Caye Caulker or Goff's Caye

Which would you say is the better spent day? Caye Caulker or Goff's Caye? Or other? How did you get to the Caye and what was your experience there for the day?

We used the public water taxi to get to Caye Chaulker. Didn't like the walk to get to the water taxi. It was confusing and we were bombarded by vendors. Caye Chaulker was an okay day and a long day (45 minutes each way plus tendering in and back again to the ship). We wouldn't do it again because it wasn't worth the trouble.

How much is the water taxi?