Magen's Bay is absolutely gorgeous! Be sure to see it from the higher elevation first. I have never been to the other beaches you mention but I don't think you will be disappointed with Magen. Hills on both sides surrounding the cove, pelicans diving in the water, rocks on the left side, cactus. We went twice in October with no crowds.
Megan's Bay vs. Coki Beach
in St. Thomas/St. John
Posted
Magen's Bay is absolutely gorgeous! Be sure to see it from the higher elevation first. I have never been to the other beaches you mention but I don't think you will be disappointed with Magen. Hills on both sides surrounding the cove, pelicans diving in the water, rocks on the left side, cactus. We went twice in October with no crowds.