Nassau & Half Moon Cay vs St. Thomas & San Juan

Hello!

Brand new here. I am looking at booking a cruise for our honeymoon and there are 2 cruise options. Both visit Grand Turk but the other 2 stops are different so which would you recommend?

Nassau and Half Moon Cay

OR

St. Thomas and San Juan

Thanks for any and all input!

So this is just my opinion, but I'm not a huge fan of Nassau. It feels dirty and run down. Half Moon is gorgeous for a beach day. St. Thomas is one of my favorites islands. I can't wait to go back again. I also had a lot of fun in San Juan. If I had the option I would choose St. Thomas and San Juan. Hands down. Both beautiful and a lot of fun things to do. Oh, and Congratulations!

Nassau is nice and beautiful you have the option to pay to to Atlantis but St. Thomas and San Juan are two of my favs.

For me it would be 100% San Juan and St Thomas. No comparison in my opinion.