Ryanvoice100

Hi all please help. Am so stuck with a first world problem. We have 2 options and the price would be similar. What would you choose and why?

1:
Flights gatwick to barbados return

Week in Barbados at St Lawrence gap area bed and breakfast

Week marella cruise on discovery with balcony

Barbados
San juan
Charlotte amalie
Frederiksted
Guadaloupe

St vincent

Barbados

Pros:

-week in Barbados included for very little upcharge turning it to a two week hol

-All inclusive cruise Inc drinks

Cons:

-Older and smaller ship. No big wow factor

-Ports don't seem as appealing from researching Internet 
£4500

2:

Flights heathrow to miami return

10 night cruise on enchanted princess Balcony

Miami
Princess Cays
St. Thomas
Antigua
Dominica
Martinique
St. Lucia
Miami


Pros:

-Bigger ship with more wow factor

-Better food shows and entertainment

-Better ports

Negs:

-Shorter trip for same cost

-No stay before or after cruise

-No drinks package Inc but works out same cost as other trip if adding drinks package

£4600

Help please, what would you choose and why