Thanks for the input, everyone! We've cruised many times in the past and the ports of call are very important - we love to explore all the different beaches. From the sounds of it, I think we'll go with the Magic. We like the 8 day length too!
I'm looking at two different cruises for 2023 - I know, a long time out! Here are the two: Carnival Magic - 8 day - Grand Turk, San Juan, St Kitts, St Maarten Carnival Mardi Gras - 7 day - Grand Turk, Amber Cove, San Juan The prices of the two are almost the same. Of the two, which would you do and why? I'm very interested in info on Amber Cove and St Kitts as I've never been to either of those two island.