We just got off a cruise on the Edge where we were in a suite. In the past we have stayed in both suite and AQ cabins, all on S class ships. In the past in Luminae we were given menus from the MD and if I remember correctly Blu and ordered from all. On the Edge we were told that since the Luminae kitchen was too far from the others we could only order from Luminae menu. On the second day we asked to see the dinner menu after breakfast. As we looked at it my husband said he didn't see anything that appealed to him. The hostess said no problem - feel free to eat at Blu or MD if you prefer.