We've sailed the Glory once and sister ships four more times, Magic twice and Breeze (also a sister ship) three times. I'd choose the Magic. She has similar amenities but a little bit more to offer. Magic has a better lido experience (good for kids), plus the seating outside the Red Frog is great to watch the stars. Also Cucina del Capitano has amazing food and service for a nominal fee at dinner. Glory has a better experience for watching movies under the stars. It depends what you like. Depending on your budget, the cove balconies on the Magic are perfect - no better place for me to sit, relax and read while my hubby and daughter take a nap. That being said, wherever would be less stressful as a home port matters too. I live in Florida and the home port plays a big part of my decision. Even though I prefer the Magic, I'd choose the Glory if I knew it would be less stressful for the trip to and from the port. You'll have a great time no matter which one you choose!