I stayed in an S1 cabin on deck 12 below the magic carpet on the Edge this summer on a Mediterranean voyage. They would clean the Magic Carpet at 3:00am on several nights (not all) and it was very noisy and kept us up. We are traveling on the Apex in March and have booked an S1 on the opposite side on the ship on the 10th floor so we don't experience this again. The S1 on the 12th floor also has the magic carpet directly above you which impacts the view and the amount of light in the room. I would stay away from the Magic Carpet.