back yet (it's been a couple of weeks since I emailed them). Have you been in contact with anyone from there? Here is the email address I sent an inquiry to: info.sevpv@secretsresorts.com. Trying to find someplace we can book in advance as we have a large group.

Thanks for any info!